Why Priveer Fans Should Not Read This Post. - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

34

Views

4.4k

Users

30

Likes

220

Frequent Posters

Pixiepixel11 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#11
Bang on post.
You said it all.
LordLuminous thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#12
I have never read PriVeer fanfic nor was I ever much of an avid fan to their pairing. PriVeer's marriage turned into a fanfiction for ShivIka's progression. What I wanted was PriVeer being a slap in the face to Shivaay. PriVeer had potential too, but I don't care much for it now.
Anyways, great analysis.
richa1792 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 2 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#13
While I agree with everything that you have written, despise the deplorable acts that Ranveer is/has committed, I can't help but play the Devils's advocate here.

You see, Priyanka's crime is no less than Ranveer's. How easily we have forgotten that she is responsible for his sister being in a coma. His sister almost died because of her. And she didn't care. She wanted to save her own hide, so she hid behind the Oberoi name. How completely powerless he must have felt, him being an ACP, him being someone who helps people get justice. He couldn't get justice for his sister. He is just a cop and the Oberoi's are too big a name and power for him to tackle. This time, David doesn't win over Goliath.

I don't condone his actions, I understand them. I get where he is coming from. Imagine the only family that you have, that family is wasting away, fighting for her life. All because an entitled brat couldn't be bothered. Couldn't possess enough empathy to help the victim. Your blood boils. You want justice. That is what you are. Justice is why you became an ACP, why you wear this uniform. And if you cannot get justice, then fine. You'll get vengeance.

What is happening to Prinku is wrong. She is being raped in a way, yes. She has had her choices taken away from her, yes. But who is to say that she doesn't deserve it after the crime she committed, the life that she almost took? In fact, as good as took. Because wasting away in a coma like a vegetable is no life at all.

I am in no way supporting any romantic entanglement between the two. I have decided to view them as two individuals. One with a burning need of vengeance, with shades of grey so dark they are almost black. But this shade was forced on him. He was pushed down into this dirt. And another one with a vulnerable heart and mind. Bathed in white but if you look closely, stained with black marks. Needing redemption but having no idea how to even go asking about it.

That would be good conflict, drama that I would love watching.
bworm thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#14
I liked priveer.
Dont Know What Is GUL planning...but we are going to hate it.

Bang on post again.

Wish this all is someone extended dream sequence and we get our original ib back
😭
LordLuminous thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: richa1792

While I agree with everything that you have written, despise the deplorable acts that Ranveer is/has committed, I can't help but play the Devils's advocate here.

You see, Priyanka's crime is no less than Ranveer's. How easily we have forgotten that she is responsible for his sister being in a coma. His sister almost died because of her. And she didn't care. She wanted to save her own hide, so she hid behind the Oberoi name. How completely powerless he must have felt, him being an ACP, him being someone who helps people get justice. He couldn't get justice for his sister. He is just a cop and the Oberoi's are too big a name and power for him to tackle. This time, David doesn't win over Goliath.

I don't condone his actions, I understand them. I get where he is coming from. Imagine the only family that you have, that family is wasting away, fighting for her life. All because an entitled brat couldn't be bothered. Couldn't possess enough empathy to help the victim. Your blood boils. You want justice. That is what you are. Justice is why you became an ACP, why you wear this uniform. And if you cannot get justice, then fine. You'll get vengeance.

What is happening to Prinku is wrong. She is being raped in a way, yes. She has had her choices taken away from her, yes. But who is to say that she doesn't deserve it after the crime she committed, the life that she almost took? In fact, as good as took. Because wasting away in a coma like a vegetable is no life at all.

I am in no way supporting any romantic entanglement between the two. I have decided to view them as two individuals. One with a burning need of vengeance, with shades of grey so dark they are almost black. But this shade was forced on him. He was pushed down into this dirt. And another one with a vulnerable heart and mind. Bathed in white but if you look closely, stained with black marks. Needing redemption but having no idea how to even go asking about it.

That would be good conflict, drama that I would love watching.


Nice Devil's Advocate there, I actually didn't see this angle. I applaud this really. 👏 I feel like the repulsive theme of the Oberoi's bending the law to their will is an excellent reason for an ACP like Ranveer to hate the Oberois. God knows how many officers lost their jobs to the Oberois.

Sure, Ranveer is bad, but does that mean Oberois are good? Not entirely, right?
nikki.171 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#16

I am disappointed, so very disappointed. PriVeer is just one of the disappointments. I wasn't ever a PriVeer shipper but I did think that this relationship could have been developed beautifully and in the sense that it could have only added to the story and the dynamics between Obrois all with Ranveer having been involved with Shivaay in the Gayatri case and not really possessing all the NKK. Sure, I wasnt really into how the Ranveer decided to stalk Prinku. But then I understood where he was coming from. But after the truth of his sister being alive came out, i didn't really see his desperation in torturing the Obrois and especially Prinku. It seemed like the ACP became even more vicious after that. And thats where the second point you mentioned comes in... being an ACP. What he did before was wrong, but to some extent maybe understandable. But with what he is doing right now! Its despicable and absolutely disgusting. Even more so because he is supposed to be the man who is supposed to protect the people - brave and honest. Not a manipulative jerk who wears the badge of law and yet thinks of himself above it. Deplorable!

Before this point, I could see the direction of PriVeer and despite not being a shipper, I enjoyed reading their stories and was excited in watching them evolve. Now. Nop. Like you said, he's not the man I wanted him to be especially for a timid and sweet person like Prinku.. I didn't mind the Ranveer of the beginning but the one we are shown now... What a reverse the ACP and Tia have taken.

I think the CVs are also at fault here. Ever since this track between them started after a gap of months, I feel like they arent showing us the Ranveer that he is, or his thought process, when he is not busy blackmailing or playing good boy.

Oh and they never clearly showed us what supposedly happened the night of the accident. I wonder if this too will be brushed under the rug like so many other things.
Edited by nikki.171 - 8 years ago
vivacious_gurl thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#17
I hv nothing left to say... Priveer or no... They hv reduced a police officer into a hard-core criminal... So demeaning to the service a police man is supposed to provide... It's disgusting to the core...
ACP Randhawa is nothing but a coward conniving bas***d... N What better can u expect when he has a mama who is psycho and a mother who is shamelessly lose charactered...
dimaag thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#18
Totally agree Navin!! Nothing to add. But I think, what the CVs are making us watch is based on his status as a mere Police officer against the mighty Oberois. I still can't take Daksh and Kamini as his family members. These three have joined hands for seeking revenge from the Oberois.
I was happy watching the initial episodes of his introduction. But when they started with the torture ranting, I thought the track is going downhill. And exactly so. The CVs have butchered an uniformed Police officer into a typical criminal.
Soapoperasrfun thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: richa1792

While I agree with everything that you have written, despise the deplorable acts that Ranveer is/has committed, I can't help but play the Devils's advocate here.

You see, Priyanka's crime is no less than Ranveer's. How easily we have forgotten that she is responsible for his sister being in a coma. His sister almost died because of her. And she didn't care. She wanted to save her own hide, so she hid behind the Oberoi name. How completely powerless he must have felt, him being an ACP, him being someone who helps people get justice. He couldn't get justice for his sister. He is just a cop and the Oberoi's are too big a name and power for him to tackle. This time, David doesn't win over Goliath.

I don't condone his actions, I understand them. I get where he is coming from. Imagine the only family that you have, that family is wasting away, fighting for her life. All because an entitled brat couldn't be bothered. Couldn't possess enough empathy to help the victim. Your blood boils. You want justice. That is what you are. Justice is why you became an ACP, why you wear this uniform. And if you cannot get justice, then fine. You'll get vengeance.

What is happening to Prinku is wrong. She is being raped in a way, yes. She has had her choices taken away from her, yes. But who is to say that she doesn't deserve it after the crime she committed, the life that she almost took? In fact, as good as took. Because wasting away in a coma like a vegetable is no life at all.

I am in no way supporting any romantic entanglement between the two. I have decided to view them as two individuals. One with a burning need of vengeance, with shades of grey so dark they are almost black. But this shade was forced on him. He was pushed down into this dirt. And another one with a vulnerable heart and mind. Bathed in white but if you look closely, stained with black marks. Needing redemption but having no idea how to even go asking about it.

That would be good conflict, drama that I would love watching.


Hi Richa. I thought about this. I really did. Which is why in my earlier response I mentioned that when he was trying to get Priyanka to admit to her crime, I understood his actions.

In my opinion the problem is with him being a cop. No matter what, that tag comes with a responsibility. He is human at the end of the day and is bound to make mistakes. But when you are a doctor, you cannot kill a patient simply because he / she did something wrong, ins't it? As a cop Ranveer has the same responsibility.

Ranveer emotionally troubled Priyanka and Om because he knew they had done something wrong to his sister but he didn't have enough evidence to take the necessary actions. He had to have one of them admit to the crime. He chose Priyanka. Then, Priyanka admitted her crime, she confessed it to him. At that stage, all Ranveer had to do was act like a cop and arrest her. Yes, the Oberoi's are influential and they would probably get her out of prison. But he had the evidence, and he should have fought in the right way. He owed it to his post, his profession.

This thing of showing a cop bound by his need for revenge and spoiling the life of a girl who has admitted her crime is not justified. Yes, Priyanka wronged him and his sister. There is a legal channel that he should use to have her punished. What he is doing now is not justified.

Also, Om supported her. Shivaay did nothing (wrt him). So how can he justify what he is putting Shivaay through? What about the whole Oberoi family that has nothing to do with Ranveer or his sister?

I don't agree that his actions are justifiable (even in the name of revenge). I would have completely supported him had he arrested Priyanka, tried to break this story in the media to make sure Priyanka cannot escape justice etc. But this is not justifiable.

They just spoilt another character beyond redemption!
napstermonster thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: richa1792

While I agree with everything that you have written, despise the deplorable acts that Ranveer is/has committed, I can't help but play the Devils's advocate here.

You see, Priyanka's crime is no less than Ranveer's. How easily we have forgotten that she is responsible for his sister being in a coma. His sister almost died because of her. And she didn't care. She wanted to save her own hide, so she hid behind the Oberoi name. How completely powerless he must have felt, him being an ACP, him being someone who helps people get justice. He couldn't get justice for his sister. He is just a cop and the Oberoi's are too big a name and power for him to tackle. This time, David doesn't win over Goliath.

I don't condone his actions, I understand them. I get where he is coming from. Imagine the only family that you have, that family is wasting away, fighting for her life. All because an entitled brat couldn't be bothered. Couldn't possess enough empathy to help the victim. Your blood boils. You want justice. That is what you are. Justice is why you became an ACP, why you wear this uniform. And if you cannot get justice, then fine. You'll get vengeance.

What is happening to Prinku is wrong. She is being raped in a way, yes. She has had her choices taken away from her, yes. But who is to say that she doesn't deserve it after the crime she committed, the life that she almost took? In fact, as good as took. Because wasting away in a coma like a vegetable is no life at all.

I am in no way supporting any romantic entanglement between the two. I have decided to view them as two individuals. One with a burning need of vengeance, with shades of grey so dark they are almost black. But this shade was forced on him. He was pushed down into this dirt. And another one with a vulnerable heart and mind. Bathed in white but if you look closely, stained with black marks. Needing redemption but having no idea how to even go asking about it.

That would be good conflict, drama that I would love watching.


TRUE. everything you have said is true. But for one thing. She confessed. she saw the inanimate body, she fell to her knees before him. And she confessed. He had his victory, emotionally, morally, according to the laws he upholds. He could have taken her in. Thrown her into jail. After her breakdown when she saw what she had done, he could have arrested her and she would have gladly paid for her sins. Expiated them, in the way his own legal system tells him the criminal must pay. Via the law.

But what he is doing is a criminal act. He caught her, but he's decided to toy with her like he is judge jury and executioner. Okay. I accepted that. I hate it, but I accept it. I watched and cringed as he stalked her, terrified her, followed her everywhere. And I hoped he would actually look at the girl he was doing this to, her almost crumbling body, her weakness, her pain and anxiety that has made her pay for three years already. Because things are not always rich=evil and poor=perfect. I hoped for nuanced storytelling. When he saved her from the goons, what was his motive? To safeguard her purity, her innocence and to prevent assault, yes?

Then what is this, if not assault?

This whole making her think she is pregnant, takin away autonomy of her body, making her almost suicidal-- this is emotional AND physical assault. This feeding her weird drugs-- making her either unconscious or unaware of the effects-- this is a violation that Priyanka did not do to his sister. And if he was powerless once --what power he has shown of late! Faking evidence, setting up a trap for a girl who is already willing to serve herself up to justice.Only that wont give HIM control over her fate, so that's not good enough. An accident, compounded by bad judgment does not equal slow, deliberate destruction of a woman's very soul and her family.

Shivaay, Rudra, Anika and even the older Oberois who are paying indirectly by taking part in this marriage were not the people behind the wheel. If he has suffered for his sister-- Om, Shivaay and Anika at least-- they are suffering for theirs now.And truly, he is a psychopath--because he caught the girl who was responsible and knows it was unintentional and a tragedy. He has stripped her of her innocence, made her a mother to a child she hasn't consented to. He Is taking her home, for his own brand of cruel torture, to pay him, personally, forever.This is beyond rage for his sister. What he is doing is so breathtakingly cruel, you cannot fashion a love story or an anti-hero out of assault and coercion.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".