silverwing1527 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

At this point its kind of obvious whats going to happen. It was also evident in the last round. The first out was a shock to me, i didnt expect pooja to get out, but from then on, it became a little clear. I knew from the beginning of the show that Mona, Shveta and Mahesh would be left. It was then evident that ajay was going to get out, and he knew it too, because he was mighty prepared to get out.

We can pretty much tell from this point what is going to happen. Mona is out next, then shveta, and mahesh will win. And im not saying so because i like him. Im biased towards mona, because i really like her because she looks like she dances from the heart and isnt here to win, but rather to have fun. her innovative style reallly appeals to me, but i know shes out next. technically, shveta is and was the most able dancer, and she really should win looking at her ability to dance. but weather she should have been taken into the show knowing that she has a dancing background is questionable.

however, i feel that the judges are really biased towards mahesh which i hate because this is a dancing competition, and should be based on that. the only one by him that i liked personally was the one last week, where he got the perfect 30, it was a touching and heartwarming performance. but other than that, sonia (his partner) has been the show stealer and he really doesnt do much, its all her, and the marks are supossed to be for the "celebrities". for example, they are critically judging the other paris on the celebrities, but when it comes to mahesh and sonia, ugh. you get the point, and im pretty sure that even if you dont want to agree with me, inside, you know that what im saying is right. T

his whole idea outrages me, because it should be that the best dancer wins, but in this case, it seems as if that doesnt apply. This show is now moving towards its critcal stages, and the judges keep saying, "raise the bar" and how its all about the performance, but when they go to judge, where does that thought go? jab judging ka time ata hai, to "raise the bar /jude according to performance" jata hai tail bechnay. Im specially hurt by Farah. She's seems the most bias of all the judges, and whenever they ask her to speak first, the fellow judges repeat exactly what she says. whoever she speaks first for gets low marks, rahter then when they ask sanjay ji or shilpa.

I had so much respecet for the judges, but i dont feel the same anymore. maybe i shouldnt have watched this show to begin with. Im sorry if i have offended any of you, but i had to speak my mind. On a happier note, Correct me if im wrong, but Jhalak Dikhhla Ja has given us a chance to see that these celebreties are human just like us, and i really like seeing them in a competition, becuase it shows us the best and worst in them. Cheers.

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

1.9k

Users

13

Frequent Posters

blyton thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
Wow....i think yours was the perfect analysis and said what i had been wanting to say for a long time.

SLB himself said today "Mahesh ki sau galtiyan maaf!" I guess that sums up the attitude of the judges. 😡
kiranb06 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3

I disagree with you there. Look we all have our favorites, everybody has different tastes. There are people who absolutely LOVE Karan Johar films, and there are people who absolutely hate them.

Likewise, just because you don't like Mahesh, doesn't mean that most people don't. It's not JUST the judges' votes that counted here, but also the mass public. I can speak for myself and my friends/family.. we absolutely LOVed watching Mahesh.. in fact, every week we're waiting with baited breath to see what he would do this time.

The judges are not biased... they're judging based on their own judgment as to who really is good. They're human too and likewise have their own tastes as well. Shilpa gave Akash a 10 at one point while the other two gave less. They've all given Shveta the points she deserved. Another example, SLB loves having Aish Rai in his movies, whereas I like Sush better. Some like Shah Rukh, while others like Amir Khan. Doesn't mean you criticize the judges for not agreeing with you!!! What makes any one of us true Judges?!

A few days ago I was thinking, shveta is the best dancer, followed by mona, but if mahesh weren't around, we wouldn't get variety and entertainment. Dance again has a lot to do with emotions and passion, not technicality. Trust me, i know a thing or two about music and dance! (that's an understatement, by the way)! I love Amitabh Bacchan, but if you watch his older movies, he wasn't a totally exceptional dancer...he pretty much had the same style..his own style.. there were definitely better dancers than him, namely Rishi Kapoor, etc.. but because Amitji had the personality, the emotions in his dancing, he became a rage. Likewise with Mahesh. He has his own style and a lot of people love it. Look, again, we all have our opinions.. not everybody likes the same kind of food, same kind of dance.. so in that way, some of us like mahesh, and some don't.

Edited by kiranb06 - 18 years ago
NKSUDHIR thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
You said it all. I think all the judges are biased towards Mahesh. Today, they showed their double standards when they said," RAISE THE BAR" to Mona's excellent performance and "Tumahri sau galati maaf" for Mahesh. Not fair at all.
tina59 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#5

There are some valid points here but then the only problem here is are the judges CONSISTENT.One on epoint they balme the other contestants for some flaws that they have but then they glorify the same for mahesh.Thats where eyeballs are rised coz we think "hello u just now said tht wasnt good abt the other contestant " and now u are praising the same .

iF THE JUDGES ALSO HAVE THEIR FAVS THEN THEY SHOULDNT BE ASKED TO JUDGE.a JUDGE HAS TO BE FAIR AND UNBAISED .

No one blames mahesh for his performance ,he is doing his best and i I def agree that he is a great entertainer but its the judges who are showing partiality and not being consistent in their remarks and scoring.

This is the same for every reality show and No one can do anything abt it .

NKSUDHIR thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: kiranb06

I disagree with you there. Look we all have our favorites, everybody has different tastes. There are people who absolutely LOVE Karan Johar films, and there are people who absolutely hate them.

Likewise, just because you don't like Mahesh, doesn't mean that most people don't. It's not JUST the judges' votes that counted here, but also the mass public. I can speak for myself and my friends/family.. we absolutely LOVed watching Mahesh.. in fact, every week we're waiting with baited breath to see what he would do this time.

The judges are not biased... they're judging based on their own judgment as to who really is good. They're human too and likewise have their own tastes as well. Shilpa gave Akash a 10 at one point while the other two gave less. They've all given Shveta the points she deserved. Another example, SLB loves having Aish Rai in his movies, whereas I like Sush better. Some like Shah Rukh, while others like Amir Khan. Doesn't mean you criticize the judges for not agreeing with you!!! What makes any one of us true Judges?!

A few days ago I was thinking, shveta is the best dancer, followed by mona, but if mahesh weren't around, we wouldn't get variety and entertainment. Dance again has a lot to do with emotions and passion, not technicality. Trust me, i know a thing or two about music and dance! (that's an understatement, by the way)! I love Amitabh Bacchan, but if you watch his older movies, he wasn't a totally exceptional dancer...he pretty much had the same style..his own style.. there were definitely better dancers than him, namely Rishi Kapoor, etc.. but because Amitji had the personality, the emotions in his dancing, he became a rage. Likewise with Mahesh. He has his own style and a lot of people love it. Look, again, we all have our opinions.. not everybody likes the same kind of food, same kind of dance.. so in that way, some of us like mahesh, and some don't.

I totally understand what you are saying but judges should not clealry say for one," Raise the bar" and for other one," Tumahri sau galatian maaf." What is this all about??? Judges are definitely biased.

teelobhain thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
Well i think thats its not a reality show and i dont think anyone is actually worried about the voting system either - shveta is bound to winn not matter what mahesh is goona be second last and the third last couple would be mona and toby; unlike fame gurukul or indian idol we have actually seen that the people have voted and hence baysuray singer like sandeep and qazi won so its so obvious - as far as i know the indian population just loves ajay and he should have won if people would have actually voted. shveta though a very good dancer indeed but dont you think people dont actually care since they never cared who was the better singer in indian idol sandeep of karuniya and they voted for the better looking one and nott he better singer so i guess its all a made up concept and all
stiletto thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: tina59

There are some valid points here but then the only problem here is are the judges CONSISTENT.One on epoint they balme the other contestants for some flaws that they have but then they glorify the same for mahesh.Thats where eyeballs are rised coz we think "hello u just now said tht wasnt good abt the other contestant " and now u are praising the same .

iF THE JUDGES ALSO HAVE THEIR FAVS THEN THEY SHOULDNT BE ASKED TO JUDGE.a JUDGE HAS TO BE FAIR AND UNBAISED .

No one blames mahesh for his performance ,he is doing his best and i I def agree that he is a great entertainer but its the judges who are showing partiality and not being consistent in their remarks and scoring.

This is the same for every reality show and No one can do anything abt it .



well the public is allowed to judge and vote and as we all know they only vote for their favourites. so basically no one should be allowed to judge according to what you are saying.
victorygirl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
yah buddy i agree with u on this ....so true !

but i still have my hope to see mona the winner 😛
kothra thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10
I agree with u..
mona n shevta both got 51..so this time it will b mona aur shevta to go..
i knw mahesh will b in a final

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".