Was 2 years really invested in the development of IB?[VB Note:pg 11] - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

85

Views

8.1k

Users

44

Likes

233

Frequent Posters

Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: parthianglory.



GK had to edit thousands of scenes, by replacing the names of past characters from other shows with the names of characters from IB.

It's a taxing process, my friend. One that can apparently take two long, hard years.

😆



There is so much she could have done with a story of 3 brother's.I mean really shown what having a sibling means.But at the end it turned out to be a typical love story
Aria1234 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: .Avengers.

sarun had chemistry. Barun at his worst was tolerable. Nakul is cardboard piece. Or mayb his twitch of expression can't be visible in naked eyes.

Khushi had more back story than all gul ladies combined...stars hanging around her bed representing her , arshi bonding over parents and stars, khushi payal buaji maa bauji bonding. Anjali khushi, dadi khushi...many many thing.
[/QUOTE
omg I thought I was the only one who didn't think his acting was good. He was okay in pyaar ka dard but the stiff arrogant guy role was not right for him.His dialogue delivery is also a bit strange every time he talks it sounds like he is announcing something and I personally don't like it. Even the Lavanya-Khushi friendship was better than most of the female relationships in this show..I still don't really know why Anika cares about Shivaay...Even the 'I feel your presence' was copied from IPKKND.The only original characters in this show are probably Omkara and Jhanvi...rudra reminds a lot of NK.

Aria1234 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: Haruhi_Mo

when IPK came, people said Arnav was copied from Maan😆

when QH came, people said the male lead was copied from Maan & Arnav😆
when Humsafars came, people said Harshad's role was copied from QH😆

and today SSO has been copied from IPK and whatever else?!😆

and yes sorry i didnt know one needs 'intelligence' to even watch a show, what the hell are you doing here and not go for documentaries😆
i'm still to see a tv show which doesnt insult my intelligence?🤪 if there's such a tv show( i mean fiction shows here, dont start with your savdhan india or whatever else😆), kindly point it out to me please😳 and shut me up😛


and i would like to add that many here never even watched IPK or QH or even Geet, so please stop comparing😳 and even telling people here that your favorites are better, because many don't even care😳

as far as my IQ is concerned, i doubt i need a certificate of same from people here😎



It's not about which show is better,It is about how there is no originality at all. I have watched all three shows and I agree that all three of them have similarities but I believe that Anika-Shivaay is a total copy of geet IPK and QH.Some scenes are very obvious...especially the ones which they copy from IPK. IPK,geet and QH had their own charms which set them apart...I hope that shivika can do that too.

Humsafars was a total copy ...at least in the beginning which is why it wasn't too successful ,If Ishqbaaz wants to be successful they should bring in at least one or two new concepts. It's because we the viewers are settling for such mediocre scripts that so many people mock daily soaps
anjs thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#34
Let me be honest, I have never watched a full episode of IB, but whenever i did watch a few parts, i always had a deja vu moment with IPK...cause everything is so much similar...and now I read that she spent 2 years developing this 😕 what did she develop, its same as IPK...

But, one thing i have to commend her for, i dont know if its only her or the whole team (somehow i feel it was Nissar Parvez n his presence) but IPK was truly a class apart... it was a show that made me (someone who used to laugh watching a daily soap), into a deeply in love with the show person. so i count it as a huge thing

Arnav n his back story, Khushi and her back story. Anjali n her mental status n he rphysical incapabilities, Arnav-Anjali relation, Khushi's bond with her family, with the Raizada's...everything was so so unique which i have never seen before.

But coming to IB, i used to read the articles on IF, and keep reading how Shivika fight and the saw a promo where Shivay suddenly finds Anika cute...i mean i was like yeh kya ho gaya...

Now I am glad that i didnt waste my time watching this show, as Gul is someone you cannot depend on, for a good show. She looses her interest and then ruins her own show and characters.

What she did here to Omkara and Ishanya, she did the same to Akash-Payal in IPK, she couldve easily build a good story around them, but never did...All energy was spent in showing Rabba ve (ofcourse i wasnt complaining ) yet she wasted opportunities and talent.

Esp when she started planning her next show, that is QH, she slaughtered the golden egg laying goose that was IPK...
anjs thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: .Avengers.

sarun had chemistry. Barun at his worst was tolerable. Nakul is cardboard piece. Or mayb his twitch of expression can't be visible in naked eyes.

Khushi had more back story than all gul ladies combined...stars hanging around her bed representing her , arshi bonding over parents and stars, khushi payal buaji maa bauji bonding. Anjali khushi, dadi khushi...many many thing.



Thanks for mentioning that, I saw a few scenes and find him so unfit for that type of character but was scared to post it here. Even his pronunciation is so bad at times...i remember one scene i watched, where Shivay is teaching Anika to savor the cofee...the way Nakul pronounce 'Savor' it was so thirdclass, i was appalled that Gul didnt ask for re-take, esp since Shivay is supposed to be a refined man.

I still remember the way Barun used to make Arnav sound...even the way he would sit, the director etc would keep instructing him how to sit as Arnav, how to stand as Arnav. and here, such bad direction...who is the director...in IPK it was Lalit Mohan and Arshad Khan, both were too good.
Aria1234 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: anjs

Let me be honest, I have never watched a full episode of IB, but whenever i did watch a few parts, i always had a deja vu moment with IPK...cause everything is so much similar...and now I read that she spent 2 years developing this 😕 what did she develop, its same as IPK...

But, one thing i have to commend her for, i dont know if its only her or the whole team (somehow i feel it was Nissar Parvez n his presence) but IPK was truly a class apart... it was a show that made me (someone who used to laugh watching a daily soap), into a deeply in love with the show person. so i count it as a huge thing

Arnav n his back story, Khushi and her back story. Anjali n her mental status n he rphysical incapabilities, Arnav-Anjali relation, Khushi's bond with her family, with the Raizada's...everything was so so unique which i have never seen before.

But coming to IB, i used to read the articles on IF, and keep reading how Shivika fight and the saw a promo where Shivay suddenly finds Anika cute...i mean i was like yeh kya ho gaya...

Now I am glad that i didnt waste my time watching this show, as Gul is someone you cannot depend on, for a good show. She looses her interest and then ruins her own show and characters.

What she did here to Omkara and Ishanya, she did the same to Akash-Payal in IPK, she couldve easily build a good story around them, but never did...All energy was spent in showing Rabba ve (ofcourse i wasnt complaining ) yet she wasted opportunities and talent.

Esp when she started planning her next show, that is QH, she slaughtered the golden egg laying goose that was IPK...



I still consider IPK the best indian soap .The story was amazing and good thing the show ended before Gul could destroy it. It is the only TV show I have ever recommended to my non indian friends and the funny thing is that many of them have already watched it and love it.

Yes,the one injustice was the Akash-Payal love line it started off so well and then went down the drain.But everything else about IPK felt like it was well written. The whole Arnav's parents and Khushi's aunt connection was so shocking yet so believable...maybe IB will also show some improvement in the future
Aria1234 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: Haruhi_Mo


I'm really sorry but people are indeed comparing the shows, and some even associated intelligence just because people disagreed here😆
as if to like any show requires any kind of intelligence😛

and unlike you, i have never watched either shows, who is Arnav? who is Maan? who is Asad? i dont know them, i have never watched their shows, isnt it wrong for those who are forcing their views on us how Arnav was better? how Maan was like this? how Asad would react like this?!
You have watched all shows, and i respect your views, but why degrade those who dont have same views? why completely insult them?
😕



I'm sorry if you feel that I've degraded you in any way,it was not my intention. I don't want to blame anyone but the writers of this show...people would not compare if they didn't see such obvious similarities...I agree it is wrong to force views and I don't believe any of us are in the right place to talk about anyone's IQ...but it is very hard for fans of other shows to see such copies especially when this is not nearly as good.

It's like when a bollywood movie is copied from a hollywood one or a south Indian one . There will be people who have not watched the original and love the copy...but for the ones who have watched it is very hard to stop comparing. We should all be understanding and guys let's not fight...this is only a TV show😉
anjs thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: Aria1234



I still consider IPK the best indian soap .The story was amazing and good thing the show ended before Gul could destroy it. It is the only TV show I have ever recommended to my non indian friends and the funny thing is that many of them have already watched it and love it.

Yes,the one injustice was the Akash-Payal love line it started off so well and then went down the drain.But everything else about IPK felt like it was well written. The whole Arnav's parents and Khushi's aunt connection was so shocking yet so believable...maybe IB will also show some improvement in the future



Nissar Parvez was very much involved in IPK from the start, dont know if he involved here in IB. But i remember reading one of his interviews where he said, that in Geet they had mentioned about Maan having a past, but couldnt delve much on it. But then they really thought of a proper background story for Arnav, and kept hinting at it, through out the show.

As for Payal, she was suppose to be there only for Khushi to reach the fashion show to meet Arnav. And Akash wasnt even suppose to be there, but then they liked Payal, and kept her around and then wove something around Akash n Payal. That is how they developed them. No wonder there wasnt much story for them. Infact initially in one of the scenes Nani had mentioned about one more brother named Dhruv, but he never entered the show.

Same thing Gul picked up, about 2 brothers, and replaced Nani by Dadi and created a new show...so what is so creative about it...same ML thinking FL is cheap, low class girl...same FL becomes the manager of ML's house...later he falls for her...etc etc...
Mimi2609 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: Aria1234



I'm sorry if you feel that I've degraded you in any way,it was not my intention. I don't want to blame anyone but the writers of this show...people would not compare if they didn't see such obvious similarities...I agree it is wrong to force views and I don't believe any of us are in the right place to talk about anyone's IQ...but it is very hard for fans of other shows to see such copies especially when this is not nearly as good.

It's like when a bollywood movie is copied from a hollywood one or a south Indian one . There will be people who have not watched the original and love the copy...but for the ones who have watched it is very hard to stop comparing. We should all be understanding and guys let's not fight...this is only a TV show😉


see it's all a matter of how you put your opinions forward, and i agree with your points😊
but many have never watched the other shows either, why force these favorites on them?😳

finally ending on that this is just a TV show, a reel show, since when liking show or liking a couple proves your IQ?😆 or did me and countless others study for no reason, no offense meant to you here😳...



Flame. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#40
I just came back from an awesome party, full with happy memories and now I just now got to know Vrushika is leaving.
Don't even want to waste my words on Gul right now honestly because I am just so heartbroken. Was really looking forward to this story but sadly they messed it up for good.
I think I am out of IB now. No more interested. Lets see!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".