ANU MALIK : Charu WAS In Sur!!! - Page 4

I woulnt agree with Anu Malik.... I thought Charu sang the song very well ..Infact I always like her sining as she always wants to make an impression and puts in lot of effort..Its visible.. She is pretty good..!

mein to chahti hoon sadi si charu aaj nikal jaye 😡

Originally posted by: macksaini

mein to chahti hoon sadi si charu aaj nikal jaye 😡

yeah i agree with i really want charu out and as u said sadi si b...............

I agree with anu/javed as well...but I guess his delivery could have been nicer but that's anu malik for you

Omg !!! Huzi has a competitor now 😉 😆

i felt charu was not as good as she was before...she was sounding strange 😕 ...anu was right..but he could told it in a nicer way..he was very rude!

If being in tune or having good singing abilities is a mark of a good composer, what would one call Beethovan?

Like Shruti and Tina pointed out, Anu pointed out the flaw in the performance and this is something which a trained ear picks up faster and better than an untrained ear. If Anu Malik had praised Charu, he would be blamed for not being able to spot a off key, and his ability as a Music Director would be questioned.

Originally posted by: rahman2005

What the hell does he think of himself!!!??? He's the most BESURA singer in the industry and he was saying that Charu wasn't in SUR!!!??? I'm sorry she was TOTALLY in SUR!!! She started very well, her song was just fabulous!!! Her performance was also amazing!!! She was definetely in SUR!!! And he was so rude to her!!! I just wish to SLAP that dog!!!!!!! I just hate him!!!!!! He should apologize to her for being rude!!! How can he say this about Charu who was ABSOLUTELY in SUR!!!???

Hey, first of all, mind your language....
Second, I completely agree wid Anu Malik...Charu might b a very good singer...but in the first gala, she was too bad, totally out of sur!

I think this was the first time in the history of II that anu malik gave a sound n right judgement . I agreed with him totally .Charu was out of sur no doubt .

Originally posted by: TinkyWinky

I'm sorry but I didnt enjoy Charu's perfomance at all.

I didnt like the way she sang and I thought she was lacking the attitude in the song.

Personally I feel she should be in bottom 3

IF U LOOK AT THE PERFOMANCE THEN U WILL NOTICE THAT CHARU IS SINGING IN DIFFERENT VOICES...THT IS NOT SINGING...SHE IS ALSO GOING FLAT AT SOME NOTES....AND I DONT AGREE COMPLETELY THAT SHE WAS OFF KEY FOR THE WHOLE SONG...I THINK SHE WAS OFF KEY IN MANY PLACES NOT ALL...