Jhanak Written Update And Episode Discussion thread No "101" - Page 29

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Problem is, sometimes things need to be shown explicitly...ye karma aur poetic justice don't feel justified or appealing all the time...makers should explicitly show everyone has left Arshi and she is suffering due to her crimes...why every time we, viewers have to decipher the events?? Cumon..this is a tv show ..Indian tv show...GOt level show nahi hai where some layerings will be there and fans will decipher it...most audience of these desi shows are common people who watch them for entertainment...unko dimag nahi lagana hota hai ke achha dekho poetic justice mili hai...unless makers point it out explicitly that Arshi is paying for her crimes, it doesn't serve any purpose.

Poetic justice kya hain? J standing on beck and call is poetic justice?

Originally posted by: PPak

Dibya did not expect this from you? :)

From day 1 no one is clear or nothing is clear. We have discussed it many times. Leena runs on ambiguity; everyone is kept discussing who is right or wrong when there is no one clear answer. She is creating a chaotic tale based on kismat vs marzi. External forces vs one's choice/will; thats why Ani's dialogs are always trying to point to her grand story plotline. The issue was Ani's of J's choices were not well crafted as out of control for her story basis - rather they appeared like they were made by choice.

Nothing will be shown explicitly. The best is to hope for Arshi's death and no coma.

The thing about poetic justice was mentioned here first time by me only, I guess..my point is...such shows are not made for audience like us, who analyse the story using our own understanding...the niche audience do not use that much of brains for a show they watch for entertainment...so whatever is happening with Arshi, they will not think that she is being punished as she has to go through painful delivery...it has to be made explicit...anyway, we have gone past that stage where any analysis mattered regarding the characters...coz, clearly, Leena is playing on expediency only...koi logical depth bach hi nahi analyse karne k liye...and no Arshi will not die...makers were very clear from the beginning that Arshi is a very important character in the tale...and as the show progressed, they have literally made her forced lead...so don't expect she is going anywhere.

Originally posted by: sanfan

Poetic justice kya hain? J standing on beck and call is poetic justice?

Filhaal to there's no justice...since the baby is already shown to be born..and Ani also never questioned how did he become a father despite asking time from Arshi to proceed..

...in my pov, one poetic justice I found was when Srishti tried burning K and in return burnt her own daughter ..bure karmo ka fal...uske baad se I don't remember any straight forward justice happening in the show...poetic justice to chhod hi do..

Originally posted by: sanfan

I am a bit lost tbh as I haven’t seen a lot of episodes and I don’t intend to… I didn’t understand the last line…in bold

Arshi is being subtly ww'd.

Yesterday and today subtext is Shubho Bipasha Laal Tanuja made Arshi who she is to further their own means.

Shubo - maybe worried abt how J is smart and challenges his position in the house -encouraged Lalon to eventually expose him

Bipasha - cares nothing for Arshi - is just using her for own purposes

Yesterday Ani saying BH family made Arshi who she is today. Today Shristi told Shubho - its him and his family who are responsible for this. Shubo kept bringing up Arshi's accident as caused by J indirectly. Ani kept initially deflecting trying to intentionally not understand that it was aimed at Jhanak and assuming mistake being pointed was his. He then lost his patience and clearly said Shubo was trying to CA Jhanak intentionally.

Ani made so much sense today - its unbelievable. It is clear PH was writing all this smoke and mirrors stuff intentionally. They know exactly what is right wrong cringe toxic. With this Ani, he may even know Arshi raped him - thats how on target he was today.

They conveniently removed any reproach to the main culprit Shristi.

Originally posted by: PPak

Arshi is being subtly ww'd.

Yesterday and today subtext is Shubho Bipasha Laal Tanuja made Arshi who she is to further their own means.

Shubo - maybe worried abt how J is smart and challenges his position in the house -encouraged Lalon to eventually expose him

Bipasha - cares nothing for Arshi - is just using her for own purposes

Yesterday Ani saying BH family made Arshi who she is today. Today Shristi told Shubho - its him and his family who are responsible for this. Shubo kept bringing up Arshi's accident as caused by J indirectly. Ani kept initially deflecting trying to intentionally not understand that it was aimed at Jhanak and assuming mistake being pointed was his. He then lost his patience and clearly said Shubo was trying to CA Jhanak intentionally.

Ani made so much sense today - its unbelievable. It is clear PH was writing all this smoke and mirrors stuff intentionally. They know exactly what is right wrong cringe toxic. With this Ani, he may even know Arshi raped him - thats how on target he was today.

They conveniently removed any reproach to the main culprit Shristi.

Again Priya I am saying this to you...you are putting too much expectations on Leena...Arshi is not wwed...she will be propped time to time...Ani has always been in delulu that Arshi is achhi ladki ...pehle he used to blame Srishti for Arshi's change and now he is blaming his family...he rarely introspect about Arshi...his logical mind loses to his guilt every single time...and that's why he never questioned her pregnancy...isse Arshi kaise ww ho gayi? She was vile and she will be vile ..Ani's attempts to consider Arshi sudhar sakti hai will be tarnished again, brutally, soon...just wait and watch.

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Filhaal to there's no justice...since the baby is already shown to be born..and Ani also never questioned how did he become a father despite asking time from Arshi to proceed..

...in my pov, one poetic justice I found was when Srishti tried burning K and in return burnt her own daughter ..bure karmo ka fal...uske baad se I don't remember any straight forward justice happening in the show...poetic justice to chhod hi do..

So having Ani's baby, but not having his love, respect, inability to keep J away, having mental insecurity, Ani not affectionate to baby, more keen to defend J than care for her, are all potic justice. Arshi's attempts to show J down and rest of family's insults are all efforts/ attempts to that dilute minimize the poetic justice Arshi is getting. Till now the problem with poetic justice was Ani's seeming duality; since all of the poetic justice was linked to him as in between Arshi J. It was not clear. Ani's clarity and stand now underlines the poetic justice.

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Filhaal to there's no justice...since the baby is already shown to be born..and Ani also never questioned how did he become a father despite asking time from Arshi to proceed..

...in my pov, one poetic justice I found was when Srishti tried burning K and in return burnt her own daughter ..bure karmo ka fal...uske baad se I don't remember any straight forward justice happening in the show...poetic justice to chhod hi do..

Ita all context.

Poetic justice could be Arshi being reminded of Ani thinking she was Jhanak everytime she sees the baby. Scale of it is detrmined by writer...but I agree with the point that it was not served in the scale of the crime and absolute...rather there were half hearted attempts so far. Lets see what happens now.

Like I said yesterday Ani's reaction to all of this is key. Leena built up in the last episodes of J trying but failing to get away from BH (albeit with J appearing an idiot); her public acknowledgement of Ani as her husband; her love for him; building up his haq which he used to excert before; Arshi's unfair treatment of J all leading to Ani's state of mind that even while Arshi is in this stage his first priority is for his first wife :)

This is something she can pull off - if she refrains from Ani flipping - which she has not done yet. I dont trust her - but so far after a long time - 2-3 episodes are going in a direction as best possible within confines of the horrid story to date.

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Again Priya I am saying this to you...you are putting too much expectations on Leena...Arshi is not wwed...she will be propped time to time...Ani has always been in delulu that Arshi is achhi ladki ...pehle he used to blame Srishti for Arshi's change and now he is blaming his family...he rarely introspect about Arshi...his logical mind loses to his guilt every single time...and that's why he never questioned her pregnancy...isse Arshi kaise ww ho gayi? She was vile and she will be vile ..Ani's attempts to consider Arshi sudhar sakti hai will be tarnished again, brutally, soon...just wait and watch.

Agreed, as I've said before story now hinges on ani's consistency. Is this a new phase or will he flip again. Until he flips - my response stands tho:)

Originally posted by: samarp2

exctsly some random phool phishi came 🙄🙄 & doing drama at home 🙄🤦‍♀️

Arshi madam time no one is there...great...during j annulment time brought some nasty woman to humiliate J.

Originally posted by: PPak

Mayuri need below from you in episode.

Ani level of ghulami and guilt? 1-10

J level of punish me - " I am at fault for didi accident" 1-10

Unless they make this episode contrast Aag episode - rinse and repeat to follow

Priya I have not yet watched episode... not have a plan to watch. The thing which I hate the most Ani shi..was already established and baby is born. So I don't have that strong heart to watch and analyse episodes.