Barun An actor-A debate (MODs close the topic) - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

274

Views

26.9k

Users

118

Likes

1.6k

Frequent Posters

...manal... thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
Hey!

OK...to be honest...I can be pretty defensive about Barun...because I love him for the person he is first and then for the actor he is...

Firstly, I have watched many Indian shows previously. Therefore, I can easily analyze the actor in him as well as compare him to other actors in the television industry. He, by far, stands as the BEST out of all of them. Also, I have watched all the other shows Barun has acted in previously. There was Shraddha, then Dill Mill Gayye, later Baat Hamari Pakki Hai and finally we have Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon. I have literally seen him evolve as an actor. And he has changed and learnt for the better. And the best part, he played a different character in every show he was part of. In Dill Mill Gayye he portrayed an evil drug addict. In Baat Hamari Pakki Hai he portrayed a carefree, rich brat with an amazing sense of humor, who learns to take up responsibilities after he gets married and realizes what true love is. And in IPKKND he portrays a ruthless business man who just pretends to not have a heart but now is crazy in love with his wife. You know what leaves me in awe? It is how flawlessly he molds himself into the character he is portraying. He breathes life into his character. I agree, there are times when things do go slightly wrong. But his brilliant acting over shadows those little mistakes. You should have seen him in Dill Mill Gayye. Watch the videos on You Tube. They will give you goosebumps and leave you thinking, "Is this the guy who actually plays ASR?"

About comparing him to other Bollywood actors. Well, I personally don't see anything wrong in that. He is competent enough to be compared with them. The time period the actors have been in the Bollywood industry is not the factor to be considered while comparing here. It is their TALENT. There are actors who have been in the Bollywood industry for decades but are far from acting.

About him being the Greatest actor. I am going to give my example here. (Hope I don't get shoes thrown at me for this.) They call Sharukh Khan, the GREATEST ACTOR. But, sadly, for me, I don't think he is.
His acting is monotonous but he is still called the Greatest. There are far better actors than him in the Bollywood industry. This is my PERSONAL opinion.

About him being given the treatment as of GOD. As far as I know, nobody has done that till date. But...Girl...Rajnikanth has his own freakin' temple! People actually worship him! In comparison to that, the feelings that people have about Barun is very tiny. It's genuine...not over rated. As I mentioned earlier, it's all about individual opinions here.

About people loving Barun for just his looks. Honestly, I don't think he is Super Handsome. There are way better looking actors than him in the industry. I don't judge him for his looks. I respect him for the person he is. He is a genuine person which is why his acting is genuine. Which is why when he cries, it looks real and we cry. When he laughs, it's from the heart. When he hates, it gives you chills. When he loves, it's mesmerizing. When he smirks and flirts, it gives you a tingling sensation. It's almost like his character is real and not fictional. His expressions can be stone like at times. Agreed. But his eyes...they emote and speak volumes when his face doesn't. And that, my dear friend, is not an easy task. Emoting from the eyes, making it so real and believable. It's not at all easy. That is something that actors working from decades have failed to do till date. That is what makes him the best for me.

He has flaws, everyone does. But he conceals them with his marvelous performances.

This is clearly my opinion
. Since it's a debate, I put forth my point. Nobody is forced to agree with me here. And I respect everyone's opinions. Yours too.

I hope I didn't sound too angry. Because I am not at all. I enjoyed replying to this post. It was loads of FUN!

Thanks Dear!

Manal <3
Edited by -Manal.A- - 13 years ago
Rockerchic thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
I never thought this one will become so popular! A big hug from my side for all those who replied. I respect and understand where you are coming from.

I have never watched hindi soaps in my entir e life. And if IPK managed to capture my attention for300 episods, then credit to Sobti.

However untill i see a performance from him with a diffrent co star his greatness will be questioned by me. For me both SI andBS are actors who do Arhi well but their acting levels are not all that great.(there are various reaons for this.) I will stand by this. As for bollywood, its a complete personality a.d not acting. This is another aspect where sobti lags. Him being media shy is okay for now. But if his off screen presence is not mended, the possibility of success is meek.

I want to see how sobti will fare without his chemistry with sanaya.

Untill such a time, i will enjoy his potrayal of arnav singh raizada, who he plays for the most part flawlessly.
Edited by Rockerchic - 13 years ago
bsforsi thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
No one can do ASR better than BS. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So - no point arguing.
jainneha thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
no i dont agree he is one of the prefect actors worth hollywood i am not sounding a crazy fangirl here ,of couse i love him for his looks but i have seen him do the best drunk act very few actors can when actors play drunk its borin but when in bhph after dmg in his drunk scene he was so funny he can act anway whatever u may feel barun is one of the finest actors out thre bttr than bollwood actors i cannot tell u how much i have laughed and cried in bhph as asr he is just phenomenal👏
ArshiRaiguptha thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
OMG..!! 😲

I completely agree with you and I always wanted to make a post like this.
But never had the guts to do that. I'm not afraid of a mad dog. But am afraid of the crazy fan-girls out there. Am Glad at-least one person thinks like me. So Glad..!! 😊

👏-- This is for your guts.
👏-- This is for the post.
🤢-- This is how you will be, very soon. Be Prepared.! 😆


LIKEDMG thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
First I really appriciate you for the post..u hv made in this forum..whr a little opposition of Barun ppl just behave like mad...😲..for u...👏...I love ur approach too..this is my first show of Barun ..before that I dont know him...I love him as ASR...I hv tried some episodes of his prev show..but I dont like him there..for me he has improved a lot... Barun need to groom himself if he want to move in Big screen...the points you hv mentioned ...I m agreed...that compare wid b'wood actors...worship like god...really fangals...😆...I like in Barun is his eyes..barun is very good and honest actor...His improvement show that he is hardworking too..most important is hw he is going to present him on screen and media...barun need to improve that...for me still he is nt properly groomed for Big screen...I dont like Barun in his prev show and dont c him other than ASR..so I cannt judge him that he is perfect...I love him as Arnav singh raizada and wid sanaya...😃..hope he will explore himself in different fields of entertainment ...
surenkal thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Rockerchic

I never thought this one will become so popular! A big hug from my side for all those who replied. I respect and understand where you are coming from.

I have never watched hindi soaps in my entir e life. And if IPK managed to capture my attention for300 episods, then credit to Sobti.

However untill i see a performance from him with a diffrent co star his greatness will be questioned by me. For me both SI andBS are actors who do Arhi well but their acting levels are not all that great.(there are various reaons for this.) I will stand by this. As for bollywood, its a complete personality a.d not acting. This is another aspect where sobti lags. Him being media shy is okay for now. But if his off screen presence is not mended, the possibility of success is meek.

I want to see how sobti will fare without his chemistry with sanaya.

Untill such a time, i will enjoy his potrayal of arnav singh raizada, who he plays for the most part flawlessly.


FOR me this is the key line: want to see how sobti will fare without his chemistry with sanaya.
In this case the co-actor has a lot to give in making him look so good. lets she how he fares with shenaz or any other actress
jainneha thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
he was with ankita in bhph and he was vgud thre as well and in tre he mademe cry and laugh both AND FRM THEN ON AND I KNEW that he is going to go ahead for me he deserves hollywood.
CravingKhana thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
A very interesting topic made in interesting times and amongs potentialy very interesting 'feedback"
I dont feel the need to add the discalimer of I luv Barun...erm i dont know Barun...
SOme find him smocking...i find him cute at times...but hey we are here to analyse his acting chops not my hormones and thier triggers so here goes...
I belive the boy has the raw material...i see the need to work on it...
now comparatively to other actors is the same medium...i would not have a clue...have only seen a Karan i think in one episode of show here on SP...and he nailed it and so did the actress..also i have seen bits and bobs of Harshad Chopra's work and he too seemed pretty good...
so judging by what i have seen he turns up average...but then again i have seen much more of him than the other two...
bollywood is highly overated...and yes a unicorn is needlessly gonna loose out...cos u guessed my view on said actor...
Aamir might be the only notable...but he to is more brilliant as a film maker...
now the south is completely differnet and there art and talent combine...to make some good entertainment but sadly dont meet the flash metre of bolly...
I digress...So coming to Barun...dialogue delivery needs to be polished.(i at first believed it was the charactor...)
i have seen a cpl of off screens and his natural facial movements and mouth contortions seemed to be highly controlled on screen to make that transformation into ASR and that is a spark...
Given that this is a daily and volatility of the writers and the charactor board and the choppiness of the screen play does not allow for accurate judgement...
besides i wonder how much freedom the actor has in playing his role...
All in all...i dont see the halo that so many worship but i do see potential in the artiste...
Rockerchic thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: tangam

A very interesting topic made in interesting times and amongs potentialy very interesting 'feedback"

I dont feel the need to add the discalimer of I luv Barun...erm i dont know Barun...
SOme find him smocking...i find him cute at times...but hey we are here to analyse his acting chops not my hormones and thier triggers so here goes...
I belive the boy has the raw material...i see the need to work on it...
now comparatively to other actors is the same medium...i would not have a clue...have only seen a Karan i think in one episode of show here on SP...and he nailed it and so did the actress..also i have seen bits and bobs of Harshad Chopra's work and he too seemed pretty good...
so judging by what i have seen he turns up average...but then again i have seen much more of him than the other two...
bollywood is highly overated...and yes a unicorn is needlessly gonna loose out...cos u guessed my view on said actor...
Aamir might be the only notable...but he to is more brilliant as a film maker...
now the south is completely differnet and there art and talent combine...to make some good entertainment but sadly dont meet the flash metre of bolly...
I digress...So coming to Barun...dialogue delivery needs to be polished.(i at first believed it was the charactor...)
i have seen a cpl of off screens and his natural facial movements and mouth contortions seemed to be highly controlled on screen to make that transformation into ASR and that is a spark...
Given that this is a daily and volatility of the writers and the charactor board and the choppiness of the screen play does not allow for accurate judgement...
besides i wonder how much freedom the actor has in playing his role...
All in all...i dont see the halo that so many worship but i do see potential in the artiste...



BINGO!

The disclaimer was more of a gag😆
Edited by Rockerchic - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine ¡ 5 years ago

Raise me a dais of silk covered in red A symbol of love, c arve with doves Colored with gold and silver thread With weaving wishes, for purebred...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine ¡ 1 years ago

Arnav and Khushi are back ...LOL It sounds incredible, yet they are doing one ad. Instagram Link

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: radix ¡ 1 years ago

Pics other IF threads MAIN INDEX 👈 [QUOTE] ZOUK Format: Advertisement Brand: Zouk bags Starring: Sanaya Irani, Barun Sobti Creator : EiPi Media...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".