More than meets the eye - Game On!!! - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

203

Views

23.2k

Users

53

Likes

974

Frequent Posters

asya34 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#71

Originally posted by: sky-if

@asya, sorry have to ask - how can the Oberois (happened in the ML track too) claim to be watched 24x7 in their own house and do nothing about it? Who is black sheep? Svet? 😆


Obviously someone in the house just like they had Tia and Svet back then ... who pata nahi but it seems they want that person to continue to watch or they would have shut it down by now ...
Like in the ML case he needed that chip and that is why the kept up the charade till that point
asya34 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#72
Hey Asya,
I am a silent member of the forum. But I couldn't help but post today.

Before I start on the response, let me just say I love all your posts. They are great insights into the character and story. tks and yes we are just 'brain stroming ' here so that we don't completely lose it with this crazy track ...lol

Coming to the post, you have an interesting theory, but I somehow find difficult to convince myself because of some scenes that were shown. If Shivaay, Anika and OmRu are in the plan together and Anika is acting based on Shivaay's direction, then how does the scene where Shivaay asks the goons to beat him up make sense? I dont think someone is watching them 24/7. What about the tragic breakdown of Shivika after the divorce sequence which was done in closed rooms? CV's have to keep us convinced that it is a separation. You really feel that they are letting on that there is anything but separation and new entry's romantic angle right now?? This discussion is the only reason that it is being questioned.

To me, if I watch the episodes without questioning and just accept what is happening at face value it looks like this to me and please correct me if I am wrong.
Pinky blackmailed Annika with Shivvay's illegitimacy
Annika is worried, depressed and acting out of sorts but Shivvay is happily clueless and busy preparing for the wedding. The woman who he claims to love more than life itself is not herself but this man is too busy to see - busy with what?? not a crisis, business matter or a terminal illness being handled. To busy planning how to make HER happy but cannot see that she is unhappy 'right now'.
This same girl who has always sacrificed for 'His' Family mind you not hers is now throwing this fit and he is still clueless and throws her out
She spends 3 months living like a beggar with a friend but he does not raise an eyebrow wondering why she has not claimed the money that she was fighting for and was thrown out asking for.
I can go on but I won't as I am sure you know the rest

After this would you not be a little amazed if that crying and devastation had not been shown??? In fact you would probably have questioned it for not happening
... as for the crying, beating etc that was something that happened even during the ML track ... Shivvay and Annika both admitted to keeping up the act at all times so as not to alert anyone

Shivvay's devastation could very well have been real in his room ... he again was the sinner, the dark man who hurt his innocent wife and had to humiliate her at his Family's altar IF this was indeed for 'Shivvay" as she said. You cannot tell me that even acting that out did not cut like a knife through his heart
Annika's pain was real - she had to live without Shivvay for who knows how long. This girl who had not lived a day without him after they had been married. Plus she has abandonment issues and fear of rejection. Look at it from that angle and imagine her walking out alone without him at her side.

Shivvay punishing himself for causing Annika pain (getting beaten up) is not a new thing ...lol

To me it more seems like Shivaay always suspected this sudden change in Anika. He is truly committed in the relationship and to Anika. Considering the reaction from Om Ru, I think he susepcts that they were in the plan with Anika too. The video chat scene with Rudra and Anika...I think Shivaay heard Anika there and somehow figured that she was on the video watching him. Then, the call on land line phone...all of her scenes where she was hinting him of going away...I think he kinda put 2 and 2 together. He must have realized the reason must have been big enough that Anika went through the drama to cause the separation and OmRu supported her in it..the brothers who don't hide anything from him. He is very hurt that Anika made the decision single handedly to do this and didn't share with him..but I think he also understands that the reason must be big enough...So, he was first trying to do this with Chawl to make her spit out the truth...now that didn't work, so he planned this whole scenario banking on the fact that OmRu will get Anika back to bring back their brother. Now that OmRu and Anika are working together which Shivaay is aware of...he will somehow find out who made Anika so majboor to cause separation and what was the reason behind it. I think Ragini and Samar are just complications to this story which were not anticipated by Shivaay. Just a guess. But with this scenario, all those emotional scenes make sense to me. What do you think?
Absolutely ... it is very possible that this could be the scenario as well ... and yes Ragini and Samar may even happen later after they get back together ... very possible

asya34 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#73

Originally posted by: sky-if

In the Mahi track, there is a scene where Annika and Khannaji try to get him to react and slap Khanna.. and Mahi is just all chilled out - "bacche ho kya, aapas me sort out karlo" he says🤣🤣
yup! that sounds like the Shivvay right now .. maybe Mahi is giving him tips and pointers 😆
Shivay training Mahi and Mahi training Shivvay ...lol 😆

😆 That looks like just like the reaction Pinky has been getting of late 😉

Edited by asya34 - 8 years ago
Blairchuck thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#74

Originally posted by: asya34


Hi Asya ! Sorry for jumping in :p I'm first time commenting on your post but I always come here to read whatever theory you post because I love the way you write.
Anyways I was thinking about the goon beating scene , It could be that Shivaay is the one who proposed this separation plan and he watched all those 3 months Annika being all miserable and sad and that day when he came to chawl he saw her that how blankly she's looking at moon he felt her pain and to punish himself for proposing separation he asked those goons to beat him
I know I know it sounds very cliche but well this is the only thing that came into my mind after reading your theory 😆

asya34 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: bs123

Hey guys, I'm usually a silent reader, but this track is truly so mysterious that I couldn't hold myself back from commenting. Here are a few points that I think we haven't really addressed here (Please correct me if I'm wrong and feel free to add your own insight).


If you think back to the time when Shivaay was kidnapped and Mahi was introduced, we not only saw that his plane was hijacked, but also that he was kept in a remote, lavish location with electromagnetic fields to prevent him from escaping, fully equipped with servants to fulfill his needs.

Now here's my question. Do you really think Kamini and Ranveer had/have the money and power to pull off a stunt like this? I think not. There had to be others behind them for sure. Maybe this is indeed where Samar and Ragini come in to the plot. Also after his kidnapping, I do remember Shivaay saying that there must be someone rich and powerful behind the whole fake Shivaay fiasco and that he would get to the bottom of it. We never really saw him trying, or so we were made to believe.

His connection to Samar is mysterious and as a lot of you have been saying, there is definitely more than what meets the eye. Again, what is Shivaay's true motive behind his attempts to own the chawl and asking for a full background check of Samar?


Also, is it just me or did you guys also get the impression from her introductory scene that Ragini has been waiting for an opportunity to enter Shivaay's life from way before the divorce drama. Perhaps, this was just the perfection situation to do so? The reason can't be purely romantic and her motive isn't clear yet.

It makes me wonder again if her family is behind the high-end kidnapping and I'm also thinking that it's not too far fetched to suggest that Mahi has maybe spilled the beans to either Shivaay or Annika regarding this, though he is completely out of the picture at the moment.

I don't know how the CV s are going to wrap this up or if these loose ends will be dealt with soon or just left as is. But there is still the lingering illegitimacy issue that has to be dealt with, which Shivaay might or might not be aware of. (There was all the cctv footage from the hospital , OM, and the DNA test that Khanna was aware of to prove Annika's innocence).

The divorce could very well have been a plan made by Shivaay alone or both Annika and Shivaay, but the way in which it played out makes me feel that it is not something that happened with Shivaay and Annika's mutual consensus since there was so much high-voltage emotional drama that took a toll on them both. However, there might just have been a master plan behind it all.

Again, We don't know how much Shivaay knows, but he certainly knows something for sure based on the last few episodes, his behavior with Pinky, his rivalry with Samar, and his cool reaction to Annika's re-entry.

Also, as some of you have been pointing out, it just doesn't make sense for Shivaay to let Kamini off the hook so easily. She attempted to murder him for god's sake!! And Anika had to bear the brunt of it when she took the bullet. It's hard for me to believe that he has completely forgotten about everything Mahi, Kamini, and Ranveer did, not taking any action whatsoever against them. No matter how indifferent he has become to the world, I just can't buy that Shivaay would not care about the safety of a family member. Even if we accept that Ranveer has changed, Kamini has never even pretended to change her ways in front of the Oberois, so how could Shivaay just let Priyanka leave OM?

These are just some of my thoughts about all of the loose ends that the CVs have left. I might just be overanalyzing or maybe the writers are going to reveal some master plan at the end and address the points I've mentioned. What do you guys think?



wow!!! fantastic points ... now you got me thinking even more ... nothing to add but I have a lot to think about

Edited by asya34 - 8 years ago
Reeltoreal thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#78
Kudos to your patience Girl ... you should have been the writer instead of You know who ... wading thru so many plots and answering all questions with logic where no one sees logic {originally :-)} . I wish some one from IB trolls this forum and reads your thread and weave some intelligence and interest in to the story...

I am still hoping for my spin on the story where Shivay over hears the convo between Ani OmRu and does OMM of OMM royally Jaise kabhi hua na ho aur pair kabhie hoga ... man ki shanti 😛 ...

Keep going people ... this is more intriguing than any future to be aired episodes .
Edited by yash2010 - 8 years ago
asya34 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#79

Awesome post! Going to enjoy the facts and analysis presented here am sure. 😃
Am stuck at the "Kameeni is around but Mahi is conveniently missing" point for a long time now. I keep skipping the Kameeni scenes and so maybe missing some clues lol. When Shivaay (Mahi?) says he will buy the chawl kyunki thum yahan jo rehthi ho, was he referring to Annika or Kameeni?!
Hmmm ... I didn't think about that ... yeh angle sey nahi soocha maeiney .. good point as to who was living there and who said that dialogue because that is where Kamini used to stay with Mahi, right!!!??

I assumed it was Annika!!! But Annika lived at some "Shiv-Parvati " named place!!!

Shoot how did I miss that !!!
This is why I started the thread .. as i said so many shatir and intelligent dimaags will definitely dig some clues up that others have missed ... 😉

How does Annika just forget about Mahi given he is kind of tied to the reason she had to give up on her love? Exactly !!! that is not the Annika we know so see you find that strange as well

How are the Oberois not concerned at all about Praanka? again ... point that I was pondering on considering they know how Kamini is ?? So either she keeps in touch and is giving them news or she and Ranveer are on team ShivIka so that Ranveer can redeem himself and of course Mahi is watching over Prinku as you said who said that 'tum jo yahan reheti ho' statement

How is Annika now confident that her reentry into OM will not cause any effect on hubby? What if Pinky were to follow through and spill the illegitimate truth to Shivaay? Is it because he already knows now? 😉 muah!!! that is what I think too ... tks for saying that 😆

In the epi with Shivaay in the clown-wala red and black stripes suit, he is nowhere a lost soul, he is all animated and all SSO-business like and clearly he had someone monitor the chawl which is why he gets Samar's picture sent to him - so no SSO isn't lost - he just is playing don't care mode to the world and the elders in the family. Yep!! that is true for sure

If this is a Shivika plan, there are inconsistencies (like the ML track - dialogs aren't supporting the storyline but maybe that is intentional) but waiting to see how things unfold. my feelings as well

sxj126 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: asya34


No Mahi n Kamini lived in good luck chawl n this one which SSO wants to buy is Happy Home Chawl

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".