More than meets the eye - Game On!!!

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

travelholic

@travelholic

Rocker

Posted: 8 years ago

#161

khichdi abhi bhi pakk rahi hai yahan pe, lage raho my munni baiis - i love it 😳

Quote

asya34

@asya34

Dazzler

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#162

Wow! You need to be story writers! Excellent analysis.

Roop also had a husband whom they showed in shadows! Sultan??

The antidote giving pseudo scientist Svetlana! Ice box Queen ...lol .. she is Kelvinator - the coolest one!!! 😉

There was another lady where Shivaai was kept a prisoner who said i dont have any chance, here, use my phone. Who is that lady? That much detail they might not pay attention to .. if they do then it will be a shock 😆

And when pinky instantly realized Mahi as the other twin, Shakthi doesnt care about it all? Yup!! they are Shakti's sons for sure even if they are not Pinky's!!!?? 😕

And earlier when Kamini was first introduced, it did not look as though Pinky knew about her at all! Correct again

Then there us the factory secret! The video in their safe which Tej was afraid of! Could the senior Malhothra be in that angle? Again Correct

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

jeenal

@jeenal20

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 8 years ago

#163

The serial is getting all confusing now...

Cant make out whether all is planned or not

Quote

asya34

@asya34

Dazzler

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#164

I was thinking about NT drama... if it was staged then it makes sense why Shivaay never reacted on Pinky's slip-ups like when she mentioned Shivaay left his number with the paanwala. We've seen during Mahi track, Pinky has her slip-ups when she's nervous like when she said to Mahi "mera murder mat karna" right again ... Pinky is very nervous about acting and she tends to go OTT with it hence the Annika-Pinky scenes coming off as cringe worthy even for Shivvay's taste (when she brings the necklace and he says "han - jao jao" ...lol

okay a question came to my mind... why did GulNeet cry while writing this separation if its staged? 😆 becuase by all accounts for ShivIka it IS A REAL judiaii ... they have to stay away from each other with zilch communication for who knows how long??? This is a plan and they do not know when they will be together again

Quote

asya34

@asya34

Dazzler

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#165

This is all good to be true. The writers can't be this competent. Roop was scrapped wasn't she? I mean we know Roop knows Svet, but that explains nothing. Its a loophole. Even Gayatri's death, killer unknown.

I want to believe this is a possibility, but its far too elaborate. I just can't imagine this, even though its so good. ...lol we are just having fun trying to figure out the plot just like GulNeet are having fun hiding it from us ... beats being emotional and depressed all the time with the 'rona-dhona' they are throwing our way .. 😉

Quote

asya34

@asya34

Dazzler

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#166

Hi Peral
First thanks for this thread no thanks needed ... it is just a fun thread and belongs to all ... 😊

I have been rewatching the show all weekend and You can actually see that when pinky saw that annika means something to shivay she started hating her so I think this was coming that she maid annika leave shivay
I don't know if you read harnets interview but she was talking about that shivays growth is finished and he has made his retemshin and that it's annikas time to start to grow and stop having insecurities but I think this interview was before they started to do damage control and changeout the track because it didn't work with the audiences
The belev that they are really doing a damage control and change the track little bit and I think to to gain back the lost trp the makers going to and change the game and make it as it was shivika game but I don't think that was the original track

oh and i forgot is it me or shivay sems like he is regretting that he threw annika out that way and that he didn't think and get angry It is time for Annika's growth and I think she is handling it well if this is a plan and they did stay away for 3 months then she did not lose faith in Shivvay and was confident of his commitment to her ... what he said at the Dargah was that I feel ... "jo kuch humare ... " and when she held her MS and consoled herself that a mere piece of paper does not end their marriage and the very first one "Jab tak Shivvay mere saath hai..." If that was how the plot was woven then I can assure you there has been immense growth and she is stronger in her trust and faith in Shivvay and is confident that no matter what happens and how long they stay apart HE WILL NEVER LEAVE HER EVER!!!
So As far as I can see she passed with flying colors

If it was not a plan then I am sorry she has not shown any growth and there is a chance she never will. These 3 months were her chance to prove that she was strong in her faith about who ShivIka were and what they shared. As she has been shown to again adopt her defeatist attitude and has not fought for what is hers but is infact shown running away to another city again I can safely conclude that there was no growth with this plot.
That growth did not happen and now that she is back at OM there is no scope for that growth ever again. That ship has passed

Shivvay regretting throwing Annika out will of course flash in his mind but only if he has figured out or already knows that doing that was wrong
But as Harneet said Shivvay's growth has already been achieved so he could not have made this grievous mistake AGAIN which then means it was an act and he regrets that he had to treat his wife that way in front of the world even though it was an act

Edited by asya34 - 8 years ago

Quote

laola

@laola

Navigator

Posted: 8 years ago

#167

Reading all of the theories the only scene that stood out to me glaringly then and now was the scene where Anika goes missing and returns with Gauri. When she said she went to the salon why did shivaay question her again or if she shivaay was completely oblivious to her plan then why was he and the whole family so worried, Anika is not a prisoner the only time Anika left the house and shivaay was super worried was during the ML track. I guess Anika had to leave publicly with the drama otherwise if the goal was to kick her out then she could have snuck out quietly taken sahil and left the city. Sahil is at the same school or summer camp someone is paying for it and anika remains in the city at the locale previously known to shivaay.

Quote

asya34

@asya34

Dazzler

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#168

I have been silently reading this thread!So many logical theories that are interesting but trust me writers & gul do not have brains to think logically!They wouldn't have thought half of these theories too!

There is a new interview of harneet where she clearly states shivika separated due to internal conflicts pinky just acted as a catalyst!Shivaay's nkk & anika's insecurity led to the separation!This separation was needed to come back stronger!She also states that shivaay has been redeemed & his journey from heartbreak back to love will be intense and beautiful! Now this interview clearly indicates that the separation is real! But none of this refutes our theory at all !!! Infact it ties in perfectly
Internal conflicts does not necessary mean Saas-Bahu
Pinky was catalyst not cause
Shivvay's NKK as we know IS Kamini claiming he and Mahi are her sons
Annika's insecurities again as I wrote in Malose's post

And not one of us (supporting the ShivIka planned this separation theory) said that the separation was NOT real ... if your spouse goes off overseas on work or to the border as a undercover cop/ soldier is that separation not planned but real ???
That pain of being away is real ...not keeping in contact is real... fretting if he/she will ever return is real ... not being able to predict when you will see them is real ... and now imagine that you fought before he/she left and had unkind words the least time that you met ... how much more painful is that

Now let me share my theory!

The separation,angst is real! Shivaay realizes that he threw her out & she didn't bother to come back & explain coz she has always done that! So he keeps a tab on her & makes sure she doesn't get a job at all!He probably goes to her chawl every night just to get a glimpse of her!The cvs have not made this clear though!He wants her to come back & answer his questions!

Quick qts and pls again it is just a discussion, I am not shooting down any theory ... like I said we are discussing the plot with zilch emotions here - only facts 😃

One fine day he gets to know about samar's visit to the chawl & the possessive hubby that he is wants to buy the chawl so that his visits can be regular & he doesn't have to hide,also keep that samar away from his wife
Why??? Why does it matter if Samar owns the chawl ... obviously someone other than Shivvay owns it right now so why not Samar??
And a dozen young handsome guys probably visit the chawl or pass her on the streets, offer her a seat in the bus etc etc ... why is Samar a thorn in the side ... ever think about it??

The dargah scene he misunderstood her to have moved on!He is hurt!He probably knows she wouldn't do that but he gets a reason to hurt her,taunt her he does it!As he walks back to the car the engagement voice over keeps lingering in his mind & just then he gets the news that samar has bought the chawl!
again you are basing this on emotions ... Shivvay is not emotional by nature ... he deals with facts and he has stated that over and over again ... if he can find out who bought the chawl it take him not more than a phone call to Chanda (who he probably already has on speed dial from the last time) to ask who Annika is getting engaged to ... because right now he has shot off his mouth without thinking and that means he owes her an apology and I can assure you that after what Annika (supposedly ) did to him he will make sure he never even talks to her forget apologizes ...

So Annika hurts him and wounds him with what she did and the CV's show Shivvay being in the wrong at the Dargah?? How is that redeeming Annika?? Now it makes Annika more Mahan imo

There u go he goes crazy,smashes things & gets himself locked up!The sso surrendering himself is shocking to anybody,the police would have called someone from his family that was rudy! Shivaay knows what the reaction will be,he expected the news to reach anika & knew she would come running else their brothers would certainly bring their bhabhi for their bhai!Anika cannot bear shivaay's hate for her,decided to leave!That's when somebody stops her,it's definitely rudy!Omru get the OM for anika!Shivaay comes back & I am.Sure khanna must have informed him about house papers! except for the smashing because he is angry part I agree with the rest as that ties in with the planned separation as well ... they have to make the world believe she came back to save him from himself

Everyone start attacking shivaay & shivaay is like it's only going to affect my life!He knew what's happening but pretended! Then he sees her chandni & there she comes!He was absolutely calm,composed,smirking as though this is exactly what he wanted! She says it's my house & you all have to do what I say & he smirks,walks away ignoring pinky's drama! again agree but imo all are in this drama

So this means he wanted her back,she is there,now he will keep her away from samar,also he will extract what he wants slowly(the answers to her behaviour that day) again you mentioned Samar but why is he so important only because he visited the chawl ad brought it ??? What if Mr. Bajaj had visited her and bought the chawl ?? Would Shivvay still try to buy it then bring her home??

They will play all the jealousy,farak padta hai games why??

using rohit,ragini & samar! When the truth is revealed,ragini & co will turn permanent villains!

Ps: I don't know if it made sense but just shared what I felt! He sure knows she played a game,he just wants answers and the truth from her now,which he will extract eventually! then it should be him playing the FPH games not her at this point as he needs the answers😉

Edited by asya34 - 8 years ago

Quote

surjyotapa

@surjyotapa

Dazzler

Posted: 8 years ago

#169

Thank U for this beautiful thread...

Of course, there are many possibilities. As we would never know whether Gul has changed the track or not, she always has the advantage of turning the story in whichever direction she likes.

As a regular viewer who does not want much complications, I would say that she should be careful this time.

Now it is clearly visible that Shivaay is suspicious, but we don't know how much he knows... At this point if they try to sell us that it was all along Shivaay's plan people would feel betrayed again. Pinky can't be redeemed so easily saying that what she was doing was all drama, as the majority are expecting her punishment.

If it was all Shivica plan, then it will be clear that all shivica emotions were fake, though few like us who analyze every scene would know some of those were real but the common viewer will find everything meaningless and leave this show.

I can assure this will happen as I have seen this happening during ML track, many of my friends stopped watching this show as all the Shivika romance, their pain, everything felt meaningless after revelation... my friend even told me that those romances were forced as shivika were acting, shivaay does not love Annika, he is using her... (sorry, but I have got this kind of feedback after ML track)...

So if this time they again try to so sell the same story they have to be very careful ... it will be good if they show Shivaay does not know the whole truth. Simple story never fails to win hearts,they should keep the story simple.

Just shared few opinions from a group of people who once used to watch this show for entertainment, but now has stopped watching it due to its inconsistency.

I hope there will be no more marriage drama for Shivaay, makers should know that people are tired of watching same old 'Billu ki Shadi' & 'Annika ki beizzati" ... So No More Shadi please

Edited by surjyotapa - 8 years ago

Quote

asya34

@asya34

Dazzler

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#170

i am loving this thread...not getting bored of reading it neither am I, so that makes 2 of us ...lol 😆

reading @bs123 & @real12 & asya's comments i'm really starting to believe this is all a master plan kuch toh jhol hai and it may not be exactly as we say but you have to admit that there is a lot of stuff that does not tie up.

my only prolblem (if this is the fact) is AniOmRu...can Annika really be acting her tears and crying and hugging shivaay's clothes for the sake of drama mein baanj hu??? remember that drama??? ... the ehassa drama near the pool and I am sure there were many others ...
But seriously in this case they were probably real as she WAS going away for how long she did not know ... so yes I can see the tears as being real

even OmRu's out burst was geuniune...i would like to belive that shivaay kept the 3 people he loves the most out of this plan just to keep them safe If she really was going away then I can see the boys distressed for real

bbut what about shivaay's heart attack??u think he would have been this effected by being seperated from Annika if she was part of the plan {it also explains shivika's angst) I think his attack WAS real .. he was really affected by the whole drama that was clear

p.s: gosh i hope this becomes true and it's all shivaay's plan...but without AniOmRu I don't think he would keep them out of this

yaar some one should really tweet harneet this thread..u guys might give her great ideas...i really want to see this stuff play out😭😭😭 Harneet ko heart attack ho gaye ga like Shivvay ..lol 😆

someone should write a story about this {the plan without AniOmRu} ...pretty please asya😭😭😭 I might as I am working on the next chapter right now ... lets see how much I can weave in 😉 I don't like long Judaii's and these extra people in my story so it might be a little difficult

Quote

1 ... 15 16 17 18 19 ... 21

More than meets the eye - Game On!!! - Page 17

Related Topics

Explore Topics