Amit looked sad on Emon's exit - Page 2

and for me prashant is the winner to walk away with the title INDIAN IDOL 3

Originally posted by: r_tvfan

I would disagree that Amit is only there because of regional voting. If you noticed after Amit's avi almost all the people in the show who are from mumbai stood up and clapped. These same people have requested Amit to sing once more so many times. And not just that, if you look around the forum or even on Orkut, Amit's most fans are from the remaining states of India. I am included in the list.

Right. But how do you know that those Nepalese in Shillong voting for Amit only ?? Secondly it is true that Prashant is through only bec of Darjeeling and Kolkata Police and Army votings as his sister's husband is in Army. They just want to see him as II 3 thats all come what may.

Saying all that I still like his husky voice and he is sincere and wants to improve his singing and takes judges comments and tries to prove himself in next gala and has improved over time, and is a nice human being. It is not his fault but his people's fault to support wrong things and do injustice to the eliminated talented contestants who are definiately better than Prashant. He could have got out and come back next year after improving and getting some training. I am sure in his mind he surely must be feeling guilty for others act.

Originally posted by: r_tvfan

Well in his chat Emon mentioned that Amit is his favourite singer in the competition. And Emon occupied a place in everyone's heart excluding Javed Ji. Even Prashant didn't leave the stage immediately.

But I have to say the two guys lifting Emon was a very nice gesture. It was a recognition of the fact that this guy is a winner.

i agreee..it made me smile with tears in my eyes

GOING ON WITH THE SUBJECT..

yea..it was too cute when he carried emon like a baby..i was like "awwww" 😛 and yes even prashant was sad..for a min it luked liek he didn't believe it..

Originally posted by: anjalibc

Amit really looked sad on Emon's exit and so he came forward and carried him. He knows how good singer Emon is.

Now i want Amit to win. Because a better singer should win and not Regional Singer.

Your are right. I noticed that too. I am surprised at the reaction in studio. People reacted more on Emon's exit. They did not celebrate Prashant's coming into finals. In my opuinion, Amit , Emon & Deepali were definitely better singers but Prashant has the biggest vote bank. I think these musical contest results depend more and more on regional voting. Not on actual singing talent.

Originally posted by: r_tvfan

Well in his chat Emon mentioned that Amit is his favourite singer in the competition. And Emon occupied a place in everyone's heart excluding Javed Ji. Even Prashant didn't leave the stage immediately.

But I have to say the two guys lifting Emon was a very nice gesture. It was a recognition of the fact that this guy is a winner.

i agree i rellie felt gd at tht tyme but still ws very veryy upset

yep dat was a really sweet gesture on amit and prshants part...i think amit wud'v been upset even if prashant went out...but nay1 cud guess da putcome lookin at the videos's of fans.

Amit is unhappy because

1. he doesn't have a strong opponent now singing wise.

2. he has a strong opponent voting wise.

Originally posted by: Maya_M

Amit is unhappy because

1. he doesn't have a strong opponent now singing wise.

2. he has a strong opponent voting wise.

well said, especially the first part 👏 👏 👏 as i said earlier, for me the competition is over now, lets hope amit wins if there is something called true talent 😭 😭 😭

Originally posted by: anjalibc

Amit really looked sad on Emon's exit and so he came forward and carried him. He knows how good singer Emon is.

Now i want Amit to win. Because a better singer should win and not Regional Singer.

Amit was sad becoz he knew what was going on - he had lost a gr8 competitor - now he had to deal with that unfair PT !!