IP REDUX; Modesty Blaise !! - Page 24

Created

Last reply

Replies

761

Views

47.5k

Users

85

Likes

3.7k

Frequent Posters

malsub thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
Hi all,
Just posted a response on GH's post on 4Lions page:
Edited by malsub - 13 years ago
tanthya thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: nivedha84

I know theres is a tug of war going btw SP and PH,lets give them one more chance to prove their worth,if we look at SP other shows,they r so dumb and they still holding their slot with their low TRPs, (YRKKH,Navya,Saathiya(thats worst),and i never watch these shows ,my friends watch them regularly and love these soaps and they said IP is far better than these shows




Who are we to give them the chance, Vedha.. it is SP which will decide ...as far other shows...I do not want a comparison war going on here and Please edit ur post, I do not want members from other forums coming here and starting a unwanted war ..


I would suggest that u look at their TRP's..They are CONSISTENT !! ..
Doodle thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: redwine1




As Gautam Hegde's post suggested today ... we must watch it now for entertainment ... so only episodes which entertain we will watch ... the not so entertaining ones can fall on the way side




Hahahaha I loved this line so much Wine ... fantastic ... 😆

ok coming to the tracks... Stigma was there earlier and that is why 6 months was added for more drama ... but they scrapped it ... and now Shyam's execution also ... they can change as they need to ... but what ever changes are made that should be sensible naa???
redwine1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
Ok as is customary ... but with half a heart i will put forth the logic question of the day...

Why can't KKGSR just slap shithead Shyam ???? I know during the Heer Ranjha act he told her to slap him .. coz in this she would at least touch him ... but what the hell is he doing to her now ... he is mauling her right left & centre ...???

Ok if she is a Gandhian .. & doesn't believe in violence why can't she scream her head off ... she did it to poor ASR (the bathroom scene) call the family members into the room ... maybe say "tiljatta" once again ...

This is truly one of the best writing ever (dripping with sarcasm) ... in a single episode you have Khushi behaving like a:
1. smart thinking woman ( she gets out of the police station as she wants to keep ASR kidnapping under wraps)
2. An intelligent woman who realizes that the PDA guys were tailing advantage of her concern for her hubby
3. A cunning woman who can think on her feet .. how she got masala mama out of accompanying her
4. A dim witted brainless woman ... who lets a scum bug like Shyam manhandle her ... who the hell is Shyam to question her on her relation with her hubby ... why the hell can't she turn around & tell him "dude manage your own wedding ... get that right leave mine to me & Arnav .. we are capable of making it work" That will be hard hitting will make audiences get up & clap ... but no we at the PH will only deliver everything which will not work ...

Why the hell can't they get Khushi's characterization right ...

In all the budget issues of the PH .. can they not have NO BUDGET for glycerine ... why can't Khushi stop crying & concentrate on anger ..
@ her hubby for not believing in her
@ Shyam for manhandling her
@ Raizada's & Gupta's for not seeing all the problems brewing just under their noses

About todays episode ... chalo at least the story moved ...


Doodle thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: sunshine99

thanks dear for liking the ID just my bit to keep a positive outlook at things..😊 Neither do I judge the story line by a single episode but believe it points at a direction for the immediate future...this is a serial story and not a novel adaptation of a writer so the thought process is bound to change like the seasons... but the basic framework needs to be maintained...which I think has been tweaked beyond the necessity... so now there is no option other than banking on Barun to sail thro' the crisis... which he will do... trp's will come to 3.00 but will IPK get back to its old glory I am skeptical... unless over dependency on SARUN is dropped we will land up in a similar soup in the future too..



Ranjitha , what they have massacred after that you just wait and watch what they will show ... They will show Arnav's repentance, redemption , and their wedding, Shyam's execution everything ... bas ILLOGICAL hogi as they have killed the tracks themselves ...

this PH 4 Lions have the track record of "Redeeming" their only Villain ... Shyam ne murder attempt kiya, their last villain did a SECOND MARRIAGE to an innocent village girl and made love to her and left her the nexy day to die in the society and later when that girl became pregnant she came to know that she was his second wife ... and he was a FRAUD ... you know what Gul Khan and 4 Lions did???

They REDEEMED him when it was his time to be convicted as the actor who was playing Villain wanted to be positive.


Edited by doodleberry - 13 years ago
ranjitha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: doodleberry



Ranjitha, I will answer your PM later on ...

But one clarification that who told you that I was not happy with ASR's ILU??? I never was angry at all... rather I was angry with PH here...

like if ASR said on deathbed fine with me as per the situation but the MAZAAK was done by 4 Lions here and not ASR ... I can justify ASR here if I want to but the problem here is NOT ASR but CVs ... they have made a MOCKERY out of 11 months of waiting ... and Khushi did make a joke out of that ILU ... in the last scene ... when will she grow up ... her questioning within her was fine but to the police??? How will I justify her "Naadani" realization here when she said to the Police that dialogue ... she should have said anything right??? It's their personal thingy ... she should have said she knows ... Instinct ... whatever. They wanted to show Khushi's innocence there but they massacred the development in her mental growth and realization ... I only loved her Smile after she heard those golden words ... and at the Police station what she said, even that became FAKE.

mujhe problem CVs ke saath hain ... they are mixing real life with reel ... reel is magical and they need to create it ... like they did in the bangle and pool and diwali

For a serial and a millions of viewers "Confession" is one scene that they dread to watch ... Imagine here the promo of ILU didn't even tun for a week ... where as all other promos ran for a week atleast ... or a month for some ...



yaar by ASR's ILU I mean the idea of confession only..
I didnt like ILU because it was said by ASR and I'm ASR pankha... I liked the scene and it touched by heart... I have told this several times, that I dont look for logic in every scene.. Its only after I came to REDUX that I understood what 4 , 9, 36 all meant... I'm a normal viewer will petty expectations...

I can understand you are disappointed but just an ILU cant be the reason for you to quit analysing and proclaim that the show has lost essence...
I always think that when you become a role model, your responsibilities double triple... your analysis and your decoding has become a reference point for many here.. you believe it or not.. the rest agree or not... so when you say this show has nothing good left to show... and that future tracks will not be effective enough, then somehow it will affect the thinking of rest too... You are the daddy of redux, hence expectations are little higher from you.. hope you understand the reson behind me coming up with all these... I know I'll have to justify to 100 odd people why I said so, how from past 2 days, I was feeling an urge to say this for I cannot hold back when I'm eager to say something... hmm probably I don't fit into this extremely logical and intellectual family 😕

tanthya thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: sharmibalan

I think IPK had been changing tracks for a long time ...All serials do...Just an example...When they first started they had Khushi working for Arnav...it didn't go well with the TRP and the public...(they thought nothing new in this)...they had to scrape their episode bank that they shot and tried another idea ...which is to make her work in his house...that went well with the audience...and their TRP went up...this is just an example
They always try new ideas and check the pulse of the audience...
All they need to keep in mind is the essence of the storyline and the Characters



Sharmi,


The PH has always been changing the tracks... we have always suported it ..but previously the PH would bring the ongoing track to its conclusion while at the same time including the seed for the next track..There would be a continuity ...but off late there is no continuity and the episode is becing stand alone, the characters are going out for a toss .. ASR is being reduced to a caricature while the warm hearted Khushi is portrayed as juvenile ...

This is what we are fighting against..
rana5 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
😲Doods, I am still in shock! I suppose we knew something had changed, everything seems so rushed. But what are you saying??? No proper confession, no redemption for everything Arnav said and did to Khushi, no middle of the road to temple, no terrace scene and Khushi getting hospitalised??????? I cannot deal with this! How long have we waited? How many months of OTT Khushi? February was the wedding and we have been waiting for the confrontation, confession, Arnav's realisation, etc... How can they cheat us like this? So many hours and hours devoted to this show! 😭 I say, why the rush for June 6 now, does it matter if a few more weeks are taken to show us these tracks? We loyal fans will understand that the timeframe is messed up, the story is more important than a stupid date!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Please comment Doods!


PS: glad to have you back however you chose.
sree07 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: tanthya



Sharmi,


The PH has always been changing the tracks... we have always suported it ..but previously the PH would bring the ongoing track to its conclusion while at the same time including the seed for the next track..There would be a continuity ...but off late there is no continuity and the episode is becing stand alone, the characters are going out for a toss .. ASR is being reduced to a caricature while the warm hearted Khushi is portrayed as juvenile ...

This is what we are fighting against..👏


Keep fighting .. never ever quit😉. At least on this I guess we are one same page.. nah same book😆
Doodle thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: ranjitha



yaar by ASR's ILU I mean the idea of confession only..
I didnt like ILU because it was said by ASR and I'm ASR pankha... I liked the scene and it touched by heart... I have told this several times, that I dont look for logic in every scene.. Its only after I came to REDUX that I understood what 4 , 9, 36 all meant... I'm a normal viewer will petty expectations...

I can understand you are disappointed but just an ILU cant be the reason for you to quit analysing and proclaim that the show has lost essence...
I always think that when you become a role model, your responsibilities double triple... your analysis and your decoding has become a reference point for many here.. you believe it or not.. the rest agree or not... so when you say this show has nothing good left to show... and that future tracks will not be effective enough, then somehow it will affect the thinking of rest too... You are the daddy of redux, hence expectations are little higher from you.. hope you understand the reson behind me coming up with all these... I know I'll have to justify to 100 odd people why I said so, how from past 2 days, I was feeling an urge to say this for I cannot hold back when I'm eager to say something... hmm probably I don't fit into this extremely logical and intellectual family 😕



Ranjitha , not like that sweety... i tried so hard during that mausam time ... during other nonsensical times ... but I am losing patience tooo ... I felt bad in posting today as just seeing me reserve all were elated but unhein bhi dhokein mein kaise rakhoon bolo ??? it's better to face the truth than stay in illusion ...

Waise who told you that you don't fit here??? you do fit here ... and I respect you views too ... bas tujhe teach karna aacha lagta hain 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".