JDJ4 losing its charm??????? - Page 5

Originally posted by: nikitagmc

My dear, my favourite in the previous seasons of JDJ was not a dancer.😃 It was a non-dancer. In the first season, my favourite was Mahesh Manjrekar, second I didn't see, and in the third it was Baichung Bhutia. So your claim that I am saying it cos my favourite is a trained dancer doesn't stand here.

I wrote the whole post as an unbiased opinion putting ahead my reasons and not simply as a fan.

About the points that you made that competition should be between equals- yes- agreed, but tell me, aren't Sushant and other soap stars at a disadvantage as well cos they don't even get time to rehearse that much? Then why hasn't the channel kept either all soap stars or none to create a balance in the competition?

Cos they want a random mix! And that is my point.

None of us would have watched JDJ in the beginning episodes if there had only been non-dancers like Akhil. Not many were fans of Chang's dancing too. These people grew on us slowly in the episodes. But we wouldn't have gone ahead and kept watching the show if there had been some good or at least average performances in the beginning.

I know there is no conclusion to this debate, it has happened in the past too. I just wanted to clear out that its not as if since my favourite is a dancer so I'm favouring this trend. Its nothing like that.

Originally posted by: blyton

I agree, it has lost its charm. Now all we get to see are people's personal lives and the same old comments from Madhuri--"mera chota packet", "aap aaj bahut sundar lag rahi ho", "you bring so much SOUL to every performance", "you do something new each time", "very nice, very entertaining"; and Remo's "this is IT" for every second performance. Oh, not to forget the celeb appearances to promote their films.👎🏼

Originally posted by: -smiley-

exactly what i felt i agree with each and every word what you said

judges are not realizing the improving talent Ragini really improved a lot.......but that is not appreciated and last weeks ragin's performance is really better than sushant and she got 23 and sushan 27 i felt really unfair and Mahi OMG i thought she would have left JDJ than Daya she is at he same place where she is performing low but ankita got eliminated and mahi is till there true talent is not appreciated

love ur post Saaki 🤗

Originally posted by: --Saaki--

@ Blue : K dear........Thats true no point in doing debate........But,I really hope there is improvement in atleast some dance forms & themes........I wanna see Indian Classiacal..........😊

Originally posted by: Tannistha

Originally posted by: shivani003

I agree with ur points about trained dancers being on the show. I mean there's too much a large spectrum when it comes to the level of dancing amongst the contestants. Take that boxer guy n Shekhar vs. almost perfect Sushant. I love Sushant n he's one of my favs but if he was to be on this show then it would have been more fun if the ppl amongst him were at a similar level.... The casting directors have done done a very poor job this year in the desperate greed for trps.😡

Originally posted by: blyton

This is actually the sore point about this season! First, they dropped many contestants to make the show more "high-profile" after Madhuri came in (and I am wondering if it was all worth the trouble, she is definitely not one of the best judges this show has seen) ....then the ones they got, were not of the same level or even nearly so. It is like starting a race with some sprinters standing many steps ahead of the start line. Secondly, by now it has become clear that some pairs were brought in on the basis of their personal equation: Sushant-Ankita, Krushna-Ragini, and no wonder rumours are flying about Sushant "threatening" the channel to bring back Ankita. He may not have done it, but if anyone suspects foul play in Ankita's return, he would be the first suspect. All this has spoilt the atmosphere and dampened enthusiasm about the show.

Originally posted by: tiya229

i agree with you guys... there was a CLEAR imbalance between the contestants. where sushant, ragini, ankita, yana were stronger in terms of skill, ability and partner, the others like akhil, shekar mahi have lost out. right from the beginning itself, it was kind of obvious who was going to be the TOP 5 and it wasnt going to be shekar, akhil, renuka..

so yes, they should have brought in contestants like reshmi desai, etc who have potential, skill, and revelant fan base.

and i dont get why the show was re-vamped for madhuri? her job is to judge, does it matter WHO she judges? and so far she has been way to neutral, borrowing all her remarks from remo.