there will never be another madhuri - Page 2

i have to keep repeating myself! u mona fans are hypocrytes!!!

Originally posted by: lil_miz_cutie

listen up buddy
we are not talkin about all those millions of people. buffie jus used some examples. we are jus comparing wats presented on stage and if sanjay is stating that shveta dances like madhuri then im sure there is a reason for it, he's not dumb. like buffie said he has done devdas with madhuri n seen madhuri dancin live n now he is seein shveta dance live so he can make a better jusgment and he jus did. but ur against it so stop sulkin coz its his opinion

Look, if i am aganist it. Aren't you against it as well. aren't you denying that Mona is equal to Madhuri. The same way I am denying that Shveta is equal to Madhuri. I respect everyone's views and opinions. And I agree that everyone has its own opinion and hence I dun agree with wat u guys have to say in this matter. He is just been nice to shveta cuz he just likes her. She dances well no doubt and so mona but I think judges prefer Shveta more than Mona... which is not right.

Originally posted by: bsmartguy

So wat u r trying to say is that its fair to equal Madhuri with Shveta because she is talented and also works hard. If that was the case then we would have millions and millions of Madhuri in India. A lot of people are really talented and dances as well would SLB also compare them with the Madhuri. NO WAY he is comparing Shveta to Madhuri just because she is a celebrity. It is an insult to Madhuri that a nondancer is been compated to her. So wat abt Mona. Isn't she talented and working hard… Both are equally working hard and talented…

No,both are not equally talented...Mona is not as talented as Svetha..Mona is not as flexible as svetha is,and flexibility is one of the foremost desideratum for a dancer....Mona is NOT as talented as SVetha is....Mona works hard,no doubt...but Talent is inborn,one cant cultivate it,and Svetha is a talented dancer,Mona isnt....Mona is a talented actress,but not a talented dancer........Hard work isnt synonymous with talent...That's what I believe😊

Yes,I stand by what I said that one can compare svetha to madhuri,as svetha is talented and hardworking..People need to get the mental block out that there cant be anyone better than madhuri ...There can be dancers who are better than her too....She was the only one in films,in her era who could do some dancing,as all others like juhi chawla,kajol,Karishma Kapoor,Raveena tandon etc werent great dancers to begin with.......There can be people who are more talented than Madhuri😊

Secondly,Dancing is something which is inborn,as well as depends on hard work..a non dancer,who has never taken any training can be a really talented one,just as how a non singer can have talent and thereby sing well(example kunal ganjawala)...Even kishore Kumar didnt have any formal training,even he was a non-singer,because he didnt take training and practice for hours..but he was so talented,....Svetha's naturally talented,and its no insult to madhuri if svetha is compared to her...Just as how it isnt an insult to kishore kumar,if someone really really out of the world is compared to him and is said to be as good as kishore kumar..Mind you,SLB didnt say that svetha's better than madhuri,he only said that she is as good as mads is.....and FYI,Sanjay bhansali is a hugeeeeeeeeee madhuri dixit fan,and he wouldnt be insulting her ....He has adored madhuri,as he said on koffee with karan,and he would be the last person to insult her......

Madhuri was of her era,and in this era,there can be many more madhuris..Aishwarya RAi is a terrific dancer,as good as MAdhuri...Mdhuri was the best in her era,there can exist dancers who are better than her..and Sanjay is not a fool that he compares his favourite madhuri to SVetha sans rhyme or reason

Originally posted by: bsmartguy

Look, if i am aganist it. Aren't you against it as well. aren't you denying that Mona is equal to Madhuri. The same way I am denying that Shveta is equal to Madhuri. I respect everyone's views and opinions. And I agree that everyone has its own opinion and hence I dun agree with wat u guys have to say in this matter. He is just been nice to shveta cuz he just likes her. She dances well no doubt and so mona but I think judges prefer Shveta more than Mona... which is not right.

Svetha is a much better dancer than Mona,and mostly everyone agree on this(If you dont,state why)....She has been the best,since day 1,and mona has NEVER scored more than her,even once when the tota marks are concerned....

Mona isnt even the best in the show,so where is the question of comparing her to MAdhuri,who is in a totally different league together....The judges prefer svetha for the simple reason that she is the much better dancer...the audience prefer mona because they like her personality,her laugh,her effort etc etc....

Originally posted by: lil_miz_cutie

i have to keep repeating myself! u mona fans are hypocrytes!!!

If Mona fans are hypocrtyes then Shveta fans are dictators. I am saying this shaveta fans just want other ppl to believe that she is the best without looking the view points of Mona's fan.

I would have been glad, if u had posted something in regards to what I have said even though if I did not match my viewpoint on that particular subject. Remember here we are debating. But you didn't do that. Instead you started accusing other ppl. So plz once again post your thoughts on the subject instead of accusing other ppl by saying Mona's fans are hypocrytes.

ye smart guy... the judges r supporting shveta more because she is the better dancer not because of anything else

Originally posted by: bsmartguy

If Mona fans are hypocrtyes then Shveta fans are dictators. I am saying this shaveta fans just want other ppl to believe that she is the best without looking the view points of Mona's fan.

I would have been glad, if u had posted something in regards to what I have said even though if I did not match my viewpoint on that particular subject. Remember here we are debating. But you didn't do that. Instead you started accusing other ppl. So plz once again post your thoughts on the subject instead of accusing other ppl by saying Mona's fans are hypocrytes.

Dude,when svetha is calumniated by the mona fans,when she is caled a "jealous looser",a "bad human being",do you expect us to take all this s**t and be as cool as a cucumber😕...the mona fans are so sensitive,that they offended even if mona is called "fat"...but how fair is it to expect all svetha fans to tranquilly take all the character annihiliation...you yourself did say svetha was jealous,do you expect us to take all this crap said to belittle svetha😭

and when retaliated to such acerbic scathing remarks,we're called dictators...how amusing👏😕

No one wants to shove it down people's throats that svetha is the better dancer..we're only logically reasoning out,and refuting reasons cited by the mona fans....IF you feel Mona is the best,lay down the points....Just by saying that someone is hardworking and has shown improvement doesnt corroborate the stance that Mona is the best..back up the stance with valid substantiation and valid arguments....all that mona fans say in her defense is "she is not a dancer,she has shown improvement,judges are biased,svetha is jealous,its tobby's fault,she has shown so much improvement,so her improvement would go down the gutter if we dont vote for her,I hate shveta,so I would vote for mona," etc..give some logical reasoning,as to why mona is better....the svetha fans say that she is more flexible,her dance is so nimble and dexterous,her lifts are more aesthetic,her hip movements are just so graceful,her toes point so immaculately,her expressions are fantastic....come up with such reasons,before calling us dictators

Mona fans(not meaning you ,but in general) are hypocritical...when Mona performs well,all credit to her,but is she performs badly,all flak for tobby...all credit to mona for improving so much,but her performance is run of the mill ,its tobby's fault or judges are biased👏...reasons cited why mona should win....svetha has attitude,svetha's jealous,svetha is a trained dancer(which she isnt BTW),it was tobby's fault.....Mona isnt the bets dancer,but she should win for her improvement etc

Originally posted by: Buffie

Dude,when svetha is calumniated by the mona fans,when she is caled a "jealous looser",a "bad human being",do you expect us to take all this s**t and be as cool as a cucumber...the mona fans are so sensitive,that they offended even if mona is called "fat"...but how fair is it to expect all svetha fans to tranquilly take all the character annihiliation...you yourself did say svetha was jealous,do you expect us to take all this crap said to belittle svetha

and when retaliated to such acerbic scathing remarks,we're called dictators...how amusing👏

No one wants to shove it down people's throats that svetha is the better dancer..we're only logically reasoning out,and refuting reasons cited by the mona fans....IF you feel Mona is the best,lay down the points....Just by saying that someone is hardworking and has shown improvement doesnt corroborate the stance that Mona is the best..back up the stance with valid substantiation and valid arguments....all that mona fans say in her defense is "she is not a dancer,she has shown improvement,judges are biased,svetha is jealous,its tobby's fault" etc..give some logical reasoning,as to why mona is better....the svetha fans say that she is more flexible,her lifts are more aesthetic,her hip movements are just so graceful,her toes point so immaculately..come up with such reasons,before calling us dictators

Mona fans(not meaning you alone,but in general) are hypocritical...when Mona performs well,al credit to her,but is she performs badly,all flak for tobby...all credit to mona for improving so much,but if she performs,its tobby's fault/judges are biased👏...reasons why mona should win....svetha has attitude,svetha's jealous,svetha is a trained dancer(which she isnt BTW),it was tobby's fault.....all these excuses clearly qualify under hypocrisy

thnx for proving my point buffie ... see u guys r hypocrytes😆

If SLB says Shveta is as good as Madhuri, why are you getting upset abt it. He didnt say she is better than Madhuri. Its his opinion, he can say whatever he likes. I agree with him though. Shveta's kohli dance reminded me of Madhuri's "hum ko aaj kal hai" song, dont remember which movie 😭

Originally posted by: Buffie

Nobody has accused anybody / subjected them to any sentence in spite of being DICTATORS 😉. Several comments from fans can be considered hypocritical (as per the definition of the word) .. But calling us DICTATORS, makes me wanna LAUGH OUT LOUD!

Dude,when svetha is calumniated by the mona fans,when she is caled a "jealous looser",a "bad human being",do you expect us to take all this s**t and be as cool as a cucumber...the mona fans are so sensitive,that they offended even if mona is called "fat"...but how fair is it to expect all svetha fans to tranquilly take all the character annihiliation...you yourself did say svetha was jealous,do you expect us to take all this crap said to belittle svetha

and when retaliated to such acerbic scathing remarks,we're called dictators...how amusing👏

No one wants to shove it down people's throats that svetha is the better dancer..we're only logically reasoning out,and refuting reasons cited by the mona fans....IF you feel Mona is the best,lay down the points....Just by saying that someone is hardworking and has shown improvement doesnt corroborate the stance that Mona is the best..back up the stance with valid substantiation and valid arguments....all that mona fans say in her defense is "she is not a dancer,she has shown improvement,judges are biased,svetha is jealous,its tobby's fault" etc..give some logical reasoning,as to why mona is better....the svetha fans say that she is more flexible,her lifts are more aesthetic,her hip movements are just so graceful,her toes point so immaculately..come up with such reasons,before calling us dictators

Mona fans(not meaning you alone,but in general) are hypocritical...when Mona performs well,al credit to her,but is she performs badly,all flak for tobby...all credit to mona for improving so much,but if she performs,its tobby's fault/judges are biased👏...reasons why mona should win....svetha has attitude,svetha's jealous,svetha is a trained dancer(which she isnt BTW),it was tobby's fault.....all these excuses clearly qualify under hypocrisy

well said buffie.
bsmartguy, i have posted my comments in red in ur quote. i'll head back to my torture chambers 😆

qt