are judges being too harsh on toshi - Page 3

Originally posted by: melonheads

Toshi's Omkara and Naino renditions were as perfect as one could get. yet the judges picked on some minute points and made a meal of it. he didnt get straight 10s as well.

in comparison others have made similar mistakes and have got away with straight 10s.

Yeah, totally! It feels like as if they have some personal enmity going on with him! He is criticised to an extend where one would just feel quitting! The way they are giving numbers 9 and 10 to everyone that I have started to believe that these numbers don't have any significance! Debo got 9's for flat rendition of saiyaan yet Toshi was given similar marks for excelling 'Naino'. It appears to me that the judges have lost the plot!!!!🤢

Originally posted by: Atlee99

I dont agree...if u think judges r being harsh to Toshi.
Judges have been even more harsh with Harshit in 2 episodes, one being in the comedy but he had taken the critisism very positively and came back with a bang of 30s. Toshi is not able to do that ....Judges werent very nice to Amey on his first episode and either to Rahul after his first performance but they have all taken it as a challenge and worked on the problems...I think becos u r a Toshi fan u r being biased to him
PS I am not a diehard fan of anyone and my views r restricted to their performances in JJWS only

Very well said. I feel Toshi's best performance is yet to come on this show and there are others who are siging better than him consistently. I do not think judges are super-harsh on him. He needs to take the constructive critcism related to his singing positively like others do.

Originally posted by: Gauri_3

Very well said. I feel Toshi's best performance is yet to come on this show and there are others who are siging better than him consistently. I do not think judges are super-harsh on him. He needs to take the constructive critcism related to his singing positively like others do.

Agree with you both. 😃

Originally posted by: koolgal_anisha

toshi is also scoring 9's on 10 is dat a low score???😕😕😕 if it is ..thn wow i wanna have such low scores too😆 i'll be more than happie u know..!!

lemme give u a recent example. Deb got 9/10/9 for Saiyyan which he didnt even sing in the sufi style. I mean the entire feel of the song is lost [u gotcha hear toshi's rendition in SVOI]. compared this with Toshi's Omkara where he got the same marks.

So you see the bias now???