Should Isha be judge or a contestant?

Page

Hibernated

Posted: 13 years ago

First the Jhalak show is for non dancers to perform. This one is par excellence. She might exceed Madhuri in dancing capabalities. What is she doing there as a contestant, which is not the right platform for her to show her talent? It is unfair for her as well as other contestants.

Quote

Frequent Posters

Arnav90

@Arnav90

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 13 years ago

So you mean only Talat, Sanath, Susheel, Archana n Bharati deserve to be the contestant bcoz except them all know dancing...

New ID only for saying this

Edited by Arnav90 - 13 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

nishu786

@nishu786

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: usrfan
First the Jhalak show is for non dancers to perform. This one is par excellence. She might exceed Madhuri in dancing capabalities. What is she doing there as a contestant, which is not the right platform for her to show her talent? It is unfair for her as well as other contestants.

Mam/Sir

you could have said the same thing by ur real id 😆...why making new id to say your view.

Gauhar khan & yana gupta were also trained dancer in previous season,this is not the first time a trained dancer is participating.

Quote

51559

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

Not again

Ab phir se argue karna parega yaar 😒

btw another ID for proving the useless point... 🤣

Quote

chocobear

@chocobear

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

apne real ID se hi bol dete...our response would still have been the same🤣

Quote

Minz aka Minnie

@*Dakoo_Minzy*

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

Isha and Salman do the maximum practice,that's the sole reason they get marks. 😎 😎

Edited by *Dakoo_Minzy* - 13 years ago

Quote

Minz aka Minnie

@*Dakoo_Minzy*

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

Isha is my favourite tis season! I'm glad she's there in JDJ 5 😃 Or else i would have missed such classy performances from Salman and Isha 😳

Edited by *Dakoo_Minzy* - 13 years ago

Quote

disha

@Conqueror212

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: usrfan
First the Jhalak show is for non dancers to perform. This one is par excellence. She might exceed Madhuri in dancing capabalities. What is she doing there as a contestant, which is not the right platform for her to show her talent? It is unfair for her as well as other contestants.

JDJ was never a non-dancers show... its about "dancing with the stars"
every season we had dancer participants(stars)...
and this made other contestants work hard...
its fun... for audiences.. as they can enjoy good performances
and also for other contestants... as they have to cross milestone set by their fellow participants

Quote

Vinder90

@Vinder90

Dazzler

Posted: 13 years ago

yeah. . anyone absolutely anyone can be on JDJ. . its not specifically for non-dancers. .

one of the first things that judges also said is that the talent on JDJ is varied and judging is done based on that. . it means . . in JDJ no one is at the same level. . if they are its coincidence. . its meant to be like that. . dancers/ non-dancers/ trained/not trained. . all have a right to be in jdj. .

Quote

Nida

@NinnzGm

Voyager

Posted: 13 years ago

#10

I kinda agree!

I'm not saying this as GC fan but I think that the contest is unfair when Isha is there..

I mean even if people like GC, Shibani and Gia are improving day by day and giving their best they will never be able to become better than Isha during this competition.. and Isha will always have the upper hand..

Let's say that Isha wins JDJ (based on talent) will it be fair for the rest of the contestant when they clearly already know that she is the best..

why did they even compete??

and if she doesn't win then it's unfair and weird cuz that's like denying her talent and the truth is that she is the most talented of them all..

she doesn't belong in this competition she belongs in something much bigger than this..