**Aneek Dhar: JJWS2 Links/Appreciation Thread** - Page 4

Hey Haaru, any news about Aneek's performance this week. Good to see you dear, don't wait this long to come on IF. 😊

Here is Aneek singing a Rafi song.

Originally posted by: bellevue

Here is Aneek singing a Rafi song.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ae0Xv9_-imo&feature=relmfu

Mgal, this video is from 2011 bangla little champs when he was hosting the show. I think he is one singer who sings Rafi, Manna Dey ji's songs so beautifully.

Originally posted by: bellevue

Mgal, this video is from 2011 bangla little champs when he was hosting the show. I think he is one singer who sings Rafi, Manna Dey ji's songs so beautifully.

You are right dear, he received the best anchor award for the show!

I am not good in judging when comes to technical part but i enjoyed the way Aneek sang Tum Pukar Lo hemant dada song and it was good one.

God bless and keep the great work going.

With best wishes,

Mgal

Originally posted by: Malaysian_Girl

I am not good in judging when comes to technical part but i enjoyed the way Aneek sang Tum Pukar Lo hemant dada song and it was good one.

God bless and keep the great work going.

With best wishes,

Mgal

Hey there Mgal. 😊 I just heard his performance and i did enjoy it very much. I edited this post so many times, trying to find middle ground, trying to be diplomatic but it's not working out. 😆 Even if the judges didn't like the key he sang in, what sort of reasoning is that to remove him from the champs side? He didn't forget lyrics, he sang in tune and with lots of feeling. So what's the problem?

I really don't understand the role these so called mentors have on the show. 😕 They only speak up and give feedback to the singers after the fact, after they sing their songs and while the scores are being given. If a champion or challenger mentor recognizes something that the singer is doing wrong (such as setting a song in the wrong key or in a key that may reduce the impact of a song) they should mention it to them during practice. Judges give feedback and scores but a "mentor" should stand behind the singer through the entire process from song selection to performance. I am not just saying this because of what happened with Aneek today. Another contestant that could have benefited from assistance was Shivam. Somehow, either he wasn't choosing songs that fit his vocal abilities and if only his mentor could have suggested something more suitable, he could have still been in the show. If the channel arbitrarily chooses songs and the mentors have no say, they can at least pitch in when the song is being aranged an practiced.