there will never be another madhuri - Page 4

Originally posted by: bsmartguy

Look what i meant was that Its public choice if they want to vote for shveta they will vote for shveta... As Mona is also insceure that shveta would get more votes than her but she never said that ppl would vote for hr cuz she is Dr. Mishra... There is nothing to be insecure its public choice... When I said its public choice I didn;t mean ppl wuld vote 4 her cuz she is jassi.. The depends on how ppl interpret when voting. JASSI OR HER DANCE, TALENT, IMPROVEMENT...

Yes,the public doesnt care who the better dancer is..they would vote for htier own personal likes and dislikes..which is called bias....and biasness cannot be justified .Period!

and yes,Svetha has everything top feel insecure about,as I've allready explained,Svetha isnt as popular as mona,b'cos Left right left isnt as popular as jassi.....Svetha hasnt been the protagonist of any pathbreaking show,moan has.....Mona has more fans,more people whoa dore her for being jassi......

Only when the public votes for talent and for the best performer,would be they deemed unbiased..if they vote for any other reason,like favouritism,improvement,affability etc,the judgment would be rendered to be a biased one...

Okay so are saying Shveta is feeling insecure cuz she is not that popular. So wat abt Pooja bedi, Akashdeep, Rati. they all are not as popular as Mona but none of them said that mona will get more votes cuz she is Jassi... Look at Shveta on other hand....

Originally posted by: bsmartguy

Do u think that when Shveta's fan called Mona is fat etc etc .. So its okay to comment on someone physical appearance but its not okay to comment on someone's jealously nature.... Many Shveta fans have also said that Mona is not a gud dancer. If Mona was not a gud dancer then she would not have been in top two. Then u guys will say that public voted her cuz she is Mona... look i not the one who is selling excuses, Shveta fans are selling excuses.

we are debating her as to who is suppose to win. but again the final decsion is up to the public. Both have equal chances of winning. and both r equally gud....

One thing..commenting on looks etc is the PREROGATIVE of the audience..when stars pose themselves for judgment,they would be critiqued...because,if weight doesnt matter at all,why does mona give interviews saying she lost weight😛...and another thing,when people can say that she deserves to win because she lost weight,one can also say that some of her dances dont look all that aesthetic because her huge hips,her huge legs make an eyesore....if weight loss can be applauded,then its just fair that one can comment when a celeb looks fat

Svetha fans didnt call Mona fat without any rhyme or reason...It is all pertaining to the dance..Now if she looks fat in a dance,people would comment about it....MOna has posed herself for judgment,and everything about her,her dressing,her weight etc would be scrutinized....

having said that,I would definitely not vote only based on weight,I would vote for performance....But,even in performance,svetha clearly beats mona.... its a fact that svetha is more visually appealing,her lifts look nice...Mona on the other hand finds it difficult to perch herself in different postures with her weight...she is not flexible

it is a fact that tobby made her lose weight because he felt that it would be easier for her to dance if she's light...she did lose weight,but yet she looks uncomfortable at times while carrying the weight..thus,the weight issue is brought in,only to say that tobby cant give steps longinus gives svetha,because mona would find it difficult to carry her weight,and tobby would find it arduous,to whirl her around,as she's on the plump side

but annihilating the character is so reprehensible....and when svetha's called names,just to prove that mona's better,it does arouse our ire....and why should one take in aspects like character while judging a dance competition.....even Mona backchatted farah,she cribbed that she wasnt given enough scores..now the svetha fans dont bring that point up again and again ,but we just debate based on performance

Weight is brought up,in the context of critiquing the performance,whereas other people bring in aspects like "jealousy" just to denigrate the character...weight is interrelated to dance,character isnt!

Originally posted by: bsmartguy

Okay so are saying Shveta is feeling insecure cuz she is not that popular. So wat abt Pooja bedi, Akashdeep, they all are not as popular as Mona but none of them said that mona will get more votes cuz she is Jassi... Look at Shveta on other hand....

svetha felt insecure in the quater finals ...pooja bedi etc were eliminated in the very preliminary rounds itself..now had they qualified for the quater finals,perhaps even they would have felt insecure....Now svetha didnt feel insecure in the very first round,but when she saw that Mona was getting more votes,only because of her popularity,she felt insecure...in the beginning,no one knew who would be judged based on what criterion..but once when svetha knew that the fans are voting only because mona is jassi,she did feel insecure.....and that too when it boiled down to just 3 people

Originally posted by: bsmartguy

Okay so are saying Shveta is feeling insecure cuz she is not that popular. So wat abt Pooja bedi, Akashdeep, Rati. they all are not as popular as Mona but none of them said that mona will get more votes cuz she is Jassi... Look at Shveta on other hand....

Originally posted by: Buffie

You cannot make a issue of mona popularity and blame mona for getting votes due to popularity. Each voter has it own choice and opinion. Also it depends what factors are voters considering while voting. So if thet are looking mona's popularity n voting u can't balme them. But see when it came to three participants. Shveta, Mahesh, and Mona. Mahesh and Mona are both popular than Shveta. Mahesh has directed and appeared in number of flims. Still pubclic voted for Shveta enough though she is mot popular as compared to others. So see public did not vote for Mahesh cuz he is popular cuz the public liked his dance. So public are voting for mona cuz they like her dance or cuz of her popularity. On the whole ppl should not just say that mona will win only because of popularity and that she is jassi cuz we dun know the factors voters take into considertion while voting. So its not Monas fault if public are voting for Jassi and not Mona. Some ppl have said that its Mona's CG fault that she did not perform well. This is not correct. It was their fault. On the same hand its not Mona's fault that Shveta is not popular as her.

Edited by bsmartguy - 18 years ago

Originally posted by: bsmartguy

Edited by Buffie - 18 years ago

To u r previous reply, buffie

how can you blame Mona if her fans wants her to win. Their fans are not wrong. They are making their favourite win the competition and that's all abt. So your argument that if Mona wins is according to the biased judge is not acceptable. Look u think that mona's fans are biased and they are just voting for jassi. But this is not the case for each and every person. Some fans vote for mona's talent. Some fans just vote for Mona just because she is Jassi. So it all depends on ppl choice. Just imagine if Shveta would have got 72 and Mona would have got 85. Would all Shveta fans suddenly vote for Mona. The answer is NO. they would not vote for mona rather they would vote more for Shveta to make her win the competition. So that's it. Every voter has the right to vote, and support to the participant that they want. So this is the case same with the mona's fan rite now.

Also tell me one thing when mona scored 54 in the semifinals and shveta scored 51. did u voted for mona cuz she got better scores from judges which means she danced better than Shveta in the semi finals.

Also this was the comment made by one of the mona's fan

victorygirl wrote

see no ones gona listen to u or me coz ppl will jus do whatever they wanna do, they dont care no mater how stronger argue u come up with at the end they will go for their personal taste n choice ...

but sure we can have fun of debating withought being rude n foul!!