ARHI FF: The Secrets We Keep [***NEW*** Chapter 19 UP - Page 88] - Page 46

Created

Last reply

Replies

615

Views

138.3k

Users

114

Likes

3.5k

Frequent Posters

jduke thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
I couldn't stop myself reading all chapters in one go. Loved all your character portrayals. They are realistic and witty. Aman is is a**hole. I adore Arnav and Aman / Lavany and Khushi friendship.
What is wrong with Payal? Why Gupta family is so distant to Khushi? Don't they like Khushi and Aman relationship? Why did Khushi walk out of house at the age of 18? Why don't Gupta elders ever reach Khushi after Aman's demise and after Khushi arrival to Lakshmi Nagar?
What happened between Arnav and Khushi that night and where? How did they meet? What is the story behind Harvard cap in her every dream?
poojasidd123 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: ArshiS.Raizada


Now that Kitti confirmed about Arnav and Sheetal, you think Aman was doing this deliberately? Getting into a relationship with girls Arnav has a past with. Aman was t that Great of a friend and a person as we can see. He lied to Arnav and Khushi, his other friends so easily and in a way manipulated Khushi against Arnav maybe.

I doubt Aman was very well aware of Arnav and Khushi's night or whatever they shared. Maybe he was jealous of Arnav and wanted to have everything Arnav has/had, which would explain that he started an affair with Sheetal and was going on with the marriage with Khushi. And Aman lying to Khushi about the Saree Arnav designed didn't go well with me that time too already.
Aman must have been jealous that Arnav is so perfect, looks good, has money and fame, has designing skills etc.
I wouldn't be surprised if later on Arnav discovers some kind of loopholes in AR finances caused by Aman.

Aman does sound like a highly suspicious character, not just with his cheating stunt on khushi but also him being highly affected by the green monster. His lying about that saree still bugs me.
poojasidd123 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
Now that I think of it, it seems arnav had always known of aman's dishonest ways to some extent and maybe knew that he was somehow jealous of him. But as his only best friend, didn't want to jeopardize their personal as well as professional relationship. And so never broke any ties with him. But I don't think he knew that aman was having an affair with sheetal when arnav-sheetal were together ( if the theory that sheetal was cheating on arnav stands).

In chapter 8, there's an instance where khushi remembers the time when she sees arnav and aman returning with a bloody fist and face from Boston,and fears what if aman knew about her and arnav. I guess it was that night she was remembering of. That means that night might have happened in the beginning phase of aman-khushi dating.
IdioTinTin thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: poojasidd123

Now that I think of it, it seems arnav had always known of aman's dishonest ways to some extent and maybe knew that he was somehow jealous of him. But as his only best friend, didn't want to jeopardize their personal as well as professional relationship. And so never broke any ties with him. But I don't think he knew that aman was having an affair with sheetal when arnav-sheetal were together ( if the theory that sheetal was cheating on arnav stands).

In chapter 8, there's an instance where khushi remembers the time when she sees arnav and aman returning with a bloody fist and face from Boston,and fears what if aman knew about her and arnav. I guess it was that night she was remembering of. That means that night might have happened in the beginning phase of aman-khushi dating.


@bold interesting, could be possible as Aman has been friends with Arnav since 20 years in the meanwhile as mentioned by him. I wonder if Sheetal plays way more role into the story than shown. And I think it can't be denied that there is for sure more to Aman's character than just the cheating bit. And it's really something else to have a dead character being revealed as a dark one than someone who's alive. Had Aman been alive, we would have been calling him names and getting over it for nothing but now, most people in the comments mention he was a jerk or asshole and that's it.
Had Aman been portrayed as a heroic figure, we all would have mourned his death 😆

@cursive considering the fact that both Aman and Arnav met Khushi at LA's wedding and Aman was the one to take first steps, it has to be somewhere at the beginning phase of them dating. The question is only when exactly, how exactly and of course, how far had Aman and Khushi's relationship been at the time. Because I think that's essential for Arnav's denial and reaction to whatever happened between them. He had to be clearly knowing about Aman's liking towards Khushi in that way and not just one dance at a wedding.
un.complicated thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 3 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago


[HIDDEN CONTENT]
The content of this post has been Hidden by User.
IdioTinTin thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
My spot😈
EDITED:

So here I am with my comment finally. First of all, lemme tell you, I love to stalk your threads 😉
And I hope I get HOW update soon. And am sooo excited for the new What if Fiction, I dream about it day and night. It's basically my dream alternative IPKKND which I want to read

Now coming to this update, lemme tell you, that I was holding my breath when Khushi was ogling and admiring his physique. And just like Khushi in original IPK, I kept my hand at my heart as it did pace a bit - not that much to be heard outside loud but enough to make me crazy, and then I read Dhak Dhak.That was the moment when I needed to pause and laugh for my craze. I have always loved Arnav Singh Raizada. I think somewhere in my unconscious mind, ASR was half of the reason for me to watch ipk, the other was of course their magical chemistry.
But I am crazy for him. I just love ASR. I sometimes wish Barun would also IRL be wearing those body fit suits and have his hair trimmed - keeping up the ASR attitude and of course, the stubble. Basically, I want him to always be Diwali night ASR. I would become his biggest fan and get obsessed with him if he'd ever start dressing and appearing like ASR in real life 🤣
Ok, enough of dreams for now. Wish someone would invent a machine that lets you have real persons from TV and movies etc, like a living copy of that person. I'd be the first one to buy it and then copy Arnav for myself and marry him and have a happily ever after...yeah...I know I'm insane. You must be wondering why am still out and not locked up in a mental asylum...well, maybe I'm writing from inside a mental Asylum, who knows😈

Ok, now after a full paragraph on Arnav and my craze for him, I'll finally dedicate few words to the update in general. What confuses me is - I checked chapter 8 and confirmed it for myself that Arnav and Aman fought over Aman-Sheetal fiasco around a New Year only because after Arnav was done telling her about their fight over his infidelity after my Arnie found Aman and Sheetal together in bed, Khushi remarked that that's why Aman was bleeding. She had thought that Aman found out about Arnav and her but hadn't been able to explains the role reversal in injury. So it was revealed why Arnav and Aman actually fought.


"Well," I swallowed, "I don't know, maybe you can answer that for me." I took a deep breath, gripping the fork in my hands tightly. "After you and Aman got in...in that fight after New Year's, things just...shifted. You were never mentioned, you guys were never mentioned. It hadn't just become a taboo, it was forbidden unless we were in direct company."

"Oh," Arnav said, stilling his movements. "I see."

It suddenly appeared as though he had lost his appetite as he placed his cutlery back on the plate followed by his napkin. I frowned.

"What did you and Aman fight about that caused such a stir?" I couldn't help but pry.

Arnav ran a hand across the back of his neck, "I don't know. Stuff."

I narrowed my eyes at his evasiveness.

"Arnav," I said my tone ringing with the warning of my dwindling patience, "I know you know. And I know, whatever it was, was serious. Was it about Sheetal? Or was it---" I swallowed, "was it about what happened...between us?"


Now in this chapter it appears that Khushi doesn't know why they fought...was it the same New Year? Or some other New Year? I would have thought that maybe you forgot that Arnav revealed everything to Khushi in Chapter 8 but I doubt that. So maybe it's some other New Year. Let's see what it's about.

Speaking of this, Aman never mentioning Arnav or anyone of his friends is HIGHLY suspicious. It just solidifies my theory about Aman and him actually being jealous or whatever of Arnav in real. Arnav and Aman had been friends since 20 years and yet Aman still didn't talk about him or others to Khushi, never told her any stories about them. There seems to be a lot more to Aman's character. All of your characters are multiple layered in this story but Aman, he appears to be someone -- too dark. I think he was holding deep grudges against his friends in real. But then, Idk, he HAS to be a real good of an actor to be acting good for so long in front of everyone. One, two, three years, ok - possible to an extent but around 20 years...they were children that time. If we assume they are around 30 currently, Arnav and Aman must have become friends around the age 10 and then- OH WAIT. That slap. Arnav slapped Aman for holding hands with his crush but that time they were 12. Maybe Aman is such a person who never forgets anything. Maybe Aman was a filmy guys, like, I'll take revenge for this slap and he never forgot that. This would explain why Aman got together with Khushi and Sheetal. They are Arnav's Ex's and in a weird way, he just was keen on being together with all the girls Arnav was ever interested in or is interested in. It's stupid but possible. For now, the theory stands.

Now coming to one thing I just now remembered. Khushi admiring Arnav's physique. Considering that we are reading from her POV, it's weird that she's actually ogling and admiring him as if it was the first time. It appears she never actually has seen his naked chest. Now that leaves me baffled about their one night stand. Every time they speak about that famous night, everything's indicates to a ONS but this update is confusing the hell out of me. I mean, ok, it isn't necessary for both to be fully naked for the act but...you know, it's confusing. Something else that could explain this would be that they were drunk that night. So they don't necessarily remember everything, for example what the other look looks like under the layer of clothes.

I hope I didn't miss anything. I read the update yesterday already and then slept afterwards because it needs my full attention and energy to analyze and put all my thoughts into words. It was a lot of food for my analyst brain 😆

You must have noticed I hardly write anything about Arnav and Khushi together, their current situation. That's because I think there's less to write about it for me because of course they are doing great with each other currently, talking and exchanging stories about each other. So I think I can't write much except that I am happy about it and admire that.

And yes, one thing, you shocked me too when Arnav revealed Anjali joined them. Haha, that's really not that Pujali Anjali from IPK but I like such cool persons. I mean, I like every person who's nice - except of those me and my bestie hate - no matter how less or more their life choices resemble to mine, I don't judge anyone but I just have a special place in my heart for people who know to live and be cool ocassionally.

So, ya, that was for now. Now waiting for Pooja's comment 😃
Edited by ArshiS.Raizada - 8 years ago
un.complicated thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 3 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago

I honestly think others have learned not to comment until you have taken your spot, LMAO! 😆
IdioTinTin thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: un.complicated


I honestly think others have learned not to comment until you have taken your spot, LMAO! 😆


They better not mess with me. As everyone knows, stalkers are crazy, right? 😉
un.complicated thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 3 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: ArshiS.Raizada


They better not mess with me. As everyone knows, stalkers are crazy, right? 😉


I'm off to bed now, but I look forward to your analysis on this chapter --- there's quite a bit of material there for you to pick apart and decode ... have fun! ;)
Edited by un.complicated - 8 years ago
Lily30 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
Loved part 17 👏
Both going in a steady relationship of friendship, although the past there making Khushi question things further.
Eager for the next part 😃

Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: ILoveFF · 6 years ago

Hello readers, Thank you for your support so far. It has been overwhelming. I am deeply grateful to every reader; sweet silent ones and precious...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: Pearl_Oyster · 6 months ago

Author's Note Dear IPK friends! Hope you all are doing well..! I am back here to the forum with another story that has been languishing in my...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: ExoticDisaster · 8 months ago

Disclaimer This is a paranormal romance story. Expect a darker edge to the romance , with themes of fear, suspense, and potentially unsettling...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: desidillse · 9 months ago

C H A P T E R 1 She was entering the office when, her gaze fell over the person who matters the most to her, "Ansh", and his name immediately...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine · 2 months ago

A splishin’ and a splashin’! A little bit of pool time is among the unforgettable ones Entangled meetings straight from Kisses to heartbreaks By...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".