This is completely unfair - Page 2

I agree with you.

Originally posted by: kannine1

well in the last episode hard kaur was clearly better than karan and Monica...and it is obvious she is a superior dancer...Karan may be working hard but they all are. He isnt doing anything that special. parul also has a daily show and also works hard and puts in lots of ours.

its his job to work hard for the show....and its all for money.

U should feel bad for ppl like Gauhar who is the best dancer and not only according to me but also according to saroj khan. and she will not win cause she is not popular like karan and parul even though she has put in as many hours as them and as much hard work as they have

I am assuming that you accept that Karan works hard...right? Now that we have established that Karan does work hard like everyone else, I will move on to point # 2.

The format of the show is public voting right? So if Karan gets more votes because he is popular and works hard...why is that a problem? Why hate on Karan and/or his popularity? Write to the channel and have them change the format...let the judges have the final word and let Baichung win...even with Judges decision I gaurantee Gauher will not win. It is unfair to ask Karan to be apologetic for his popularity...he earned his fan base and they support him....it's a democracy after all...right?

Thirdly, Jhalak just like Dancing with the Stars is about celebrity non dancer....do you agree that the likes of Gauher and Hard Kaur know dancing before they entered the show? Hard Kaur is from the music industry and performs on stage, she has a definite advantage....Gauhar is a model and has danced in numerous music videos...so there is her advantage....so this puts Karan at a disadvantage because the playing field is not leveled at all? I am sure no Karan basher would notice this fact...that the man is competing with stage performers and dancers.

Regarding Parul...she is a from a daily soap I agree.....does she not use the line, "I am from the most popular show with highest TRP..please vote for me" ? I did not see her mentioning her dance skills in her voting apeal!

I support Karan and I am unapologetic about it!

Originally posted by: kannine1

well in the last episode hard kaur was clearly better than karan and Monica...and it is obvious she is a superior dancer...Karan may be working hard but they all are. He isnt doing anything that special. parul also has a daily show and also works hard and puts in lots of ours.

its his job to work hard for the show....and its all for money.

U should feel bad for ppl like Gauhar who is the best dancer and not only according to me but also according to saroj khan. and she will not win cause she is not popular like karan and parul even though she has put in as many hours as them and as much hard work as they have

@kannine1
i definitely agree with you about the Gauhar thing. It really sucks when good contestants get out because they aren't getting votes. But then again, this is a reality show, and thats the problem with all reality shows. almost always, only the most popular end up winning.

most people agree that gauhar is a good dancer but the reason for her not getting audience and not being as popular on the show is again herself and the controversies she has been in on the show so far. People say that she is a good dancer but they don't want to vote for her because they don't like what she did to hanif, they don't like her attitude or they don't like what she says on the show.
Some others didn't get many votes in the beginning but as the show progressed people liked them and their dancing and started voting for them like Hard Kaur (in the first few episodes they said she was barely saved and didn't get many votes...i will also admit i didn't like her otherwise but the show changed my mind....and i like her now) Monica (also didn't get many votes in the beginning) Shilpa (also didn't get many votes in the beginning) both monica and shilpa have ended up in faceoff because of that also but now all of them get good votes. Yet Gauhar from day 1 did not get the audience support and she herself is the reason for that, she needs to change her attitude a little bit if she wants the audience support. It is wrong to hold Karan's or Baichung's popularity against them in audience votes.....People will support who they like

You are totally right sweet heart! totally agree with u! its just not fair well karan deserves to win because he have improved soooo much and thats what jdj is about he is really much deserving he is an awesome dancer!

Even though this is a reality show.. ppl.. should know when to vote and when to not... just casue Gauhar didn't get votes is not only becuz of Karan.. there are others too.. and Gauhar might have not achieved to every level ppl expected...

gauhar is making herself stuck in so many controversies that ppl don't want to vote for her... its not just that Karan has most votes.. it depends on the person...

Originally posted by: hope4u

well, its true that all the contestants keep bringing his popularity to the front.. Maybe because they r all jealous. 😆 . come on, everybody would want a fanbase like he has got. imagine if international voting was allowed.. they might as well stop all the rounds and send hard kaur and karan straight to the finals in that case. 😃 .
but at the same time what they r all saying is right. you see the trend, the lowest scorers come in the face off. the only guy who has defied this logic is karan. he was safe even when he got 19, when technically, he and ram should have been in the face off. even parul, who has a good fan base came in the face off when she got 19. that's because only karan has a fanbase who vote twice as hard to make up for his marks. here, i completely agree with what gauhar says. even if karan gets 8, he'll not be in the face off coz he has a fanbase which will vote 10 times to make up for his score, which is honestly not fair.
having said that, i dont think karan is here only because of his votes. he has given some average, good and brilliant performances. and deserves to be here. he is definitely better than the contestants who have gone out till now. in my opinion, its time for baichung to leave. inspite of his record 30'which is purely coz of judges drooling over " ohh chhoo chweeet" baichung. then it should be parul, monica and then honestly karan. finals in my opinion should be hard kaur, gauhar and shilpa.coz they r the best in terns of dance and improvement right now. hard kaur and gauhar however have been good dancer from day 1. if u see their graph, it was always high and its remained like that. the others however have grown from strength to strength. so looking at it that way, finals should be shilpa, karan... and anybody else..

😆

i completely agree with u. but it is not always fair that it is always thrown in the face that he is there just because of popularity. i completely believe that now once he makes a mistake and gets low scores he will be in the dance off and he will be out. it should also be seen that what he was what he is. i beileve he is was a very nervous and a out of beat and stiff dancer. and to see him do what he has done on this stage is a surprise for all who have seen him before. this is because of his hard work and willingness to learn. and i feel if this fact do not take him ahead in jdj its fine but it should be apprieciated.

Originally posted by: Dr.KaranSG

I am assuming that you accept that Karan works hard...right? Now that we have established that Karan does work hard like everyone else, I will move on to point # 2.

The format of the show is public voting right? So if Karan gets more votes because he is popular and works hard...why is that a problem? Why hate on Karan and/or his popularity? Write to the channel and have them change the format...let the judges have the final word and let Baichung win...even with Judges decision I gaurantee Gauher will not win. It is unfair to ask Karan to be apologetic for his popularity...he earned his fan base and they support him....it's a democracy after all...right?

Thirdly, Jhalak just like Dancing with the Stars is about celebrity non dancer....do you agree that the likes of Gauher and Hard Kaur know dancing before they entered the show? Hard Kaur is from the music industry and performs on stage, she has a definite advantage....Gauhar is a model and has danced in numerous music videos...so there is her advantage....so this puts Karan at a disadvantage because the playing field is not leveled at all? I am sure no Karan basher would notice this fact...that the man is competing with stage performers and dancers.

Regarding Parul...she is a from a daily soap I agree.....does she not use the line, "I am from the most popular show with highest TRP..please vote for me" ? I did not see her mentioning her dance skills in her voting apeal!

I support Karan and I am unapologetic about it!

completely agree with u
the contestants selected r not on the same level of dancing. gauhar hard kaur r definately wonderful dancers infact even parul and shilpa can move
but does this mean that they will be winning only
if that was the case the result would have been declared in the first episode only why so many episodes and all the unnecessary hard work from all the others
what about progress and change from the initial stage. isnt that important

i am sorry if this sound rude

Originally posted by: av10dulkar

completely agree with u
the contestants selected r not on the same level of dancing. gauhar hard kaur r definately wonderful dancers infact even parul and shilpa can move
but does this mean that they will be winning only
if that was the case the result would have been declared in the first episode only why so many episodes and all the unnecessary hard work from all the others
what about progress and change from the initial stage. isnt that important

i am sorry if this sound rude

Thanks....I am glad you saw my points as fair....its not fair to Karan to be competing with dancers on the show and people conveniently forget that point! They only focus on his fan base!