ANU MALIK : Charu WAS In Sur!!!

What the hell does he think of himself!!!??? He's the most BESURA singer in the industry and he was saying that Charu wasn't in SUR!!!??? I'm sorry she was TOTALLY in SUR!!! She started very well, her song was just fabulous!!! Her performance was also amazing!!! She was definetely in SUR!!! And he was so rude to her!!! I just wish to SLAP that dog!!!!!!! I just hate him!!!!!! He should apologize to her for being rude!!! How can he say this about Charu who was ABSOLUTELY in SUR!!!???

well my thoughts differ.. i thought he was rite.. i didnt like her at all today..

Originally posted by: iiLOVEyouu

well my thoughts differ.. i thought he was rite.. i didnt like her at all today..

I mean just tellme where her surs fell flat!!!??? The song is basically sung by a Male and she managed to sing it so well!!! I don't know what was missing for you but I thought she was amazing!!!

well ure just a biased charu fan...she was not at all good today...very nasal, out of sur...she could do so much better than this...

Originally posted by: *payal*

well ure just a biased charu fan...she was not at all good today...very nasal, out of sur...she could do so much better than this...

I'm a Charu fan but I'm not biased at all, I'm sorry, who are you to judge me and say that I'm biased!!!??? In the piano rounds, when Charu wasn't in SUR, I totally agreed with the judges!!! I agreed that in Piano Round she was for 1 song not in sur!!! But today I'm sorry to say but she was totally in SUR!!! Now that's my point of view, you can't say I'm BIASED!!!

Originally posted by: rahman2005

I'm a Charu fan but I'm not biased at all, I'm sorry, who are you to judge me and say that I'm biased!!!??? In the piano rounds, when Charu wasn't in SUR, I totally agreed with the judges!!! I agreed that in Piano Round she was for 1 song not in sur!!! But today I'm sorry to say but she was totally in SUR!!! Now that's my point of view, you can't say I'm BIASED!!!

who are u to call a music director stupid? there has to be some reason behind anuji's judgement...hes a music director, so he would know what hes talking about...i mean, im not saying one should agree with everything a pro says, but calling him stupid is uncalled for

I'm sorry but I didnt enjoy Charu's perfomance at all.

I didnt like the way she sang and I thought she was lacking the attitude in the song.

Personally I feel she should be in bottom 3

Originally posted by: *payal*

who are u to call a music director stupid? there has to be some reason behind anuji's judgement...hes a music director, so he would know what hes talking about...i mean, im not saying one should agree with everything a pro says, but calling him stupid is uncalled for

If some members on the forum can attack Alisha Chinai who has given some of the best songs in movies so even I can attack Anu Malik!!! I'm sorry!!! I don't want to keep talking with you!!! It's useless!!! I'm giving my view, if you don't agree, don't reply!!!

Oh yeh I'd just like to add that I dont know anything much abt Sur,Tal and Sargam and having said tht I still left tht she was off beat and her sur was wayward.

I dont knw much abt music but I could make out tht she's out of sur

Originally posted by: TinkyWinky

I'm sorry but I didnt enjoy Charu's perfomance at all.

I didnt like the way she sang and I thought she was lacking the attitude in the song.

Personally I feel she should be in bottom 3

Look that's a fair answer!!! She's not attacking me like nothing!!!

Well my bottom 3 is : Richa, Smita and I don't know because everyone else was good!!!😉