Compare only this weeks performance for eliminatio

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

veena

@VEENAGOPAL

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#21

Guys feeling sorry that GIA got eliminated

i defo hopeed she will stay till end..but it happened...cheer her for wat she did until now

Quote

chocobear

@chocobear

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

#22

Finally. Thank Goodness if this news is true. That girl always got on my nerves. Good riddance.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Vidisha

@Veni-Vidi-Vici

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: chocobear
Finally. Thank Goodness if this news is true. That girl always got on my nerves. Good riddance.

same here😆

Quote

megustajalebi

@megustajalebi

Voyager

Posted: 13 years ago

#24

If Shibani was eliminated before Gia, then I would be convinced that the show was badly scripted.

Sure Shibani got lower scores this past week (which I don't think she deserved), but she's given better performances than Gia overall. This isn't just about one performance, it's about evaluating the whole picture. After all, do you really think a person who has earned multiple 30's would get eliminated before someone who only earned one 30?

Quote

416905

@416905

Voyager

Posted: 13 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: canuck-umz

Bharti should also have been eliminated a long time ago. The jokes are indeed getting old and some aren't even funny. I find that Manish is enough entertainment by himself, he is so spontaneous plus I always get a good laugh when he says stuff to Nishant, Savio or the others. Bharti has been getting too much screen time while the others have not been promoted much. Bharti is only being kept for the entertainment quotient but I am sorry good dancing is enough entertainment for me. I am not disappointed in Savio as such because, in a team you are only as strong as the weakest player, Savio can only do so much with Bharti unless she focuses more on the dancing.

p.s. thank-you for the very, rational, coherent, and unbiased post

You're welcome! It's always nice to have a sane discussion without the fear of being bombarded by the campers! And I am actually sad that Gia became the victim of the TRPs race. I still do not support Bharti's stay as a dancer in JDJ. If the network loves her so much they can chose to make her an anchor once she is eliminated fairly and squarely. I also think she was given marks keeping her comic and weight issues in mind. None of her dances have actually deserved anything beyond 25 barring last week's performance. In all honesty I've seen people heavier than Bharti dance way better than her. It's just sad that she's getting unfair treatment, besides I would love to know how much votes all these celebrities get. Even though Im not a Gia Manek fan, I can see how popualar she was as Gopi, there's no way Bharti's scoring more votes than her. I don't mean to come across as a Bharti hater, it's just that she really did deserve to go before Gia.

Quote

-Nafisa-

@-Nafisa-

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#26

Yes the show is scripted, Giaa and Karan Wahi have more fans then Shibani. Giaa would have received more votes then Shibani so baised on votes alone Shibani would be out, rather then Giaa.

But the people that go in the bottom 3 are never the ones with the lowest scores, as Sushil Kumar went in the bottom 3 even though he scored 27 points, he was also eliminated with a high score. So that doesn't matter, it's the votes the viewers give when they send SMS that matter, that is what jdj would like us to believe.

But...

When we were calling Uday Shankar CEO of Star Plus, in the first 2 week's of Giaa's replacement he said that Giaa Manek was tied to a 2 month contract with Jhalak dikhla jaa, at the time we all thought that is the length of the show, but then the first few weeks nobody was eliminated and then they introduced more people in the show and instead of the group getting smaller we have as big a group as from the beginning of the show, 2 months has arrived 16th June 2012 to 15th August 2012 and Giaa Manek is eliminated, last week some people even sent 300 SMS votes, now I'm thinking of that 2 months contract with Giaa and what that has to do with the elimination rather then the votes she received on Sunday.

Now to Mr Uday Shankar, don't you think that excuse of her being tied to a contract and her not being able to come back to Star Plus whilst she was in that contract should give us hope now?

Don't feel your hopes are dashed that she didn't win or progress to the final of jdj, feel instead okay it's scripted and her contract was for 2 months and she is out because of that. Therefore, Star Plus is not going to see this as Giaa has less support that's why she is out of the show. Rather, they will see it as her contract finishing with that employer, so we should now go back to Uday Shankar and remind him that he said he could do nothing about bringing Giaa back because of the that contract with jdj, that had her tied to Colors.

So Star Plus is not going to see Giaa's elimination as her having less support from fans voting in SMS and online for her to stay, rather her contract ran it's course and she is out of the show now because of that.

Quote

@TheRowdiest

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 13 years ago

#27

if ppl r talking abt fan base ...then Ravi kissan is the super star yet he went out and he never got so low marks , (even say it was biased marking )...his average was 26 ... he never got so low marks

Quote

Jane Doe

@Jane_Doe

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#28

I dont care as long as the better dancer stays... Though its sad to see Gia leave, especially when she left SNS for this show... But still Shibani is an awesome dancer, and i didnt find her performance bad enough to get her eliminated...

Quote

686375

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

#29

this is funny ...first people dought kartey hai juges ki marking pe ,khuch time baad usi marking ko point batna ke elimination pe dought kartey hai now in logo ko prob hai jisey itni baar 30 mila vo out kese ho sakti hai khuch time pahley usi key perfect 30 ko unfair bata rhey they ...acco to me ***** ko out hona chahiye becharee shammpa thak gyi hai new style envent kartey kartey 😆😆

****name calling of contestant not allowed

Edited by tannipartner - 13 years ago

Quote

hridayh

@hridayh

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

#30

Originally posted by: megustajalebi
If Shibani was eliminated before Gia, then I would be convinced that the show was badly scripted.

Sure Shibani got lower scores this past week (which I don't think she deserved), but she's given better performances than Gia overall. This isn't just about one performance, it's about evaluating the whole picture. After all, do you really think a person who has earned multiple 30's would get eliminated before someone who only earned one 30?

now nwext turn may be karan or guru,..shibani is far better dancer than them,...so guru//karan should be eliminate,...