Amits limitations were very visible today - Page 2

Originally posted by: Pseudonym

it would be interesting to hear prashant sing something like bulla ki jaana though i don't know when that's gonna happen. i don't think any singer can sing every single type of song, different voice types are suited to different songs.

Originally posted by: mr_bond

Trust me Amit cannot alter his pitching.(it was 4 him i think that sonu nigam said "aapke high notes n low notes dono hi bahut strong hain...but i guess sonu was biased )He is a typical thick tuned singer. (wot does that mean???) Compare the tone of the songs he sang - nasha yeh pyar ka nasha, pahela nasha, Omkara, Tum kya jano, Chalchale and others- all sound similar.(4got 2 mention other songs 2) He lacks pitching versatility.(😆) Contararily compare the tone of songs Prashant sang- Ek Haseena thi, Ya ali, Rind Posh, Bheege Hoth Tere, Kaho na Kaho, Kuch na kaho. (singin different songs makes no diff if they r not sung well... n xcept rind posh mal n yes ya ali i dont think he sang most songs very well...was flat in most of them n off key) And don't forget the sharp falsettos in Bheege hoth, (which sounded wierd)Arabic notes (wierd again) in Kaho na kaho and the thick tunes in Ek Haseena thi.(off n flat) Compare the variety in the chords of these songs. He accomodated thick and sharp pitching equally well. Prashant is much of an all round singer than Amit, which Anu Mallik has figured out very early in the competition.(has he???) Lets see who can win the heart of the public- Prashant or Amit.(here i agree with u)

Originally posted by: addyydda

Trust me Amit cannot alter his pitching.(it was 4 him i think that sonu nigam said "aapke high notes n low notes dono hi bahut strong hain...but i guess sonu was biased )He is a typical thick tuned singer. (wot does that mean???) Compare the tone of the songs he sang - nasha yeh pyar ka nasha, pahela nasha, Omkara, Tum kya jano, Chalchale and others- all sound similar.(4got 2 mention other songs 2) He lacks pitching versatility.(😆) Contararily compare the tone of songs Prashant sang- Ek Haseena thi, Ya ali, Rind Posh, Bheege Hoth Tere, Kaho na Kaho, Kuch na kaho. (singin different songs makes no diff if they r not sung well... n xcept rind posh mal n yes ya ali i dont think he sang most songs very well...was flat in most of them n off key) And don't forget the sharp falsettos in Bheege hoth, (which sounded wierd)Arabic notes (wierd again) in Kaho na kaho and the thick tunes in Ek Haseena thi.(off n flat) Compare the variety in the chords of these songs. He accomodated thick and sharp pitching equally well. Prashant is much of an all round singer than Amit, which Anu Mallik has figured out very early in the competition.(has he???) Lets see who can win the heart of the public- Prashant or Amit.(here i agree with u)

Originally posted by: Pseudonym

it's not just about the voice.it's pretty difficult as it is sung at a pitch which makes it hard to sing without sounding strained (even with a light voice).

Well, Emon can. Not that it matters now

Originally posted by: mr_bond

Trust me Amit cannot alter his pitching.He is a typical thick tuned singer. Compare the tone of the songs he sang - nasha yeh pyar ka nasha, pahela nasha, Omkara, Tum kya jano, Chalchale and others- all sound similar. He lacks pitching versatility. Contararily compare the tone of songs Prashant sang- Ek Haseena thi, Ya ali, Rind Posh, Bheege Hoth Tere, Kaho na Kaho, Kuch na kaho. And don't forget the sharp falsettos in Bheege hoth, Arabic notes in Kaho na kaho and the thick tunes in Ek Haseena thi. Compare the variety in the chords of these songs. He accomodated thick and sharp pitching equally well. Prashant is much of an all round singer than Amit, which Anu Mallik has figured out very early in the competition. Lets see who can win the heart of the public- Prashant or Amit.

I think thats the reason they have Amit Vs Prashant. Both are equally talented to win. With Emon there wouldn't been a competition at all.

Originally posted by: Surkilla

Well, Emon can. Not that it matters now