[QUOTE=smileyallora
First of all love you loads for such an awesome thread di😊gave my grey cells a quick rush up😉 Your welcome and a good dose of cold facts and deducing helps to get the emotions in check as well, don't you think ?? 😉
Diving direct to theory at hand...
How much do i love this theory? 100%
How much do i want this to happen? 100%
To what extent do i think this will actually happen? 40%. lol ... yep I know 😆
And why exactly is it?
1)As many have pointed out... yes all of pinky- anika conversation happened out in the open. But why would bad at acting pinky do OTT hatred acting to anika (if at all) especially every time she has a moment with shivaay? (I do remember cvs saying it was coincidental most times. But it was not after the nape kiss. Why would a acting evil saas do that?
Our theory is based on the fact that they are being watched at the OM by someone that they have not zeroed on yet ... so all have to act
2) the way pinky behaved with anika saying the najayaz raaz... sorry it was full of creeps not a pinch of sadness i felt there. Why would pinky the uniquely sucker at acting do such a daksh's mom like performance out there? There was a lot of feeling in that scene I do admit but she was speaking about Kamini as well and that is where the emotions may have come from - the fact that she had been lied to about her other son Mahi's existence and it being hidden all these years from her... she is Shivvay's-Mahi's mother we know that as Gul has said that Shivvay is NOT illegitimate many times so imagine her now finding out her other son grew up with Kamini all these years away from his mothers love
Again this is on the theory that we have mentioned not GulNeets at Face Value
3)why did shivaay cut the anika's call remembering that ugly throw her out confrontation?
How do we know that she did not mention something to him that made him cut it off in anger? Like 'I met Samar at the chawl today' ... the CV's just showed us shots of the two on the phone that is all ... also as per our theory they are supposed to keep up the act remember?
4) shivaay singh oberoi is and has always been a hyper protective brother. I just can't cvs justifying him compromising prinku's marriage just like that with ranveer just for the sake of fighting against the malhotras. So with that logic how did he accept Ranveer that easily then?? Just because his wife said that marriages should be given another chance?? Really!!?? GulNeet's way does not make sense either
In our theory Ranveer is no longer the bad guy ... he needs to be redeemed as well soon, remember??
Then why did he react very very ugly with anika that she had cried her eyes out that day?if it was an act why did he flip again saying he believed her? That is a question I ask you because you say that 'there is no plan' so why the flip?? What made him say that? He did not say he saw what Gauri saw on the CCTV footage??
Wouldn't it have been easy to throw her away that day itself if at all it was a plan (with or without anika in plan) again I ask you that ... why was the media and the tamasha needed for the world to see?? Why the great big show??
5 )whats with the stone singh oberoi? Why should he behave indifferent to even his family members?given that om went into coma i really don't think any family member including shivaay would be keen on maintaining the pretense (stone singh n whatever) if at all it was a pretense Would you say he was almost like Mahi those days and even now??
6)about daima clip... its the latest mallika bangles. Cvs don't really bother about its logics. We have seen how bad they flip with mahi ,ML track and why not the infamous daksh as ranveer 's mamu (Ranveer is not related to Kamini by blood. He is her (allegedly) friends son that she brought up as her own)
and robin aka dushyant. Robin and kali thakur came back from death KT no comments as that is DBO as for Robin, I always knew he had to return or how would it be proven that she was already married to Robin when trying to marry Shivvay.
... so why wouldn't the chip grow and end up being a pen drive at tia's house? So you think that was just bad editing??
7)if its all a ruse, why the omru and anika confrontation where she is explaining them the najayaz raaz? Om can't act that good. He is sach's beta. (Even during shitia shaadi 3 he never lied. He just kept the mobile aside smirking. Nothing more nothing else.
But he kept up the charade of Annika's ML and pitched in with the acting even on Shivvay's wedding day so in effect he did not lie but just evaded the truth in a round about way ... so yes he is a good actor but of course does not lie outright.
) But here i saw genuine angst and tadap. Why would they do that? Why did anika get a promise from them? I know I keep repeating this but it is based on someone watching them ... Why all this confrontation (and all others we have seen and will see) and reveling such secrets in the open if Annika does not ant Shivvay to hear?? Would she not have done it behind closed doors if she was that afraid of him overhearing it??😆
I am sure every Oberoi maid and help heard that secret there ..lol
8)its shivaay... who had hated to stay away from her even after he had challenged in farak games in shitia shaadi 3. "Stay in this bedroom. What if something happens to you" he said scared that she might get into trouble if she slept in the study.
"Stay angry but stay in the house"
"As long as your sister is with me sahil ... nothing will happen to her. I pinky promise you" he said to sahil who was scared about her life after gun shot.
"You and sahil will be safe with me in oberoi mansion" shivaay during stalker and first hug sequence.
My point is the guy is always damn sure that her safety is with him and him only. He wants her to be with him willingly or unwillingly. If at all she had a threat from malhotras, i just don't see any sane reason why he would pretend to leave her. This is not yet another sane guy. He is insanely in love with her that he swore that he would fight even god for her. So why wouldn't he fight for her by keeping her with him(shivaay never compromises with her safety... if there was a threat to her safety before i can totally see shivaay become a kangroo carrying anika 😆😉) Who is to say that there was no safety arranged at the chawl when she lived there. And if he did not have he watched then how the heck did he know Samar was there?? Why did he care that Samar bought the chawl ??
As for Annika's safety we know that he does sometimes let her take risks - throwing her from the top floor (the ML track) imo was a big risk but I also know that he only takes calculated risks
9)divorce- too huge showdown for shivaay in front of media. NT also. But if pinky not evil what about NT hiring? NT is somehing no one understands even with the GulNeet plot at face value so for the theory to make sense of it would be unfair as we have not been given any leads about what happened in those 3 months to understand where this whole Samar thing comes in
And how on earth will shivaay justify sahil kidnapping then? was the shivaay redemption also fake? How did NT get so much money to kidnap Sahil?? Did they show that Pinky gave her that money and asked her to do that?? What did anyone gain out of Sahil's kidnapping?? Neither NT nor Pinky benefitted and Om did mention that to Shivvay but he just cut him off then if you remember and we all found that very very odd.
So pinky is EVIL. that is a CV call ... we are only stating facts here not trying to redeem Pinky ...lol
THERE MAYBE A FAIR CHANCE OF SHIVAAY AND OMRU BE IN PLAN TO BRING BACK ANIKA.
BUT...
10)why the jealousy game? Shivaay must not be affected as he knows the truth right? plan within a plan - ML style is what we are asking you to think 😉
I have loads more questions di... but since am very sick unable to type... will ask soon. I know one thing about the cvs... they don't lile complications. .. they love to keep things complicatedly simple😉
I would love to know your view on these questions.
Ps. Sorry that i couldn't reply you before in that length breadth thread because of my sickness. Thanks a lot.😊
Love Friendship Dating and Relationships
Bindi
