Weakest out of semifinalists ? - Page 2

Originally posted by: salmangirl

Dancing wise gurmeet is weakest..He din improved..he is still the same as 1st week..

Definetely Bharti & Gurmeet (no bashing plz to his fans)!!!

Simply coz of level of difficulty others r attempting & that they r working but GC kinda lost his touch on Jhalak competition now, hez better off acting!!! No que of being hardworking n decent but not par to semi-finals!!!

Gurmeet is the weakest. But as I said before, He is the winner.

IMO dance wise Gurmeet definitely is the weakest. And when I say improvement, it is solely because of Shampa. She knows how to work around his weakness and make use of whatever dance or postures he is capable of. For me he is still at the same level of dancing he was since week 1 and it was obvious in his Saturday's performance. Only when it comes to emotional acts, since his expressions and body language are good, he takes over Shampa and it makes sense him being an actor.

It really confuses me how he is going to stand up against Rithvik, Isha or Rashmi in the finale face off if he were to emerge out as a winner.

On a side note, I loved the thing he did with his stomach muscles, that is some talent.

Originally posted by: Me_Anonymous

Purely based on dance, out of those four: it's Gurmeet. But he has shown a lot of improvement as well (it's visible in most of his performances). Compare his first performance and even this Saturday's episode (15th September) - that was a bad performance but wayyy better than his first ever performance. So he did really well on the show👏.

Every other contestant has weaknesses too but it's just that Gurmeet's is more visible - the others are better at hiding them or lucky that we haven't really noticed them as much.

The finals will be ONLY Judges decision so I don't really think voting bank matters anymore in the show. Or am I wrong? Voting + Judges = Winner or just Judges score = Winner?

I honestly hope that person wins who performed the BEST in the finale, not making someone a winner including previous performances too - it would be un fair to all because those who were her from the beginning had more time to show different things/concepts/dance forms etc on stage while those who came later in the competition don't have the 'faitgue' which most of those who were in from the beginning suffered from at some point in the show so they never got a chance to go through the 'bad performance phase' - so in that way the judging scale is not really on the same level/standard.

But if it's just Finale performance then it's on the same scale IMO.

Thanks for the explanation ME_Anonymous.. I am so lost about the finale and semifinals..

Originally posted by: vgiri

Thanks for the explanation ME_Anonymous.. I am so lost about the finale and semifinals..

What they recorded today, did Isha dance? Do contestents require public voting..

If they do not require voting on coming saturday and sunday, it is good.. votes is the issue for Rithvik..

Sorry vigiri. It's not an explanation. It was just my wishful thinking which I was hoping someone would confirm (I am assuming you are talking about the winner being judged on finale performance alone and not previous ones)😳

Yes, the recording today, Isha did dance and as per *Spolier* she scored 30.

I think the finals will have 3 contestants and as per *Spoiler* since Bharti is out this coming week (22 and 23 Sep) for next week as in 29th & 30th September episode will have Rashmi, Isha, Gurmeet and Rithvik and I think one more will be eliminated to get down to 3 total contestants - so yes Voting will happen but not in the Finale as only judges scores matter then but in semi-finals, I think voting and scores are both combined.

so to break it down for my own understanding and others too:

22 & 23 Sep - Semi-Finale - Bharti elimination (so 4 contestants left) - contestants will most definitely require votes so that they stay in the competition for next week too i.e. 29 & 30 Sep

29 & 30 Sep - Finale - one more elimination so we will be left with 3 contestants when the performances for this Finale episodes start. But after the performances, I don't think contestants will need vote as winner will be decided only by Judges scores

^ this is what I know and understood so I could be wrong

so we have 2 more weeks to go as in 4 more episodes and then JDJ5 ends😛

I don't think that Jhalak's winner has ever been decided by the judges marks alone..its a combination of both

😲 Hold on,