deepali has not been that consistent

i dont why all judges say that she has been consistent

out of the 5 galas...she performed well in only 2

in the first gala...she was told that her singing was dead...then she performed well in the 2nd and 3rd gala....then in the 4th gala she did not perofrm that well and made the excuse that she had fever and stuff and now in the 5th gala she completely sang off key again

the only contestant who has been consistent is amit...and i would like to say ankita but i am not too happy with her song selection even though i am a fan

true..Deepali can never be indian idol..because of that..it can be only Emon,Amit or Ankita.

Originally posted by: shrutibali

i dont why all judges say that she has been consistent

out of the 5 galas...she performed well in only 2

in the first gala...she was told that her singing was dead...then she performed well in the 2nd and 3rd gala....then in the 4th gala she did not perofrm that well and made the excuse that she had fever and stuff and now in the 5th gala she completely sang off key again

the only contestant who has been consistent is amit...and i would like to say ankita but i am not too happy with her song selection even though i am a fan

ok now....in d frst gala it was only anuji who didnt like her singin or sumthin.....most of d ppl liked it

no issue bout d 2nd or 3rd gala....

in 4th gala alisha said ki she had fever hence she cud not "perform"....n plz stop givin it d name of excuse she didnt say ki mujhe fever tha....she said on asked by udit ji "sir meri GALTI hai mera galaa kharab hai"....now how much modest she can be....javedji n anuji liked her singin....n most of d ppl here n even my frnds liked it.

it was only n only d 5th gala in which everyone said ki she was not good nd even i agree....varna all d times ppl have found her good at singin.....itz only that at two of d times she didnt get 100% frm d judges.....even amit didnt get one time i thnk or maybe two.....n also ankita 2-3 times.......no big deal bout that.....par unki ki hui galtiyaan shayad logo ko yaad naa rahi ho.....

Ankita..never got negative comments ..please..and Amit too..

Originally posted by: yogsma

Ankita..never got negative comments ..please..and Amit too..

oh! come on....she did get in d last gala itself by udit nd alisha...nd in chamma chamma too by uditji....amit got by uditji in jhumru one....n i dun rememeber more.....i am not used to remember ppl's negative points coz i never tend to attack but yeah! i have to becum defensive sometimes for ppl like you.......

I think its unfair to judge someones performance entirely on the basis of the judge's comments. I personally think Deepali has been completely consistent. I thought she sang "Tere Bina" beautifully, the musicians made the song sound so flat, its really their fault, her singing itself was flawless.
And if anyone thought her "Prem Jaal" was bad...well no comments :p I thought it was awesome!
Personally I think Amit and Deepali have been the most consistent singer/performers that have shown the most versatility in their singing.

Yes i agree wid u! 😳

Amit, Ankita have been consistent rite from day 1!! Also parleen was consistent!😳

Even Emon has improved!😳

Take Care

Anoli

xxx

Originally posted by: Anoli

Yes i agree wid u! 😳

Amit, Ankita have been consistent rite from day 1!! Also parleen was consistent!😳

Even Emon has improved!😳

Take Care

Anoli

xxx

ok so everyone except deepali was consistent............well no comments then.

only her last perfomance was BAD
the rest were good... and consistency i believe is not measured by judges comments. the 1st gala was good not ouststanding but quite good(apart frm anu the other 3 judges didnt say anything bad and even anu's comments was weird cuz first he said the problem was sur then he changed his reason n said presentation then he said she didnt sing from heart ...he himself was unsure where she fell short) and the second and third gala performance was absolutely great. The fourth one is where she got mixed comments (now who in II3 didnt get mixed comments? even amit and ankita got it... amit got before nasha yeh pyar ka nasha and ankita got when she sang suraj hua maddham) and deepali's fast song..prem jaal.. the second one which she sang was genuinely GOOD
she went wrong with bahon mein chale aao cuz she couldn bring the appropriate feel to the song. And yes her last performance was not good at all... it lacked feel, she went wrong in parts of the antara. I really dont think she is inconsistent... she is truly TOP 3 material

Originally posted by: roadies_4 fan

oh! come on....she did get in d last gala itself by udit nd alisha...nd in chamma chamma too by uditji....amit got by uditji in jhumru one....n i dun rememeber more.....i am not used to remember ppl's negative points coz i never tend to attack but yeah! i have to becum defensive sometimes for ppl like you.......

They were not absolutely negative comments..and even Alisha praises her for her performance. Whatever may be the case..Uditiji was useless in saying negative against Amit for jhumaru..it was such a wonderfully done ..i dont think so anybody else other than Kishor da would have done justice to it..but Amit did so beautifully.He was second best to it after Kishor da...

In case of Deepali..you know her problem is song selection..she selects Lataji's songs..which nobody..NOBODY other than Lataji can sing better.
Luka Chuppi was absolutely dead singing..her voice is so good..but it never touches heart ..the way it touches for Lataji's song.