NEED HELP !!! PLZ !! with My Frustration regarding Chandini !!!

ChitraGS thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1

Hello everyone, yes its me again and I am a bit low especially after the watered down episode we had today. There was not need to drag todays episode, given the fact that the CV's are rushing with this wedding track 😕.

I have been reading a few posts on IF and outside IF and have a lot of people judging, misjudging and over judging Chandini. I am doing none of the above as I do not like Chandini at the moment. Post the baby track. Full stop. !!! 😡

But since I have read some amazing posts trying explain her character as well as actions,as well as had a good whack up my backside by my good friend Sharada 😆, who wanted me to empathise and sympathise with Chandini. I decided to make a post and throw this question to this forum to help me please 😃!!! , so I can better understand Chandini.😉

Okay here are my points of grievances so please read them and explain and clarify to your best ability. Let me warn you that I am not someone who is easily convinced, but nevertheless I am someone who once convinced will stick to it with full conviction. I believe in a healthy debate , so please let us keep this discussion as a healthy as possible to discuss are differences and POV on this character.


Please note I am only speaking about Chandini ( and not about Shivani, so wud really appreciate if you didnt make personal remarks on Shivani. I love Shivani to bits and I think she is portraying this character beautifully 👍🏼)


Okay , so here we go


  1. Chandini is a broken soul herself. : Okay I am willing to give her that. She has had a lot to deal with with her dad, mum ,stepmum , Dev and above all with Meghu recently while having to deal with her own kidnapping trauma and PTSD.

  2. Chandini loves Aday : No I dont think she loves him , tho she is attracted towards him and is confused why. She is clearly torn between her love for Dev and her attraction for Advay, Dont blame her coz Advay is way ttooo hottt to handle😳 !! HEHE😉

  3. Chandini trusts Advay : No , I don't think she trusts him. Chandini is the only person who knows Advay has or had multiple passports and multiple ID's which he destroyed right in front of her eyes. So practically one wud only assume that any person who is hiding his ID shud be fraught with caution. 😲

    Also Advay has made it clear he wants to ruin her family and Chandini will do kuch bhi for her family, hence why , she will want to stay away from him. Also I read somewhere that Advay only speaks the truth to chandini, I disagree on that too, coz Advay hasn't first of all told his reality to her. ( AKA abt DEV ) , also Advay always puts Chandini in trouble with her family,

    He lied blatantly that she had called him to rescue her when in reality he had called her ( how I know, I replayed the epi, and Chandinis phone rings after she cuts the call to Indrani, so Advay called her for sure, but lied about it easily). Hence why she says to him ki aap , jhoot bol rahe hai, please dont lie.

    He also lies about the fact that they are in love in front of her family, when they clearly are not. So as far as Chandini is concerned Advay is a dishonest man with dishonest intentions only here to dishonor and defame her family name.

  4. Chandini decided to give the baby away and did Meghu a favor : Seriously this is a sore topic for me, I don't even want to discuss this , coz no matter how much you try to convince me on this, I don't think I am going to budge.

    What Chandini did was the ultimate betrayal IMO , to Meghu but more so to a 1 day old baby, given the fact that she too is an almost orphan , who doesn't have a mother and has a father only for namesakes.

    If she really want to do a favor, she cud have convinced Meghu to make this decision in a rational and sensible way. Mind you only convinced not pressurised. But no she had done neither and has decided to decide for her sister and has sealed the fate of an innocent child in the process.

    I am not so upset that the baby was given up to an orphanage as we do hear and read about many such stories and it sad really that our society is responsible for such heartless decisions. But what annoyed me was the fact that she decided on behalf of Meghu and didn't even give meghu a chance to decide the fate of her own child, so much so that Meghu doesn't even know her baby is alive, so she hasn't even held her baby to her bosom.

    Now this is simply too much for me to handle, SORRY !!! I am not a mother yet , but still I feel so strongly on this point, I am sure a lot of our IF members who are mothers wud have cringed at what Chandini has done to Meghu. Is there a redemption from this, I clearly dont think there shud be one, but I am willing to give her a chance as she too is a broken soul owing to her need to see her mummy happy.


So above are my points , the ones that I can think of at the moment,

TBH the only thing that I have come to believe about Chandini till now, is that Advay somehow manages to bring out the worst or maybe the best in Chandini.

He manages to challenge her and make her do and say things that are actually out of her character. Or maybe not, maybe this is how she is, a bold strong confident girl who has lost her voice owing to Mummy and her manipulations,

But Advay manages to crack that Sati savitri image and lets her be who she truly is, I believe only in Advays presence Chandini becomes her own person and fights him back , just like how she used to when she was still a child and was unaware of the ways of the world.

Hence maybe why she is attracted towards him, as she is her true self only when with him, Hence why she cries when he is hurt and feels comfortable with him to discuss the trauma of her abduction. Advay helps us stand on her own feet as well as stand up for herself, She is now standing up to him but soon will find her voice to actually stand up to Indrani too one day i think.


So guys the above are my points of grievances towards Chadnini along with my assumptions of her character so far.

So please advise and suggest your thoughts and assumptions on this matter so I can finally begin to see her with a renewed sense of faith and finally manage to sleep well at night HEHE😆


Cheers, Chitra





Edited by ChitraGS - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

51

Views

3k

Users

20

Likes

260

Frequent Posters

.Ashleydevlin. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Nice post. What I assume is chandhni's reply to all the questions,'' kuch kuch hota hai, tum nahi samjho gi''


2filmy thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Point 2. add her blind love for her mom too
Point 3 Of course he will not tell her he is Dev
She will blabber it to Indrani and the Dev will be killed
Pagal hai kya Advay ?
She still trusts him to some extent
I cannot explain that
I agree with your thoughts at the moment that you said
-Sush- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#4

For me...it is very simple...
Chandani is a good soul...who has been manipulated by Indrani as a child...she has innocently said things that have helped Indranis wicked plans to destroy Devs family...
CHandani trusted Dev...and is still hopeful that he will show up to save her...
She feels very indebted to her step mother for providing her a family, and protecting her...
She feels she has to do whatever she can to pay back to the family who has been so good to her...

The kidnapping has traumatized her...but she has kept her fighting spirit...
I don't see her as a broken soul...A broken soul is not full of care for others...Chandani is like a gentle light that takes away darkness...soothing to everyone...meaning no harm...
She is unsure why Advay says the things he says about her...as far as she knows...he doesn't even know her...so she brushes off what she can't explain...
She knows the thought of PP touching her makes her cringe...
She knows...somehow that's not the case with Advay...she feels physically attracted to him...
Although she brushes that aside...she is too traditional ...She does know that Advay does not like her family...and is not only holding grudges against them...he is deliberatily trying to show them down...
She doesn't like that...
She protects her family in every way she can...Protecting Megha from being social outcast for being an unwed mother was also a part of that...She wasn't thinking what is right ...what is wrong...she wanted to protect Meghna and Indrani ...and she thought that she could do that only by giving up the baby and not telling Meghna ..and that was that.

THere you have it...Chandani in a nutshell...what I didn't understand is why so many people on IF have such a tough time figuring Chandani ...I have made a mental note to ask my mom in India ...what she thinks about. Chandani...provided she is still watching IPK...😃

Oh...BTW...I do not understand the Sati Savitri comment...How can Chandani be Sati Savitri if there is no Satyavan in the picture? On the contrary...she is one of the very few FL who is actually displaying physical attraction to a guy ...who is not the "good boy" by any books...😆
Edited by -Sush- - 8 years ago
ToxicLove thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Oh I love this post. I am going to come back and see if I can try explaining Chandini, esp on giving the baby away...😳

Edited ***


I am back to write my 2 cents on Chandini but before I get to her characterization...there is something I wanna share.


Coming from a broken/disoriented family, I grew up as a timid, shy, silent girl. At a very very very young age, I watched my mother break down, fight against the life she was forced into, fight against every single person who planned to get me and my sister married after we complete 10th grade. She became fierce, independent, didnt care who supported her and who didnt. I was so proud of her, still am!


I have to admit, I was never into studies but seeing her struggle so hard to get us to a position where we could stand on our own feet, made me zealous and accomplish something that she could be proud of. And that's where it all started, as a token of gratitude for not abandoning us, I began to do things that would please her, that would make her happy. Over the years, she took some decisions that I was not really thrilled about but I chose to stay silent because that's what made her content, and ultimately happy.


As I entered into pre-teen years, my maternal family who initially showed their backs to us, started showing up at our doors, visiting us for vacations. That's where I fell weak further. Before that moment, I and my sister spent several summers/ celebrated festivals without cousins or the extended family. Our life was pretty much limited to four walls because basically we had none. So when they came back to us whether to show love or fake love, I was thrilled, I craved for their attention, and wanted to do things that would make them stick to us, to love us longer. We would give away all our (hard-earned) toys to our cousins (without mom's knowledge) simply because they would come back to us next summer at least for the new toys, if not for us! Does this emotionally connect me to Chandini? Oh Hell Yes!


Now that pleasing thingy went on for years, until one day I decided to go against my mother. It was the time my family was looking for suitor for my little sister. A guy was chosen, my family (except me and my sister) met them, they all liked his family and the guy himself. Since I was living in another town, (happily married) were asked to fly down to meet the guy. I along with my husband flew down to the guy's town and 5 mins into the meeting I knew what would be the fate of my sister if she end up marrying that guy. I returned home and told my mom that that guy is not a fit. Now remember, I didnt even discuss this with my sister who is supposed to have a say. I didnt ask her because I simply knew she would be better off without that guy. Now you can question me who am I to decide on my sister's behalf? Fair enough, it's a very valid question! But but...


Because, I knew my mother, my family, and how my sister is, and the kind of struggles we went through the childhood, I took a decision in the best interest of her. And this is exactly what Chandini had done. She didnt think if she was taking right decision or wrong decision giving the baby away. As far she knew she took a decision in the best interest of Meghu, with no malign intent.

Tomorrow my sister can come back to me and question me why had I interfered in her life. Honestly I will not have a concrete answer but as an elder sister/well wisher I did what I thought was best for her. Same way, Chandini may not have an answer for Meghana but she did what she thought was best for her little sister.


That being said, if we still want to give it a logical approach then I have to point this out...Chandini knows how it feels like to live every single day without having a true motherly love. If a woman like her had taken such a drastic decision, then don't you think it suggests there could probably be something more to the story? Something more compromising might have happened with Vashisht family or at least with Meghana that forced Chandini to do this?


We still do not know what exactly happened to Meghu at that time. So it is too early and very unfair for everyone in the forum to judge her (and Meghu for being the way she is now) But whatever might have happened, when a person (not just Chandini but anyone around us) does something like that, instead of passing a logical judgement that she shouldn't have done it or he should have done it that way...It is very important to understand there must be a reason for them (Chandini) to react that way, to decide that way. And the only person who can decide if Chandini's decision is wrong or right in this case is strictly Meghana's but no one else!



I don't mean to offend anyone with my take, but I have been waiting patiently for so many days hoping people will understand and connect to Chandini. But as days pass by I am more and more baffled as to why no one is able to relate to her. Do we have to go through something so miserable like her to understand the way she is behaving? A question that we all need to question ourselves!


PS: Chitra, thank you for posting this question. I ended up writing a composition here😆...So rambled alot! 😆😆 But calling Chandini as AblaNari and Sati Savriti kinda rubbed me in a wrong way, made me abit emotional too...but No hard feelings, I understand every one has their perspective. I just want to put mine across.




Edited by ToxicLove - 8 years ago
PSharada thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Sush has explained Chandni so well Chitra. I am going to say ditto to what she has said.
When figuring out Chandni we need to put aside - what we would do if we were in those circumstances. I guess many are not getting Chandni because they are directly comparing chandni and her actions to what they would do. We have the luxury of unconditional love and support from our family. First and foremost Chandni doesn't have that - She has a family per se but she knows it is full of lies and she is nothing more than a burden to her mother.

She wants to do right things but for wrong people. She was the one who felt really bad when Advay was drugged. But she didn't oppose her mother because she is right now standing beside her mother and her mother is wrong.


Does she love Advay. Nope not right now. Subconsciously she feels secure around Advay - it is like she knows he is someone who is there for her.Not having the luxury of unconditional love of mother, having her bestie leave her without any answers, being kidnapped and tortured - She is now drifting alone in the wind like a trembling leaf. She needs sahara, she needs her anchor in life and once she has her anchor then she will heal. And her healing is through Advay only. She knows out of all the lies spun around her, he was the only one who was truthful to her. He was the only one who honored her wishes and somewhere she did trust him to deliver on his promise that She will be his and He will be hers.


She needs to unravel the mystery of why her heart feels safe around Advay whereas the brain is telling her to hate him. That soul connection was there today too in the episode. Even when Advay was being drugged he saw his Chandni being taken away. Chandni even when she was being dragged kept on looking to see if Advay was doing okay.


Trust me this is going to be a poignant love story if they weave it right. Chandni ke baare main sirf itna kahungi ke she is someone who is fragile yet has tremendous stregth, she is someone who is docile but will fight everyone if she is provoked, she is someone who will want to solve things without hurting anyone but if anyone dare hurt her loved ones she will not hesitate to strike back. I want Indrani to try to hurt Advay again much later in the show when Chandni has fallen for Advay or when she learns that Advay is Dev - Then she is going to rise towards the danger as a tigress and is going to fight her mother. That would be the complete 360 for the character. That at one point of time Chandni who was willing to do anything for her mother will fight her mother to protect her love and her soulmate. I am waiting for that here in this story Chitra. If Harneet does give this na I am going to start a FF of my own. Bas bol diya.
Edited by PSharada - 8 years ago
Joyness thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
Chandni I agree with Sharda...Chitra you too have made valid points...but it's like Chandni doesn't have the luxury of safe loving home so much bhi to get her mom's love. As far as Advay is concerned she is attracted to him which sane girl will not be attracted. But she loves Dev till now so she is fighting her heart mind ye Kya l love Dev but I am attracted to Advay...but somewhere she feels safe with him soul connection as girls good touch bad touch in imbibed in us do Chandni feels that pp bad touch and Advay good touch..as far as baby is concerned the back story has to come. But yes Meghana ought to be the decision maker let's see why Chandni did what she did...
Channa_mereyaa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: -Sush-


For me...it is very simple...
Chandani is a good soul...who has been manipulated by Indrani as a child...she has innocently said things that have helped Indranis wicked plans to destroy Devs family...
CHandani trusted Dev...and is still hopeful that he will show up to save her...
She feels very indebted to her step mother for providing her a family, and protecting her...
She feels she has to do whatever she can to pay back to the family who has been so good to her...

The kidnapping has traumatized her...but she has kept her fighting spirit...
I don't see her as a broken soul...A broken soul is not full of care for others...Chandani is like a gentle light that takes away darkness...soothing to everyone...meaning no harm...
She is unsure why Advay says the things he says about her...as far as she knows...he doesn't even know her...so she brushes off what she can't explain...
She knows the thought of PP touching her makes her cringe...
She knows...somehow that's not the case with Advay...she feels physically attracted to him...
Although she brushes that aside...she is too traditional ...She does know that Advay does not like her family...and is not only holding grudges against them...he is deliberatily trying to show them down...
She doesn't like that...
She protects her family in every way she can...Protecting Megha from being social outcast for being an unwed mother was also a part of that...She wasn't thinking what is right ...what is wrong...she wanted to protect Meghna and Indrani ...and she thought that she could do that only by giving up the baby and not telling Meghna ..and that was that.

THere you have it...Chandani in a nutshell...what I didn't understand is why so many people on IF have such a tough time figuring Chandani ...I have made a mental note to ask my mom in India ...what she thinks about. Chandani...provided she is still watching IPK...😃

Oh...BTW...I do not understand the Sati Savitri comment...How can Chandani be Sati Savitri if there is no Satyavan in the picture? On the contrary...she is one of the very few FL who is actually displaying physical attraction to a guy ...who is not the "good boy" by any books...😆

exactly totally agree sush
ToxicLove thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
sorry double post😕
Edited by ToxicLove - 8 years ago
Rimi_BS thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
I totally agreed with Sush,Psharada, Toxiclove..
They have said it all...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".