II3 presentation is a farce

mr_bond thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
lets discuss on today's show:

1. They forced all the contestants to vote someone out. And all the boys ganged up against Ankita. And Ankita voted against Emon. What impact does this make on their friendship? How long will the bitterness last?

2. They asked the studio audience to vote someone out and revealed that 50% of them were against Ankita. Poor girl how bad she might have felt? Thanks to her courage, she kept her heart strong.

3. When Emon was revealed as one of the bottom 3s, Javed was reminded of how he accused Emon of copying Sonu Nigam. And then Udit was blamed for Amit's fate by Anu Mallik. Poor Udit nearly burst into tears. God bless him. I mean what the judges are supposed to do if they are to be questioned about their judgement later on and blamed for someone's possible exit? Why hire them if their judgement is to be disrespected?

4. Why ask the judges to pick their favourites during the filming of elimination. They have already commented on their singing the day before. Why push the judges to be favourable for a certain contestant only to put sadness in the others' face?

5. Everybody needs to go, one after another. It feels bad when someone so close have to leave. But thats what the competition is about. But as presenters and judges why to show emotional inclinations towards certain individuals? Why to cry when one goes and not when another goes? Why not edit the excessively emotional parts and broadcast an entertaining show? I mean you can show all your love and intimacy behind the camera. Why waste so much time for showing sad faces and tears?

6. Why make the voting public the scapegoat and get them blamed for everyones' misfortune? I mean if you want to express your displeasure why not do it in a graceful and diplomatic way without hurting others?

7. Why to torture the remaining contestants and leave them full of guilt for someone's departure? And than why ask them to sing for the next gala only after few hours following the torture?

The result episodes are absolutely farcical. This II3 production team needs to learn few things about how to stage a better result show. The whole show is all about wasting half an hour to reveal an ousted contestant. Do the producers know anything about creativity? There are so many ways to make really interesting and entertaining fillers. Otherwise watch some UK and US versions of the past and get some idea. So much drama but nothing worth for an audience's precious time.

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1.2k

Users

11

Frequent Posters

ashi_mania thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
3. When Emon was revealed as one of the bottom 3s, Javed was reminded of how he accused Emon of copying Sonu Nigam. And then Udit was blamed for Amit's fate by Anu Mallik. Poor Udit nearly burst into tears. God bless him. I mean what the judges are supposed to do if they are to be questioned about their judgement later on and blamed for someone's possible exit? Why hire them if their judgement is to be disrespected?

I totally agree with this part....acco to Anu n gang...its like the others shouldnt point out anything that they disliked abt a certain performance coz then it leads to them coming in the bottom 3.....wat kinda logic is that.....agar aisa hain toh sabko praise karo.......or better still.....u urself go n declare ur fav as a winner....,matter ends over there only
RIPSI thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
Our Ankita was strong and calm and took the voting of her co-stars and studio audiance with courage. she was coooooolllllll. bcs she is the best. keep it up ankita we are there for u.
bhumi_130889 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
totally agree with you mate....they need inspiration...this was one competition where i thought everyone gets along and hopes for the best and would be happy if the other won...it was so different to the uk and US versions where everyone fought and stuff...but now they are causing conflict between the contestants and thats not fair...and its not fair for the judges to blame the public...the person evicted may hav onli lost by 1%...we dont know wot percentage the person goes out on so how is it fair to blame the audience...i think the judges and the producers have themselves to blame...and i also believe that this program may be slightly fixed...who knows whether they count our votes????
Vickrant thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
Your point no.3 reminded me of the crush controversy.... Alisha said Anu's harsh(personal)comments to Deepali made a negative impact and she got into danger zone cuz of it and Anu yelled and shouted at Alisha for accusing him for it and now Mr.Malik is doing the same thing Alisha did at that time.. strangely now he isnt yelling and shouting
Xigxag thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
I really agree with u there Bond on ur first 2 points. Ankita is a strong phenomenal lady I admire her for tht. The production really does torture her alot. Ankita we luv u!
xkcd_1 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: anvesha rulz

3. When Emon was revealed as one of the bottom 3s, Javed was reminded of how he accused Emon of copying Sonu Nigam. And then Udit was blamed for Amit's fate by Anu Mallik. Poor Udit nearly burst into tears. God bless him. I mean what the judges are supposed to do if they are to be questioned about their judgement later on and blamed for someone's possible exit? Why hire them if their judgement is to be disrespected?

I totally agree with this part....acco to Anu n gang...its like the others shouldnt point out anything that they disliked abt a certain performance coz then it leads to them coming in the bottom 3.....wat kinda logic is that.....agar aisa hain toh sabko praise karo.......or better still.....u urself go n declare ur fav as a winner....,matter ends over there only

in my nd only my opinion...i thot anu had been put in wrong lyt befr bcoz of deepali...nd 2 day i see him desperatly tryin 2 blame javed nd udit....tht ws just nt dun on prt of anu/......

starry_eyes29 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
And then Udit was blamed for Amit's fate by Anu Mallik. Poor Udit nearly burst into tears.

omg ..anu is such a hypocrite!!..he blames udit for his comments on amit and say its his cuz of that tha hes here in bottom 3..so none of the other judges can say wat they feel yet anu can scream at the top of his lungs and degrade sumone( liek he did to emon and others)..u no wat thas so dumb thurs only 5 ppl left and thurs 3 in the bottom 3 so obviuosly ther wud b sum one hu sang really gud in bottom 3 cuz they cud have been third highest in voting...i didn't like anikta but i must say yesterday she actaully sang gud with her natural voice and she moved around less and it sounded nice..judges shud b aloud to say wat they feel but it shud stick strictly to the singing and nuthing else..also ur rite they shud stop asking the contestants hu they think shud b out unless sumone sang really bad..as for the ankita thing mayb thur sying tha so tha ppl wud vote for her more..as for the judges they shudn't pick favs. cuz thas not wat thur here for..like its so clear hu alisha likes..anus always changing his fav...sad tha chang got out cuz i think he actauly sounded really gud to..to me prashant shud have gone..or emon cuz he wasn't singing all tha clear but emon has given better performances b4..this is soo crap wat the show does is it plays with ppl emotions..which is not rite becas it is a singing competition and thas it. and thas wat it shud b kept at..instead of playing games with ppl..
mr_bond thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
Thank you all. I wonder if others' want to have their say. Over to you guys 😊
.Lina. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 18 years ago
#10
I agree...da bitterness of da friendsship, rly shocks me.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".