Option 1 will bring more Shivika moments and most of these will be funny with lots of Nok Jhok. If OmRu too would be involved here, it will be a "Sune pe Suhaga" track like the previous detective scene (All 4 finding that girl of CD)
Option 2 will bring a contradictory side of SSO - he can sleep with Tia but Anika cannot? He cannot see Anika let go but has to marry Tia? And him being controlling by someone?? It's too not like SSO.
Redemption track can happen in other way. For SSO to forget his NNK obsession - why is have to do anything with Anika? Like Om, wht it cannot be only SSO;s self struggle? The "vaanvas' track they offered in promo can easily, beautifully brings the change in him.
When he is not an "oberoi' , he would have to do something on his own, has to make his own name - and has to live with all normal classed people etc. i.e. living in the real world being nothing -- ONLY THEN he can understand things, only then he can understand Anika's worth.
So, first option PLUS vanvaas track is what will make Shivika or SSO story a different one.