Compare only this weeks performance for eliminatio - Page 2

Siddhi... What they have made up in mind that if gia survives elimination than its scripted and if shibani survives its not scripted...

When shibani scores low why can't she be eliminated... If she survives i will doubt jdj is scripted... But see the posts above... They will try to say show is scripted if gia survives but no one is talking about shibanis low score ...

i really don't understands,..why people bahind of gia,..bharathi also got low scores,...why nobody is talking about her,...becoz,..she is funny,..,.this is double standard,.

sincerely i think too shibani should be out or gia...shibani is being protected out there...don't know why i have this feeling everytime madhuri talks with her and yes one more thing bharathi is not an extraordinary dancer but frankly if there is no bharthi i will watch only isha performance n thats all...she is the reason who make me attached to jdj...each weekend she make me laugh man...love her😛

No body is against Gia. You guys are only defending her because you guys are her fans. Like I said I am not a fan of Shibani but what matters to me the most is how hard and dedicated someone is to learn to dance and how consistent they have been.

@Bhavya @ Siddhi - Please read my post, no where have I said that I have a problem with Gia. Gia has scored lower than Shibani many times yet Shibani kept coming in the bottom while Gia wasn't. Why did you guys not say then that because Gia's scores were lower than Shibani she should have been eliminated. Why are you saying it only now when it's the first time Shibani has scored so low while Gia has scored higher than her. Also, Darsheel has been consistently scoring 27 and 29 yet he kept on coming in the bottom while Gia was not even though her scores were lower than his. How come you guys never felt that it's been unfair to Darsheel.

Yes I agree that Bharti should have been eliminated a long time ago but maybe the show is scripted which is why they are keeping Bharti, because she is entertaining people. For me personally, I feel that Bharti should be eliminated but I do applaud bharti for learning to dance. No one is mentioning Bharti because the topic maker did not mention her.

Anyways, don't worry, Shibani is going to be eliminated next week for sure because she keeps on coming in the bottom 3 and now that her marks are low she will be eliminated for sure.

^^ god elimination is done already dont know who got Eliminated... Sorry i could not read ur above post properly...

Pray gia should not be...

gia is not eliminated becoz,..she had fan follg,.who voted for her,..and who see jdj only becoz,.of gia,..this time karan also get less vote,...becoz,.of votes he will not eliminate,..same with gia,..before 1/2 times,.guru got less vote,..but he also not came in bottom,...becoz,.of fans votes,.judges are giving their marks,...fans are giving their votes,.

Originally posted by: bhavya

^^ god elimination is done already dont know who got Eliminated... Sorry i could not read ur above post properly...

Pray gia should not be...

That's okay. I was in no way saying anything bad about Gia or any of the other contestants. For me, dance comes first. I wasn't a fan of anyone but I do have my favourites after watching the show, solely based on how these contestants are dancing and nothing else. Like mentioned by others, there are many people who only watch the show for a contestant they are a fan of from before and they will do everything to keep them in the show regardless. You asked for everyone's opinion and I was simply giving mine in a kind manner and I don't think I have said anything mean about any of the contestants in my posts. In fact, even if someone is a weaker dancer, I can still find things I like about them and can appreciate about them. It's unfortunate you did not read my post properly or else you will see that I have also said some good things about Gia.

I do think Shibani is a better dancer than most of the telly celebrities. And I hope JDJ plans to keep her for a bit longer. In the last few seasons the underdogs have been chosen as the winner (Baichung/Meiyang) who actually improved their dancing skills. Shibani does fall in the same category as the previous winners. Problem with Gia is that her dancing hasn't really improved much, yes she has come up with something new everything week but her scores have remain constant. Shibani and Puneet bring something new every week but with slight improvements. Just the past week was a lil disappointing for them. I still think they could've gotten a few more points than 23. Bharti is another issue for me, I don't think she's that great a dancer and in all honesty I want see her ousted before Gia Manek. I don't know why she's been outshone more than anyone else on the show with her same old fat jokes and lack of dancing skills. This isn't a comedy show, it's a dance show and she isn't a great dancer and Savio has really disappointed us this season.

Originally posted by: 416905

I do think Shibani is a better dancer than most of the telly celebrities. And I hope JDJ plans to keep her for a bit longer. In the last few seasons the underdogs have been chosen as the winner (Baichung/Meiyang) who actually improved their dancing skills. Shibani does fall in the same category as the previous winners. Problem with Gia is that her dancing hasn't really improved much, yes she has come up with something new everything week but her scores have remain constant. Shibani and Puneet bring something new every week but with slight improvements. Just the past week was a lil disappointing for them. I still think they could've gotten a few more points than 23. Bharti is another issue for me, I don't think she's that great a dancer and in all honesty I want see her ousted before Gia Manek. I don't know why she's been outshone more than anyone else on the show with her same old fat jokes and lack of dancing skills. This isn't a comedy show, it's a dance show and she isn't a great dancer and Savio has really disappointed us this season.

Agreed! Last season, I went in as a fan of Meiyang and his improvement was tremendous plus he had the untapped potential of a dancer from the very beginning but by the middle I wanted Sushant to win because he was the most consistent. Just because I was a fan of Meiyang Chang does not mean I blindly supported him, Sushant proved that he was a better dancer after working hard and along with Shampa came up with really creative concepts while Meiyang was close he wasn't as good.

I am not a fan of Shibani, I am actually indifferent to her but I like her personality better than the others there, she always congratulates and hugs people after their performance. She has also shown the most improvement amongst the others, she dances well (like you mentioned, better than a few of the telly celebs) and works hard but she doesn't have the fan following to back her up. I appreciate her for these things but also feel sorry for her.

I applaud Gia for always trying something new and she showed a lot of improvement in the beginning but now she has plateaued and there is no more improvement. She needs to focus more on what the judges are telling her to do. Also, Nishant needs to invest in her more. Disappointed in him this season.

Bharti should also have been eliminated a long time ago. The jokes are indeed getting old and some aren't even funny. I find that Manish is enough entertainment by himself, he is so spontaneous plus I always get a good laugh when he says stuff to Nishant, Savio or the others. Bharti has been getting too much screen time while the others have not been promoted much. Bharti is only being kept for the entertainment quotient but I am sorry good dancing is enough entertainment for me. I am not disappointed in Savio as such because, in a team you are only as strong as the weakest player, Savio can only do so much with Bharti unless she focuses more on the dancing.

p.s. thank-you for the very, rational, coherent, and unbiased post

Gia is eliminated!