ANU MALIK : Charu WAS In Sur!!! - Page 3

Originally posted by: rahman2005

If some members on the forum can attack Alisha Chinai who has given some of the best songs in movies so even I can attack Anu Malik!!! I'm sorry!!! I don't want to keep talking with you!!! It's useless!!! I'm giving my view, if you don't agree, don't reply!!!

what is the point of a forum/discussion if everyone agrees with each other?

anu malik was right..charu was horirble today... i like her but today she asnt up to the mark...

Anu malik is not a singer so it doesn't matter if he is besura or not what matters is if he can detect sur or the lack of it in others....he has made all the leading singers in the industry sing for him so obviously he knows a thing or tow about singing...
By that yardstick then what is Javed Akhtar doing as a judge then? Has anyone heard him sing, so as to judge whether he is besura or not? So should only singers be judges? I believe that Anu Malik and Javed are there people who appreciate good music not as singers...
btw while i simply adore Charu and her singing i am sorry to say yesterday was not one of her better performances

Annu was sooooooo right 😊
nd none of da girls were gud today except ankita nd jolly 👏 👏

Originally posted by: rahman2005

I mean just tellme where her surs fell flat!!!??? The song is basically sung by a Male and she managed to sing it so well!!! I don't know what was missing for you but I thought she was amazing!!!

uh..have u ever heard the song???that song is 90% sung by a female..and another thing..i like her and i think she is very good but last night she was BAD...she sang one of my fav songs and totally messed it up while trying to give a good performance

Charu is a good singer but she was off-key , what the judges esp anu and javed felt was that the music was played in one pitch and she was singing in singing in a pitch different from the music which was true.
thats why she was off-key, the sur was good but her pitch and the music didnt gel at all.
bad song selection

Originally posted by: meenal_rox

i agree wid rehmaan2005.....ur totally rite....its not that im a Charu fan so im supporting her....but she sang very good....she mite not hav given her best today....but she didnt sing the WHOLE song off key...yea she went a bit off sur in the antara .....but not the whole song....she was in sur.....i dont agree with anu at all....and alisha was rite....she went off sur in one or 2 places not in the whole song....and Deepali rocked too today...so i dint like anuz judgement 4 sum of the contestants today!!

Thats because she didn't sing the entire song.

For me, she wasn't off key at all!!! What is most shocking is that he was rude to her!!! It was like he has some enemity with her!!! That's really unprofessional!!!

Originally posted by: rahman2005

For me, she wasn't off key at all!!! What is most shocking is that he was rude to her!!! It was like he has some enemity with her!!! That's really unprofessional!!!

thats just him and u shoudnt take these things presonally cuz they are all done for publicity😊

Originally posted by: rahman2005

For me, she wasn't off key at all!!! What is most shocking is that he was rude to her!!! It was like he has some enemity with her!!! That's really unprofessional!!!

personally i dont like anu malik myself i think he is biased towards girls he thinks are goodlookn (like last yr antara even wen she sang bad he wud say he sung well defyin sonu nigam) and he usually favours charu and for once i thot he ws being professional and admitting tht she didnt sing well....and he has said wen she sings well so u cant say tht...

dude just coz for u she wsnt off key it doesnt mean she wsnt...and for ur info tht song is sung 95% by a female and i didnt have to hear charu and shilpa's(the original singer of the song) to say she was off-key...but just to make sure i did and please she was totally off key javed akhtar's rite she sung it straight instead turning her voice at the points she ws supposed to...

dont get me wrong i like charu but she didnt sing well full stop theres nothing to get offended abt she didnt sing well on tht day so she didnt every1 has their bad days accept it dude chill out