DANCE CRITIQUE CORNER *not a gushing thread* - Page 8

It's Okay mere stalkers ki Jai Jai

I thought that this week the judges were by far the most unfair to Pratyusha.

Pratyusha's dance was definitely one of the best this week. In my opinion, it was the second best after Isha/Salman. I mean I totally get it if you guys don't agree it was the second best but at least we can acknowledge that it was one of the better performances. It had the most dance, performed really well, and on top of that thing with not a lot of room to dance. And I didn't even notice where she made a mistake!

However, what score did she get? The lowest. She got the same score as the rest of the lowest performances. Now tell me how is that fair? How the hek did she get the same score as Gurmeet and Talat? Her performance was much much better than theirs.

Forget about lowest, Sanath, Sushil, Archana, and Ravi scored better than her!!! Are you kidding me? Their dance was better than Pratyusha's?I am not saying she deserves a 30 or a 27. No. But she most definitely did not deserve the lowest score.

I know judges are being unfair quite often this season. And I totally get that Salman/Isha may have not deserved that 30. I agree with that. But at least it was acknowledged that their performance was the best because their performance was the best even if they did not deserve a 30.

I thought Pratyusha's score was the most unfair this week.

Originally posted by: lolo234

I thought that this week the judges were by far the most unfair to Pratyusha.

Pratyusha's dance was definitely one of the best this week. In my opinion, it was the second best after Isha/Salman. I mean I totally get it if you guys don't agree it was the second best but at least we can acknowledge that it was one of the better performances. It had the most dance, performed really well, and on top of that thing with not a lot of room to dance. And I didn't even notice where she made a mistake!

However, what score did she get? The lowest. She got the same score as the rest of the lowest performances. Now tell me how is that fair? How the hek did she get the same score as Gurmeet and Talat? Her performance was much much better than theirs.

Forget about lowest, Sanath, Sushil, Archana, and Ravi scored better than her!!! Are you kidding me? Their dance was better than Pratyusha's?I am not saying she deserves a 30 or a 27. No. But she most definitely did not deserve the lowest score.

I know judges are being unfair quite often this season. And I totally get that Salman/Isha may have not deserved that 30. I agree with that. But at least it was acknowledged that their performance was the best because their performance was the best even if they did not deserve a 30.

I thought Pratyusha's score was the most unfair this week.

pratyusha is improving though the ending of the steps are still clumsy

Bharti was pure entertainment so i guess the dance did take a step back.

Sanath J - v awkward and the marks and the comments were horrifying to say the least

Darsheel and partner - they were for sure fab. Dance and entertainment value as well.

Gia - Clumsy.

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Lifts are part of a particular western dance... Indian dance shows never follow a true dance form or techniques when it comes to ballroom or latin dances..

They create hotch potch or should I say mish mash by throwing lifts and rolling on the floor here and there in the name of some sort of western dancing..

Why not try something truly classical be it eastern or western..

JDJ's level is no where close in comparing to "DWTS" as part of the show name or SYTYCD...Not bashing the show but posting mere facts..

For me Sanath gave the weakest performance. He didnt even completed a single step without flaws. A pity the choreographer, in their practice video, she seemed to b helping him in mugging the dialogues bt on stage, he didnt lip sync at all. Ofcourse I respect him as a cricketer n so do the judges bt since its a dance show, marking should b based on DANCE only.

Pratyusha should have been second highest scorer of week.. Ok not that she deserved to score better than sanath, sushil, archana... Wanted to spit on judges on that very point

Just saw the promos for this week... There are 2 jodis that the judges are praising a lot and are in focus...