Puja-Deepali-Emon

These three contestants came to danger zone within first two galas. From different discussion thread here and from the judges remarks (specially Anu Malik) it looks like these three are the most deserving candidates and better than the rest. But even then they are failing to impress public (at least in term of votes).

What do you think the reason for this? Are they overrated? Why they are lagging to attract enough public attention?

itz quite strange no...the best singers always end up in the danger zone...

last season, karunya, amey and meenal faced the danger zone quite abit...they were the best singers...antara also came 2 times i think (if im not mistaken)

and now itz emon, deepali, puja and amit's turn (remember amit was even voted out!)

it's a sad story is what it is

Originally posted by: tpam

it is becoz of incompetent judging..
wen u priase an average singer u raise the bars from 4 to 7 out of 10

wen u say bad stuffs abt a gr88 singer u deduce the numbers from 9.5 to 7.5 out of 10!!!! soo stil gr88 singers remain better...

bt the judges tend to confuse public .. they never mention whether the performance was according to ur strength or weakness or overall.. more over both the galas on the result day they make such shocking faces that they hav never thot they can cum to bottom 3??? bt why dnt u set standards before hand??

i think this is kinda new style of judgement making public confused

ya you even confused me........😆

ya it is quite strange these three r the strongest contedors of II3..n see them in bottom 4 is quite shocking..not quite very shocking....i dunno y the public isnt voting enough 4 them..n i really dont get it wt they wnt 2 see in an II...i jus wanna say is..plzz vote 4 talent.. as my opinion in my pointofview i can see now smita n prashant r the weakest ones there..n deepali, emon, puja, abhishek n parleen r the strongest one..cant say bout ankita cuz she is not tht gd at singing by her grr8 performance people 4gets bout her singing ..well this is wt i think....ok all i wanna say is vote 4 the tru talent 😊

I think the reason for this is dat the fans of dese contestants mite have became overconfident dat since dese r the best, dey will nt get out, and due to dat are not voting enough for dem. I remember once suhit came in the botton 4, and got saved, however the next time his fans voted so much dat he dint cum in the botton 4. Wen fans start feeling dat their star is as it is too popular, they tend to vote less and due to this, good singers have to cum in bottom 4. 😊

ok but now fans know na ki they have to vote for RJ.....so plzzzzzzzzzz vote.... 😊

emon definately don't deserve for ii3.
ii3 must have following things:
1. good singing (which emon has)
2. good personality (no)
3. good attitude (no)
4. friendly (no, only with girls)
5. cooperative (no)
6. no leg pulling (he has)
7. smart as@/over smart (he has)
8. over confident (he has)
As annu ji has already revealed, "emon thinks that he is smarter than other contentent and which is very very danger"
I think he will be in danger zone in gala3 also. i'm not voting for him and i'll be working against him.
for me:
ii3 should be one of the follwing contenstent:
1. amit/chang/deepali/ankita/prashant
2. abhishek/charu/parleen
3. puja/emon/
4. smita

Originally posted by: tpam

it is becoz of incompetent judging..
wen u priase an average singer u raise the bars from 4 to 7 out of 10

wen u say bad stuffs abt a gr88 singer u deduce the numbers from 9.5 to 7.5 out of 10!!!! soo stil gr88 singers remain better...

bt the judges tend to confuse public .. they never mention whether the performance was according to ur strength or weakness or overall.. more over both the galas on the result day they make such shocking faces that they hav never thot they can cum to bottom 3??? bt why dnt u set standards before hand??

i think this is kinda new style of judgement making public confused

agree...wid ya completely...esp. the last line!!!!

Originally posted by: julee

emon definately don't deserve for ii3.
ii3 must have following things:
1. good singing (which emon has)
2. good personality (no)
3. good attitude (no)
4. friendly (no, only with girls)
5. cooperative (no)
6. no leg pulling (he has)
7. smart as@/over smart (he has)
8. over confident (he has)
As annu ji has already revealed, "emon thinks that he is smarter than other contentent and which is very very danger"
I think he will be in danger zone in gala3 also. i'm not voting for him and i'll be working against him.
for me:
ii3 should be one of the follwing contenstent:
1. amit/chang/deepali/ankita/prashant
2. abhishek/charu/parleen
3. puja/emon/
4. smita

And I thought Indian Idol was a singing competition..