Ishpit/Abhash from VOI has thin voice - Page 3

Originally posted by: anjalibc

If you cannot accept the "truth" pl do not read here.

One person's truth maybe another person's lie. Its all relative. I have every right as a member on this forum to express my opinion and certainly will not take such instructions from anyone else!

Originally posted by: r_tvfan

I don't think anybody has a problem with the work he's done. He still remains one of the greatest lyricist and best scripwriters giving us scripts such as Sholay. And I'm sure he will continue giving us good lyrics.

But it is wrong for any human being no matter what position they are at to predict someone's future. What angers me is how can someone so learned and wise, contradict his statements and tell an 18 year old you will not be successful.

Just because he is a well known lyricist, does not mean, he gets the right to abuse an 18 year old. Yes as a judge he can judge his singing, but not his future.

And if the incident is scripted, then people will think even more lowly of him- a great lyricist who I'm sure earns enough abuses an 18 year old on tv for money. I personally don't think Javed Ji would do such a thing for money. He meant what he said. Even if he was having a bad day, being a celebrity he should know that it is wrong to vent his anger on an 18 year old reality show contestant.

I understand what you are saying. And I have no probs with people criticizing his comments over contestants...but to make derogaratory statements about him based on his profession and qualifications on being the judge on the show is insulting the man.

To answer your question. Yes it is wrong for one to de moralize a contestant but it is not wrong for him to express his opinion and criticize him. I personally did not like his statement either about Emon not becoming a playback singer. But just as you said its wrong to insult a contestant - I feel it is wrong on my part to undermine his ruling of Emon having a thin voice. He feels that way and has his reasons - so be it. I can agree or disagree but who am I to question his qualifications as a judge?