there will never be another madhuri - Page 8

Originally posted by: xaneroyxx

Spending more time or energy on this would be futile. because I have made it clear that i am not a fan, when it seems that you are making it a life goal to campaign for shveta through the arguments being posed on the "general functionalities" of the show. This was never meant to be a comparative case study, but incidents were pointed out to elaborate the discussion. there's a manipulative sense to twist things around and direct them towards your favorite contestant. granted bearing in mind the sentiments fans have for their contestants however if should never override reasoning. and at the end of the day to each his own. and if your sole purpose in not just this thread but many is to show that shveta is invincible then by all means, i think its good for you..and you should dedicate this energy in voting. moreover i believe you have great career prospects for a politician. but in an age of prevalent democracy..it is only exercised by hearing both views and taking them into consideration. not by trying to propel your beliefs on the account of others. constant bantering wont get us anywhere. and the results are going to be out soon, and i believe this discussion is going to take an uglier from after. you seem to take everything said in context of the two contestants..and to inferiorate one and empower another. i hope it works for you. but the discussion posted was on the judges behavior and the show in general.

JDJ is a great show with some mishaps..but there is a life beyond it.

This is very interesting...

SO when views are stated,you call it enforcing..going by that logic,even you enforce...What was all about Sanjay's biasness and citing reasons to defend your stance..that's precisely what I did...if you're not open to other opinions,I reckon you should have never posted the thread,because threads garner opinions,and I just stated my opinion about the bharatnatyam and about Madhuri' being a trained kathak dancer,and svetha not being one

I couldnt care less if youre a fan or not,but atleast be open to other views which are backed with proper reasoning.....Just attacking and calling me manipulative just for contradicting your view connotes the escapist tendency....

Originally posted by: Buffie

Originally posted by: silverwing1527

tina59, can i ask you a question, are you rooting for mona or shveta? just cause i get confused sometimes. not that it matters, just that i like your responses, but get confused at times.

well actually I dont care coz I like both of them and I would be happy if anyone wins . I am just glad that the top two went through and that I have admired and liked both of them since JJKN and hip hip hurray long back .

I think both are talented and beautiful in their own way . In the JJKN forum,I am a big fan of Mona but in JDJ , i dotn know ,I want the person who gets the maximum votes to win .

u know,I was writing like buffie in the NB2 forum and one can read those posts but then later i realised that its no use and people have their likes and they think that the person they like are the best and performed best and thats exactly why reality shows are conducted .

HGT fans felt that they were the best and some others felt that hussain and Tina performed the best and thats understandable coz each one looks at things in their own perspective and its based on their characteristics and likes and thats how opinions are formed and its common human nature.

Originally posted by: tina59

😉

holy crap how can ppl type that much!!😆 if its more than a paragraph long ,i dont even bother reading seriously!!coz i hate reading!!😆 plz keep it simple n short😛

Originally posted by: xaneroyxx

Spending more time or energy on this would be futile. because I have made it clear that i am not a fan, when it seems that you are making it a life goal to campaign for shveta through the arguments being posed on the "general functionalities" of the show. This was never meant to be a comparative case study, but incidents were pointed out to elaborate the discussion.


If I read correct English, the title reads something like "There will be no other madhuri"

This post appears in the JDJ section of IF, clearly reflecting its relation to the show. Obviously, the topic discusses SLB's comparison of Madhuri and Shweta.

there's a manipulative sense to twist things around and direct them towards your favorite contestant.

HELLO?? well, there is a valid reason for shweta fans to discuss whether she can / cannot be compared to madhuri. WHAT MANIPULATIVE SENSE DO YOU SEE HERE??

granted bearing in mind the sentiments fans have for their contestants however if should never override reasoning. and at the end of the day to each his own. and if your sole purpose in not just this thread but many is to show that shveta is invincible then by all means, i think its good for you..and you should dedicate this energy in voting.

Well Yeah., Please LOOK UP FOR POSTS yelling out PL Vote for Mona, Mona is the Winner etc etc.. Thanks for ur UNCALLED FOR Advise Please send some over to the Mona fans who have posted topics such as SHWETA-good dancer , bad person

Unless u find that FUTILE TOO 😉

moreover i believe you have great career prospects for a politician. but in an age of prevalent democracy..it is only exercised by hearing both views and taking them into consideration. not by trying to propel your beliefs on the account of others. constant bantering wont get us anywhere.

I am soooo happy that you reckon that. Given all this knowledge and maturity, ur point in attacking a single person here is ???

and the results are going to be out soon, and i believe this discussion is going to take an uglier from after. you seem to take everything said in context of the two contestants..and to inferiorate one and empower another. i hope it works for you. but the discussion posted was on the judges behavior and the show in general.

It was a comment about "Shweta" in case you failed to realize... 😆

JDJ is a great show with some mishaps..but there is a life beyond it.

Oh yeah and we are loving it!!
Oakland is leading by 17 points for the first time and i am watching the game. Life beyond JDJ is great too and so is LOGICAL REASONING and SUPPORTING a better DANCER performing in a DANCE COMPETETION.. but yeah, as u r not a fan, u may not know 😆😆

We are not promoting Shweta.. She doesnt know us, doesn;t care and doesn;t need us. and we know that too.. it is just that she has scored the most points so far.. and is the best dancer in JDJ 1
We r ready for public voting disasters.. been there. won;t feel bad if ss loses. She'll bag a movie b4 anyone else on the show. she'll make it big too.. whether ppl love her or not.

mQT

Originally posted by: Buffie

This is very interesting...

SO when views are stated,you call it enforcing..going by that logic,even you enforce...What was all about Sanjay's biasness and citing reasons to defend your stance..that's precisely what I did...if you're not open to other opinions,I reckon you should have never posted the thread,because threads garner opinions,and I just stated my opinion about the bharatnatyam and about Madhuri' being a trained kathak dancer,and svetha not being one

I couldnt care less if youre a fan or not,but atleast be open to other views which are backed with proper reasoning.....Just attacking and calling me manipulative just for contradicting your view connotes the escapist tendency....

Re-read your posts and if you don't find the tone shveta is great , shveta should be commended, shveta this shveta that. Then you should discuss. I never neglected your views, or not taken them into consideration. again its not you that is manipulative, it is your method of arguing, which tends to highlight on contestant on the account of the other. Your reason may mean nothing to many, because according to them your statements constitute nothing but favoritism, which is your right. If you saw my last post as an attack then I appologixe but that was definetly not the message i wanted to send across. You are entitled to your own opinion. yet when its time for general discussion what is relative is what counts. like i said its not escaping "reason" because I think we all are far from realixing wat that truly is..its saving time and energy on bantering with people whose motives and opinions are obvious. I expressed my opinion on something, the judges and the show in general. you replied reflecting that on your obviously favorite contestant. to me its not about proving you wrong and proving me right. your opinions are valid to you. so basically good for you..keep up the spirit.

Originally posted by: tina59

why cant u seem to understnd that some look for ceratin things in their celebrities and something that appeals to them and thats called "X factor buffie ,should i dig up ur post on X facxtor and its there in every reality show and thats along with the dancing skills they got .

basically meaning,looking at every other factor but what should be looked at(i.e. dancing/singing)

II and JDJ are not personality competitions..the public should strictly look at ONLY dancing/singing,not looks /smile/attitude etc

oh thats very convenient buffie,on one had u say that svetha should win coz she was the best dancer and this was a dancing competition and on the other hand u say that u supported amey coz there were worse singers,whats that about.

yeah,I supported amey because he was one of the best singers...and when I was supporting him,there were still worse singers..this time on JDJ,it has boiled down to just two.....here its either svetha or Mona...but there it wasnt a situation where it was just either karu or amey..there were still worse singers,and I was expecting all those to get out and then have an amey karu final........and amey never reached the final...had amey can karu reached the final,and had I rooted for amey,even if he had sang badly,i would be called biased..which didnt happen.....so II 2 and JDJ situations are different..they arent the same

This is exactly why I say debating with you is tiring..because you seem to bring in the same points again and again..I clearly said that I'm voting for the best dancer,and out there on II -2,I was rooting for amey,who was one of the best singers...but amey never reached the final,and thus that situation was different from this...I cant elaborate anymore,because I liked both amey and karu,but amey a bit more..and both were very good singers,at par...and it all depends on the performance of "the D day"...on certain occassions amey was better than karu and vice versa...but had they entered the finals,only the finals performance would matter..and here,in the final,svetha performed better...so she should win

I am asking you ,why didnt u support karunya when it was clear that he was the best amongst all the singers and indian idol was about the best singer isnt it buffie he was right there with amey date when "worse singers like ravi and anuj were there " ,coz u supported amey coz he appealed to u more than karunya and thats the fact but unfortunately as i said again and again that u think that the world revolves around u all the time and its sad that u think so

hello,look,reiterating, amey never reached the finals,where it boiled down to just two....when 10 singers are singing,i would want all the bad ones to get out and i would want the best to compete in the final.....and i had always wanted an amey versus karu final..thought I liked amey,i never wanted karu to get out...now had it boiled down to just two,and had karu sang better than amey,then i would have rooted for karunya...because i always want the best to win...and II 2 never had anything as scores...but here svetha is a far better dancer than mona, the scores say so,most of the people also agree on that..and even you have accepted that many a times mona fell short of expectation....Till amey was there,he and karu were pretty close...and both were talented singers..amey can be said to have been as good as karu,whereas mona is just not as good as svetha....any neutral person can say that svetha is farrr better...but you would again go through the rigmarole,so no point debating..

its again sad that u dont care , but I do form an opinion based on how they write and the thoughts they convey and it does ceratinly tells a lot abt the character. I have made my point clear and I think this is going to continue unless someone changes

I dont what you think about me lol😆

btw wasnt this the same buffie who once found john abraham the most handsome oh yeah then came on abhishek and now its hrithik huh and and and it was arman aka apurva once isnt it , that once again says abt ur thoughts and views .

yeah,but as I said,had they entered a dance competition,i would have clearly voted for hrithik....I had said the same thing when you citesd the SRk abhishek analogy,seems like you never got the point....

and stop analysing my character here,based on my crushes😆.I'm still 18,I'm not an auntyjee that I settle with one man...I dont call people biased,only because they like somebody or have a crush on somebody..but when people turn a blind eye to their faults(like how you're never accepted that a contradiction is a contradiction,and have been harping the same cliches ever since) and when fans cite dumb reasons like "smile,affability" etc as the yardsticks of dance,that's when they are called biased..One wouldnt become biased for having crushes..I' didnt take any lifelong pledge that I would adore only abhi or hrithik....but having said that,if they enter a competition,i would vote only based on their talent...and if the abhi fans then say that he is the best,when he isnt,i would call them biased...

Originally posted by: sonyaee

Reality show judges are notorious for making false promises. Don't get your hopes up just yet on Shveta making it big in Bollywood. Lets see if SLB even remembers her after JDJ.

that is sooo true.. Remember Anu Malik in indian idol..promising every one of them for a chance to work with him

karunya got a break but not with him and that was about it