Watch

TEAM

Jhalak Dikhla Jaa 8 India Forums

halak Dikhhla Jaa Reloaded: Faisal Khan winning the show is NOT unfair - Page 2

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Created

9years

Last reply

9years

Replies

Views

Users

Likes

Frequent Posters

1032675

Hibernated

Posted: 9 years ago

#11

It is unfair for 1 zollion Sanaya's fan😆 there devi did not win.. they must be planning to give DHARNA against the decision.. Bharat me patharo ki kami hone ka imkaan 🤣

Quote

AthuRoSalian

@AthuRoSalian

Beginner

Posted: 9 years ago

#12

Well first of all let me tell u I m silent spectator of Forum but ppl saying Faisal is undeserving is irritating...

They say non dancer should win ...

But the actual concept of show is dancing with stars...

And Faisal Khan is indeed a telivision star...

For those who says he doesn't have fandom ... Let me tell u he has crazy fandom... People love him so much ..

He is popular on telivision n as we all know DID lil master season 2 got record break votes...

Just think at that time he was not a star still he won ...

N now everyone knows n loves him so oits totally Fair for him to win ...

He is the most deserving winner

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

ViTharvforever

@ViTharvforever

Sparkler

Posted: 9 years ago

#13

well i completely agree...faisal deserves this win...even if shamita or mohit wins. do u think sanaya fans will accept it???no ...for faisal their problem is he is a dancer..if shamita or mohit wins their problem will be popularity...they cant accept facts against sanaya...so its waste of tym to explain things to them

Quote

Fatima

@Fatima_Q

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 9 years ago

#14

Every year there is a trained dancer in the show, but they are usually not popular with the public. As a result they are able to pull in less popular votes. Slowly the public may warm up to them because of their outstanding performances...but it takes time..and in that time they can easily get eliminated due to lack of popular votes.

This in turn helps the non-dancer participants...who can stick around longer due to the votes they are able to draw in. The extra time they get helps them improve in their dancing abilities. Some past contestants have really shown great improvement. And often the non-dancer wins...confirming the myth that only a non-dancer should be the winner of JDJ.

This year was a little different...we had a dancer unlike any other...a junior participant who tugged at the heart strings of the public with his outstanding dancing. His choreographer was innovative...and his dancing partner almost as good as he was...And he had a good fan following of his own.

So yes...finally...it happened...the dancer worked his butt off...the judges saw it each week and delivered the scores...the public saw it too and delivered the votes..👏

Faisal won. He deserved it. Finally...a candidate who was the best dancer and the won the hearts of the public took home the trophy.

I'm elated. 😃

Edited by Fatima_Q - 9 years ago

Quote

dontinvademars

@ILuvPrachiDesai

Dazzler

Posted: 9 years ago

#15

Totally agree with you naseem, faisel is extremely talented and he deserved to win!

Quote

peeyara

@peeyara

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 9 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: ILuvPrachiDesai
Totally agree with you naseem, faisel is extremely talented and he deserved to win!

mera nahi hai yeh Saarah😆

i found it on twitter n forgot to mention "article" in title isiliye confusion 😆

yup faisal deserved to win😃

my mom is super happy that he won and when I told her whats going on twitter she was like "huh" 🤣

my poor sis couldn't watch ABCD 2 kyunki mom jhalak dekhegi ab😆

Edited by peeyara - 9 years ago

Quote

Afrin

@PizzaHolic.

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

#17

He deserved to win and he won.

Doesnt matter he is small but HE HAVE WON MANY PEOPLE'S HEARTS 👏

Quote

meeyaa

@meeyaa

Navigator

Posted: 9 years ago

#18

Firstly, the core solution is that the program should be changed to be strictly for non-dancers only. Else, this issue will happen all the time. In any competition, you need to have participants with a similar skill set and the parameters of judgement fixed, measurable and verifiable.

The reason Faisal winning is unfair according to me are :

a) Dancing like any art form improves with training and a person with years of focussed training is surely at an advantage instantly compared to a person without such a background of training. For a real non-dancer, even balancing will be a problem initially.

So imagine, they have 2 days to prepare for a dance. A non-dancer would have to learn the basics and slowly evolve to include some difficult steps and then try to get some wow steps if possible. On the other hand, a dancer like Faisal would meet up with another fab dancer Vaishnavi, and say...hey lets do the butterfly-twist or something and instantly they would try it and get it. So the result that can be achieved in the same 2 days differs because of the years of training before. Its not a question of real talent still.

Sanaya's performances have really improved for a non-dancer and everyone has acknowledged this. She has mastered basics, done difficult steps and even performed many wow steps in -every- dance in this short time period.

b) Choreography : Faisal, Vaishnavi and Vivek - 3 dancing minds vs Jai - 1 mind. Just think and you would realize how unfair it is.

May be a dancer sould be paired up with another person without a choreographer with them. But with a choreographer too present, you have a major unfairness to all other participants.

Its not fair to Sanaya that she didnt win because inspite of becoming the best among the non-dancers, she didnt get the trophy because her final hurdle was to compete with person with years of training against her 13-14 weeks.

Faisal's win surely reiterates that he is an excellent dancer but Sanaya's win would have inspired people that with focus and hardwork, even a non-dancer can do wonders .

Quote

raji

@Bujee09

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

#19

👏 yup totally agree...I enjoyed his final performance it way brilliant...vivek vaishnavi their team n Faisal deffo deserve this win...wishing the kids n given a wonderful life ahead...am so happy that the money will help these two live their dreams...most deserving winners

Quote

jyoti01

@jyoti01

Navigator

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#20

I think all the tv artists take some dancing classes or the other before they enter the industry. Sanaya has been dancing on stage shows - she did not just pop up on stage. She must have some training. Even Dhrashti Dhami said she was a non dancer. The fact is she used to give dance classes to kids when she was in college to earn pocket money. It is obvious she would give dance classes only if she had learnt dancing herself. Trained dancer wud be someone like Isha Shravani who had trained for 8 years in her family run dance school in south. Isha shravani did notlose, she had hurt herself and had to leave. Lauren did not have any fan base in india when she took part. Faisal was not only dancing, his popularity was more coz of his serials and was popular with the masses. His winning is justified. His performances were outstanding.

Quote

1 2 3

Faisal Khan

halak Dikhhla Jaa Reloaded: Faisal Khan winning the show is NOT unfair - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics