Why Assylum, without Trial.

anjs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#1

As far I remember, its the court and the judge who decides that the accused is mental stable or not. And they decide whether to send him / her to the Assylum or to Jail.

So how did the police decide and sent him packing to the Assylum ?

Cv's you also started making fun of the law and order of the country ?

If you plan to add thriller track, at least read the basic laws of the country.

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

512

Users

4

Likes

24

Frequent Posters

Ilovecoffee thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Not only law n order but also medical science. Since when warden hv the right to use ECT on the patients. Giving ECT is not halwa as they r showing. First warden has no right give ECT to any one. Second Atharv is conscious, ECT is given in total unconsciousness, moreover Atharv is not a candidate for it from any angle, his psychosis is trauma induced, plus he is already responding to his medical treatment. These show can make joke of anything for their benefit. In true sense ECT is gold standard treatment for resistant cases. Resistant means those who ain't responding to medicine atleast for years. Instead of removing stigmas from the society abt mental patients n treatment they keep promoting it. Utter nonsense. But what else can be expected from them 😡
anu023 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: anjs


As far I remember, its the court and the judge who decides that the accused is mental stable or not. And they decide whether to send him / her to the Assylum or to Jail.

So how did the police decide and sent him packing to the Assylum ?

Cv's you also started making fun of the law and order of the country ?

If you plan to add thriller track, at least read the basic laws of the country.

its not court but a qualified psychiatrist and a forensic expert who decides mental stability..since courts lawyers have zero medical knowledge.
And haan no one is sent to asylum just lik that..
This show has showed almost every profession is bad light..
Btw asylum is a derogatory word. And there are mental health centersor rehabilitation centres or mental hospitals . Moreover warden is usually nursing staff of non medical staff who r not qualified to giv any form of psychiatric treaatment. This show is wrong on many fronts
ButterflyOnRose thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
Hey i havent seen the episode yet so i dont know what they have shown into it I can comment on that after watching the episode
But saying in general,
Police will take Atharva to asylum to confirm whether he is truly mentally unstable or just pretending Since the accused is acting as mentally unstable and his family too said he is mentally unstable ,police will check the truth in it and based on that public prosecutor will prepare the case This report will be presented in the court If Atharva is really unstable confirmed with police investigation too then he will be send to asylum If he is not then he will be sentenced to jail
In asylum logically Atharva should be going through series of tests to check his mental unstability Nothing more I dont know what cvs are showing 😆Need to watch that first
anjs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: BeatifulSoul_

Hey i havent seen the episode yet so i dont know what they have shown into it I can comment on that after watching the episode

But saying in general,
Police will take Atharva to asylum to confirm whether he is truly mentally unstable or just pretending Since the accused is acting as mentally unstable and his family too said he is mentally unstable ,police will check the truth in it and based on that public prosecutor will prepare the case This report will be presented in the court If Atharva is really unstable confirmed with police investigation too then he will be send to asylum If he is not then he will be sentenced to jail
In asylum logically Atharva should be going through series of tests to check his mental unstability Nothing more I dont know what cvs are showing 😆Need to watch that first


Oh, i didnt know this is the procedure. I thought that He will stay in police custody and a case will be filed n proofs will be presented by his lawyers, that he did the crime as he is mentally unstable and later he will be sent to the Assylum.

They did show him in the Assylum. But when he refuses to eat as Sujata isnt there. The warden comes and beats him. And since he retaliates, the warden calls for electric shock treatment to be given. That was the precap.
ButterflyOnRose thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: anjs


Oh, i didnt know this is the procedure. I thought that He will stay in police custody and a case will be filed n proofs will be presented by his lawyers, that he did the crime as he is mentally unstable and later he will be sent to the Assylum.

They did show him in the Assylum. But when he refuses to eat as Sujata isnt there. The warden comes and beats him. And since he retaliates, the warden calls for electric shock treatment to be given. That was the precap.

This is for proof The police will present proofs too Alone finger prints are not enough to punish him The defense lawyer will say he is unstable then what police will do so they need proofs

Seems like they dumped Atharva into not a good asylum Logically he should be going through tests at the moment but then how will cvs show their drama if everything goes smoothly đŸ„±đŸ˜†

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".