Message for Mr. Sanjay - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

126

Views

12.6k

Users

112

Likes

561

Frequent Posters

RajPreet_Preeto thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Dear Mr Sanjay Gupta, here is the post made by one of the writers of IPKKND who was there since the beginning and left because of PH. please do read.

The Bitter Truth - A Note from Kernal

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=3276678

Content of the post:

Dear IPKKND viewers,

Before, I write anything I have to say that this is not to create panic or anything. Nor am I confirming any rumours. Just some shared views.

I know I cannot force anyone to believe whether I am an authentic source or not. Many of you might wonder why I did not make a post defending myself after 4 Lions stated that I was not a part of the production house. I have to add that I never stated that my views were shared by the production house in any of my posts, I always maintained that they were the views of a certain set of people associated with the show. This is also why those posts were not posted through their account.

Furthermore, the production house has no way of knowing the identity of spoiler givers (and to clarify I am not a spoiler-giver) as those people use aliases which is true for majority of the people on this forum.

The reason I used this account to make posts about the show was because I genuinely felt a need to thank the audience. Some may argue that India Forums is a very small representation of the show's audience and I completely agree.

Why did I still make those posts?

Simple. I cannot thank every single person who has played a role in helping the show achieve the success that it is but even if I am able to thank a hand full of people it satisfies me to an extent.

Some may call me overly emotional, melodramatic etc. and they have every right to do so and at the same time I am entitled to my views. IPKKND has been a life changing experience for me. It has a very special place in my heart. I truly believe that I will never come across a show like IPKKND in my life but I am happy knowing that I was apart of something so magical and capable of connecting people across the globe.

I am aware that many rumours are in the air concerning the show. When a media outlet leaked the news of Barun giving his notice, only a select few were aware of that news. No one on set knew of this and were kept out of the loop for quite some time. We only got wind of the news when it was leaked by one of the producers to a former journalist.

As much as I love Barun and support him there are things going on behind the scenes and with the production house that are not being disclosed so I guess we all have to keep waiting until "next week" to find out. Whenever next week may come.

A few months ago, the storyline was abruptly changed which was both negative and positive. I leave you to decide what was what. Many storylines were rejected for unknown reasons. Initially my aim was to give every character importance but due to certain interferences, certain characters became mere props. Something that I will always regret.

I have been apart of IPKKND right from the beginning. I cannot express the joy I felt seeing characters being portrayed on screen that were once mere sketches on paper. For the past year and a half I have literally lived through this show. I woke up thinking about it, thought about it when I ate, and went to sleep thinking about it. Some of you think you are obsessed, imagine being me.

A couple of days I received a text informing me about an open letter on a forum called Forum32. Being a curious person, I made an account so I could know what the fuss was about.

"The story of IPKKND has run it's course."

The final blow.

When you devote almost every waking minute to something you love and you read something like this, it hurts beyond words. It shocks me that there was once a time when IPKKND was someone's baby but I guess according to some this baby is all grown up.

Do I think that some professionalism needed to be displayed?

Yes.

Why?

Because posting such letters is a disrespect to the viewers and even a bigger show of disrespect to the people who work tremendously hard to make the show a reality.

Now many of you might think that I am doing the same thing by posting this letter. And yes maybe I am. Maybe this is my way of venting.

I woke up this morning and made a a very hard decision. I want to remember my baby for what it was, not the politics or the drama it has become. I want to be able to remember the characters we started with, not just the ones left. After months of internal fighting, I decided that it was time to leave the show. Almost all of you will never know who I am but I just needed to write this. Honestly I am not even sure if I was able to get my point across or not but by writing this I have obtained some peace to my inner turmoil.

I do know that many reading this will question my loyalty for the show and maybe even bash me for abandoning it in the middle. I can only justify myself by writing that when something you have worked very hard for is snatched from you hands by others so they can enjoy the "high" and once they have churned out what they can, they throw it on the ground instead of placing it back in your hands, it is the last straw.

Once again, I cannot thank each and every one of you enough for making IPKKND what it is. I am forever indebted.


"Why can't we get all the people together in the world that we really like and then just stay together? I guess that wouldn't work. Someone would leave. Someone always leaves. Then we would have to say good-bye. I hate good-byes. I know what I need. I need more hellos."

'Charles M. Schulz

Signing off for the last time,

S.B. and others.

I am not Gul. She's too busy with her "baby" to be bothered to write this anyway.



Edited by kernal - 07 November 2012 at 5:45am

samster03 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
1.Retain barun back
2.change the ph
3.bring back all the actors and writers who were made to leave the show because the dirty politics played by gul
4.If not, end the show with a good note and give us ipkknd season 2 with the same cast and crew but with different ph.


NO BARUN-NO IPKKND-NO STARPLUS
saddafmahmood thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
I really want SP to take over IPKKND, becoz there is no other shows in SP wich can bring so much of fame and name to SP..
puglet thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago


THIS IS A "MEMBERS ONLY" POST
The Author of this post have chosen to restrict the content of this Post to members only.


-Farwa_Ibrahim- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
we want just barun as ASR pleaseee
bepatient thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Dear Sir,
This is a mail requesting you to please retain Barun Sobti as Arnav Singh Raizada in Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon show on your channel. IPK is indeed a phenomenon. A one of a kind experience. Huge number of us enjoyed it immensely.
But definitely the best part of my IPK journey is the first one year. The script was well written. The characters were all entertaining, each holding a charm of their own. Believe me sir, when I say, this is my first ever India TV show and Indian Hindi Channel.
What kept us all hooked to the show was offcourse the entertaining script, fantastic direction, amazing camera work, awesome dialogues, talented actors and the cherry on top of all that is the sizzling chemistry of Barun and Sanaya. Offscreen or onscreen they were a treat to watch. Their facial expressions, body language, dialogue delivery were all perfection. Whenever I see them on the screen, I get a smile on my face !!
Never in our dreams we imagined IPK to be entangled in such controversies. Without Barun Sobti, even if the show is not going to end, it is a virtual end for lots of us who got hooked to the couple Arnav and Khushi. The show will never be the same without Barun as Arnav.
The wonderful story of Arnav and Khushi started degrading with respect to the story line, look and feel of the set, actors attire from june 2012 onwards. The degradation in terms of quality is very much apparent to anyone. There are so many inconsistencies wrt characterisation, so many unconnected stories, scenes which were just left adrift, poor execution, bloopers and pathetic story tracks. All this happenned suddenly to a show which was earlier perfect wrt everything !!!!! Many of us wondered as to what happenned to the creatives who created this gem. Even during this depressing time all the loyal viewers of IPK continued watching the show because of the star cast and especially the leads Barun Sobti and Sanaya Irani.
After hundreds of messages sent to ph on 4Lions forum32, we got this open letter from the 4Lions citing the reason as "IPK story has run its course...all fairy tales end with marriage." . Viewers were appalled and shocked at this statement which was essentially to let us know that 4Lions was looking forward to end IPK ASAP. Then came the news of two actors, a writer and the male lead exit from the show.
Sir, please let this beautiful story live its life to the fullest and let the actors who put their life into it survive along with it. Please retain Barun Sobti as Arnav Singh Raizada and give IPK better writers. IPK is a show which has lots of potential and if change happens now then it will be a sure shot winner for Star Plus in domestic and international market.
Thanks,
Regards
Ardent IPK fan
Edited by ipkkndfan30 - 12 years ago
SViji_2706 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago


Hello,

I'm an ardent fan of IPKKND,the very reason I'm hooked to this show is due to the USP of this show and the chemistry which Barun and Sanaya portrays on screen as ASR and KKGSR. We fan's can't imagine to see anyone replacing Barun in ASR's position or a new guy in Khushi's life.WE fan's are very much disappointed and also r hurt by SP's reaction to these issues. SP is not taking any serious action regarding our demands and r taking the fans for ride from past 2 weeks.SP received more then 20, 000 calls but no response in terms of official statement...also BS said he has no movies or serials lined up... but SP claims he has!!!!We very well new PH r playing politics behind the screen and they r not at all interested in the show anymore which is very much evident from their open letter on Forum32 by stating "we r run out of ideas/course".


Open letter to viewers of IPKKND

4lionsfilmsPosts: 55Administratoradmin
The story of IPKKND has run it's course. The two people in love have got married. All fairy tales end with "and they lived happily ever after". We have asked you earlier and ask you once again. Please post your story ideas here - and we mean "story ideas and tracks". "Show love scenes between Arshi, get the intensity back" etc. is not a story idea. The post which gets the maximum number of likes - we will incorporate it in the show(or try to!) - otherwise come back and tell you why it couldn't be done.
Any comments on this post which do not amount to a story idea or other stuff like change in wardrobe will be deleted.There is a feedback section for that - and we read it.Stay on topic. Read what others have written and press the like button if you agree with it or post a comment to add to it. Don't add links to some other stuff you have written. Please write in black only.
Fair enough? Let's go.
Thank you.

This is not the only reason to accuse PH,we also new the fault is from PH's side where if one person quit the show it is understandable but every important person from the cast quitting the show like Akshay,Deepali,Writer of this show and now Barun is also leaving leads to everyone of us to confirm something fishy is going on behind the screen.The another reason same happened with the famous show GEET.The fourth reason 4LIONS removed IPKKND from their official pages... we have.

For us fan's

No barun = No IPKKND...
No Sanaya=No IPKKND
No SaRun=No Arshi= No IPKKND
If they even bring up Shahrukh or Salman or almost Aamir, no one can potrye Arnav Singh Raizada like Barun..
We want Barun in the show till the end...
We need them...
they are our life...
We can't live without Arnav and Khushi...
They are our life...
Please solve all the problems soon...
we love Barun so much..
Please!
If they want to end the show, end it only with Barun and Sanaya closing all the loops...
And give us another show with Barun and Sanaya...
Pleasee...!!!!!
Its a humble request from all the fans all-over the world...

These r some of the links pls do read as it is very imp for u to know abt fan's situation.Plsss


Part 1: http://wp.me/p2TQP0-4

Part 2: http://wp.me/p2TQP0-a

Part 3: http://wp.me/p2TQP0-b

Part 4: http://wp.me/p2TQP0-g

Part 5: http://wp.me/p2TQP0-i

the link to ipkfiasco1's blog

http://ipkfiasco.wordpress.com/ This has the most objective analysis of the whole situation.

http://www.fuzionproductions.com/a-never-ending-crisis-in-iss-pyar-ko-kya-naam-doon/comment-page-4/

http://www.fuzionproductions.com/barun-sobti-supporters-creating-an-uproar/


We demand to SP is to retain Barun in the show and change PH or if they can't retain Barun then we request to end the show with SaRun on happy not before Barun leaves the show.But looks like sp is acting as a slave for that ph


We kindly request u to take necessary action to help us fans who r fighting for our IPKKND.


Thank U,
An Ardent Fan of IPKKND/SaRun/Arshi
indi52 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
dear mr gupta,

if what hetal believes is accurate, and you are really going to be reading this thread, thanks for that.

a look at your cv tells me you were with hindustan lever in the '90s. i am a copywriter and was with hta in '95 working on the close up account for close to a year and a half. interesting times. mr mukul deoras, who i have great respect for, mr tarun (i think, gupta), and a mr sanjay gupta comprised the core brand team. it was tough working on the account and yet a fantastic place to learn about advertising.

mr gupta, iss pyaar ko kya naam doon? despite that question mark is a rare product. no question. yes, it is a daily soap, but thanks to a mix which is impossible to deconstruct fully, it has beauty, and indescribable magic in it. this product has the possibilities of being a cult like star trek and friends. and i do not exaggerate here.

i have never ever been a soap watcher. in fact, the only reason i subscribed to indian channels was to get a sense of india as my years abroad stretched longer. i missed home. i turned on the tv, saw the song and dance and melodrama for a bit, wondering at the ghastly costumes and bizarre story lines, just getting a short dose of india the day seemed to require. and switched off.

then came ipkknd. it was barun sobti that got me in. but the story that wrapped right around and held me tight. 12 midnight the day's episode would be aired. i'd be up, watch, then watch repeatedly on youtube, sometimes till 3 am.
you can imagine my consternation at my own behaviour. this is not how a 52 year old woman, who is from advertising, and hates tv, in fact sort of considers it infra dig, acts.

and yet i was there, night after night.

still here.

this is a rare rare product for a channel.

at its heart, asr/barun sobti, kkg/sanaya irani, their chemistry, ved raj/gautam hegde and team's writing, raju singh's music, arshad khan/lalit mohan's direction. tagline: rabba vey.

the most key ingredients: barun, sanaya, chemistry. put it anywhere, it will say ipkknd and it will work.

for the last six months almost the story has gone all over the place. horrible cuts, jumps, amnesia. we have screamed and shouted. but still we are here.

games, insult, stonewalling, from first production house, then your organisation, nothing has stopped us.

you have viewers from around the world who are often highly educated professionals with no dirth of "life," whose friends and family have openly laughed at this fascination and yet they don't budge. my friends love to tell me about my midlife crisis. then go on to speak of how they are reading fifty shades of gray.

that came from another fabulous product which connected with millions: twilight.

you should see the fiction coming out of this forum. 8,000 pages on india-forums itself for ipkknd. na bole tum of colors has 380 odd pages, yet that audience got the ear of the channel. season 2.

not my place to tell you how you should keep iss pyaar ko jya naam doon? up and running. but please don't end it. and don't let anyone but barun play asr. if he needs a long break, all of us will stay tuned and wait for him as we did last year.

this has such potential, this simple smart clean stylish serial with a funny undeniable depth. please see that. sense its possibilities as a brand, a winner and save ipkknd. a request: do please release a dvd set and a music cd. this one is worth keeping. and watching again and again.

thanks for your time. i never could write short copy.

best regards
indrani robbins
Edited by indi52 - 12 years ago
710617 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Retain Barun or end the Arnav khushi story with Barun with sanaya...happily..
priyatnl thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
Do you even know that all IPKKND viewers are shifting to Madhubala and Qubool Hai

Do you know the reason?

The track that was supposed to be here is now running there and viewers have already started shifting
> Hope you stitch your hole in the sack and save your show.

I am so sorry that you didnt know that 4Lions had posted all your inside discussions online

I was sure StarPlus had control here


We want Barun Back and screenwriter Gautam Hegde on the show.
>
> Akshay, Deepali, Abhaas, Gupta Family, Mamaji along with the current cast
>
> And writer Gautam Hegde with Vedraj
>
> If possible Arshad Khan with Lalit Mohan as directors
>
> Most importantly change 4 Lions production house and remove Gul Khan
>
>
> We are ready to watch even a new season with the above team
> Bring the actor who showed us heaven
> Change the producer who is showing us Hell
> Prove yourself that you are No1 GEC
> Dont waste you time


Give viewers a new season with the same cast (including Barun) and new PH if it is not possible to bring Barun in current story

We want to see Sanaya and Barun only on the show. No one as ASR n no other lead for Khushi

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".