deepali has not been that consistent - Page 7

Originally posted by: shrutibali

i am obviously comparing her to the other contestants in the contest...not just amit but also emon, ankita, puja have a better record than deepali..and i am saying that in general a lot of people say that she is one of the best contestants on the show...in that case her track record should also be one of the best which it clearly is not😊

There has been no instance when Ankita rendered better than Deepali. The judges are overhyping the performing Ankita and not the singer Ankita. If Deepali is being scolded then that is because her league is high and judges expect her to sing in that league. Had she been a mediocre singer from the beginning then she would have gathered a lot more wah-wahs from judges by now.

So Emon and Deepali getting criticised and mediocre singers getting praises doesn't mean that good singers faired bad compared to mediocres. It just means that good singers could have been better compared to their previous renditions.

Originally posted by: joshi23

For e.g. men like the fact that shes a 'fair-skinned' cute contestant compared with others like Puja who doesnt have her looks but a much better singer.

I feel sorry for great singers yet not so good looking contestants like Puja and Smitha. Why is our janta so superficial? Kiya hum goray rang se impressed he? yoon he? Kyoo hum kisis lari a sirf talent nahi dekhtay?

You girls should think about this and then you will love Puja much more than Deepali.

Deepali is fair and pretty? From which angle? She was not even shown on screen before piano rounds. I remember after hearing her for the first time members here started posting here with surprise and wondered where she was all these days? In my opinion Puja and Deepali have similar kind of beauty. Both of them caught people's attention through singing and not with fair skin or dance.

The only pretty and fair gal was Charu and she is already out.

Originally posted by: joshi23

Maya.

Me tumko bata raha hoon ke deepali ko 75% larke is liye vote dete he kyonke wo gori he....

Bhaiyya agar Deepali gori hai to mujhe kyon nahin dikhti?😕 Mujhe sirf Charu gori aur sundar dikhi.

kiya abhi tak tumkp hamarr larko ki mentality nahi pata?? unko deepali ek gori gori patni ke roop me dikhti he.

Aapko kaisan pata ki usko ladke vote de rahe hain? Yahan forum pe hum sab jo usse support kar rahein hain wo ladke hain kya?

Bechari Puja ko apni patni ke roop me nahi dekhtay.. isi liye usko vote nahi dete despite Puja being a much much better singer than Deepali.

I go for substance not looks.. Thats why I will always support Puja aur Ankita over Deepali anyday.

I go for substance too my friend. I will always support a good singer. Don't really care about channel games.

Originally posted by: shrutibali

wow so according to u the janta has a lot of charity money to waste on indian idol huh???? this is the best defense statement i have ever read😛

yea shurtii but i always hear same comment frm siddh towards Ankita..so it dosnt matter im happy richa aneja is out frm da v 1st epi..she didnt even deserve to reach piano round..

Originally posted by: anam k

hmm...well...her 1st song in the galas was...luka chupee...n only anu-ji had sum prob then 2nd was jub chaye mera jadooo...tht was awesum!...then in the 3rd gala she sang mera piya ghar aya...she was the best tht day...n in the 4th one she was goood...not bad!...n in the 5th gala...all the made up story was stamped on her!...4 no good reason...she was fabulous in all...atleast better than ankita...as v all r just used to listen all high rock songs from her...she has no voice...which was clear in her suraj huwa madham...n if u say tht amit is good i agree wid it...but can he sing any high rock songs...well simply it is NO...he can't!...

Moderators and fellow posters, Please take note. This topic is clearly about Deepali and everyone is talking about her merits or demerits, and this guy chimes in about how she's so much better than Ankita. For your Royal Moron-iness, let me just clarify that we are talking about Deepali's consistency not her consistency relative to Ankitas. Where do these people come from????😕

Originally posted by: siddh_v

Ankita is in this show by crap ok. She is here because judges and janta gave here charity ok. She never deserved to even make it to top 12.

Well, if charity is so easy to find in India, then I really wanna go to Cannes Film Festival and watch the Roland Garros in 2008. Anyone feeling charitable enough to pitch in on my vacation trip tincan.

Originally posted by: joshi23

Sorry Payal, but Deepal is not 'one of the best'.. she's simply not.

What has she done to be classifed as 'one of the best'?? She has sung badly in 3 out of 5 galas? I dont remember any of her piano round performances. She was completely pathetic and out of sur in the last gala. She's been reported to be involved with Chang and that has been openly discussed on Rubaroo several times. She has admitted to having a crush on someone after coming to Indian Idol.

All in all, she has been in the 'news' more because of singing-extrinsic factors rather than her singing. Yes she has a lot of fans and they appreciate her other characteristics rather than her singing. For e.g. men like the fact that shes a 'fair-skinned' cute contestant compared with others like Puja who doesnt have her looks but a much better singer.

I feel sorry for great singers yet not so good looking contestants like Puja and Smitha. Why is our janta so superficial? Kiya hum goray rang se impressed he? yoon he? Kyoo hum kisis lari a sirf talent nahi dekhtay?

You girls should think about this and then you will love Puja much more than Deepali.

But again, while you are saying she's more popular for extraneous factors, these factors shouldn't be used to evaluate her consistency. Deepali was the "Girl that could" from the beginning. Almost everyone of her fellow contestants identified her as the one to beat in the piano round, and their vocal trainer mentioned that he thought Deepa could be the dark horse who takes it all. And straight guy here, and he completely disagrees with your assessment up there. I would do Puja in a jiff, and putting Puja and Smita in the same category looks wise is wrong on so many levels, though nothing against Smita. Deepali's alright though she did look fantastic at the last Galas. The hottest girl was Harshida and she's there no more.🤢. So if there's one thing we can establish, its that we are not rooting for Deepa because she's so friggin hot, but because she is so friggin talented.

Originally posted by: madhy

yea shurtii but i always hear same comment frm siddh towards Ankita..so it dosnt matter im happy richa aneja is out frm da v 1st epi..she didnt even deserve to reach piano round..