xaneroyxx thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

my impression of sanjay leela bhansali has totally changed after following JDJ- Madhuri is impeccable and her talent is simply out of reach. she's simply a land mark. others can try, they can form their own niche. they can never be her, comparisons are futile and naiive.

Created

Last reply

Replies

145

Views

10k

Users

28

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

lil_miz_cutie thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
u r such hypocrytes. when ever shveta gets praised u like to say bad things about her to wipe it off n when ever mona gets praised, u always try to rub it in shveta fan's faces. listen, it was his opinion not urs. if he thinks that she is as good as her then that is his problem not urs, so stop harassing even the judges opinion if at least not the shveta fans.
mermaid_QT thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: xaneroyxx

my impression of sanjay leela bhansali has totally changed after following JDJ- Madhuri is impeccable and her talent is simply out of reach. she's simply a land mark. others can try, they can form their own niche. they can never be her, comparisons are futile and naiive.



errrr.. would u say the same if sanjay called mona the next madhuri? 😉


insouciance thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
One thing...Sanjay has worked with MAdhuri ,he has seen her perform live...We(mostly) have seen only the finished product,with so many retakes ....Sanjay would have watched Madhuri perform infront of his eyes,and now he's seeing svetha...SO,if he feels that she is as good as MAdhuri,he is in a position to say so,because he has worked with her,none of us have seen mads/svetha in person dancing..We've only seen them on tv/big screen.....

He is in a better position to judge,he knows better than us....lets not take that away from him...

courtsey ..HArd rock 😊 ..She had said the above in a ost,I reiterated the same
lil_miz_cutie thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Buffie

One thing...Sanjay has worked with MAdhuri ,he has seen her perform live...We(mostly) have seen only the finished product,with so many retakes ....Sanjay would have watched Madhuri perform infront of his eyes,and now he's seeing svetha...SO,if he feels that she is as good as MAdhuri,he is in a position to say so,because he has worked with her,none of us have seen mads/svetha in person dancing..We've only seen them on tv/big screen.....

He is in a better position to judge,he knows better than us....lets not take that away from him...

courtsey ..HArd rock 😊 ..She had said the above in a ost,I reiterated the same



thats exactly wat i was gonna say. rite on grl!😆
mermaid_QT thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Buffie

One thing...Sanjay has worked with MAdhuri ,he has seen her perform live...We(mostly) have seen only the finished product,with so many retakes ....Sanjay would have watched Madhuri perform infront of his eyes,and now he's seeing svetha...SO,if he feels that she is as good as MAdhuri,he is in a position to say so,because he has worked with her,none of us have seen mads/svetha in person dancing..We've only seen them on tv/big screen.....

He is in a better position to judge,he knows better than us....lets not take that away from him...

courtsey ..HArd rock 😊 ..She had said the above in a ost,I reiterated the same



very good point buffie!
bsmartguy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: mermaid_QT



errrr.. would u say the same if sanjay called mona the next madhuri? 😉

yes, I would say the same thing if SLB had called Mona the next madhuri. He is equalling Shveta who is a nondancer and just learning dance to the great Madhuri. Thats also proves that how badly SLB wants Shveta to win the competition.

Edited by bsmartguy - 18 years ago
insouciance thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: bsmartguy

yes, I would say the same thing if SLB had called Mona the next madhuri. He is equalling Shveta who is a nondancer and just learning dance to the great Madhuri. Thats also proves that how badly SLB wants Shveta to win the competition.

SVetha is a talented dancer...There is something called as T_A_L_E_N_T...Kunal Ganjawala wasnt a clasically trained singer,but he won the award for the best singer male in 2004,beating even the trained and seasoned SOnu Nigam......Because he was talented....

If one is really talented,one can even better the veteran...In reality singing shows,the judges so many times tell the contestants that they sang better than the original singer...That is what talent is all about...

Svetha's talented,and even if she isnt trained,she can better all the seasoned veterans,because that is precisely what talent is all about.....One either has the talent,or doesnt..There are no two ways about it

If one isnt talented,one can achieve a certain level by HARDWORk,but when the talented one ALSO works hard ,they beat everyone

bsmartguy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Buffie

SVetha is a talented dancer...There is something called as T_A_L_E_N_T...Kunal Ganjawala wasnt a clasically trained singer,but he won the award for the best singer male in 2004,beating even the trained and seasoned SOnu Nigam......Because he was talented....

If one is really talented,one can even better the veteran...In reality singing shows,the judges so many times tell the contestants that they sang better than the original singer...That is what talent is all about...

Svetha's talented,and even if she isnt trained,she can better all the seasoned veterans,because that is precisely what talent is all about.....One either has the talent,or doesnt..There are no two ways about it

If one isnt talented,one can achieve a certain level by HARDWORk,but when the talented one ALSO works hard ,they beat everyone

So wat u r trying to say is that its fair to equal Madhuri with Shveta because she is talented and also works hard. If that was the case then we would have millions and millions of Madhuri in India. A lot of people are really talented and dances as well would SLB also compare them with the Madhuri. NO WAY he is comparing Shveta to Madhuri just because she is a celebrity. It is an insult to Madhuri that a nondancer is been compated to her. So wat abt Mona. Isn't she talented and working hard… Both are equally working hard and talented…

Edited by bsmartguy - 18 years ago
lil_miz_cutie thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: bsmartguy

So wat u r trying to say is that its fair to equal Madhuri with Shveta because she is talented and also works hard. If that was the case then we would have millions and millions of Madhuri in India. A lot of people are really talented and dances as well would SLB also compare them with the Madhuri. NO WAY he is comparing Shveta to Madhuri just because she is a celebrity. It is an insult to Madhuri that a nondancer is been compated to her. So wat abt Mona. Isn't she talented and working hard… Both are equally working hard and talented…



listen up buddy
we are not talkin about all those millions of people. buffie jus used some examples. we are jus comparing wats presented on stage and if sanjay is stating that shveta dances like madhuri then im sure there is a reason for it, he's not dumb. like buffie said he has done devdas with madhuri n seen madhuri dancin live n now he is seein shveta dance live so he can make a better jusgment and he jus did. but ur against it so stop sulkin coz its his opinion

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".