Hey IIians..
We have the results of Judge v.s Judge Debates, Round 5 and 6 for you now...we know Round 5 results are overdue...but we were caught up with our own lives all last week, we could not get time to arrange anything...
Anyways the good news now is...that we have both last week's results, and this week's results with us...to make up for our lateness 😳
***********************************************************
Round 5 Results - Thanks to Lady In Pink (Eisha) for judging in such a short notice👏
Here are the results !
Let me start off by applauding all the contestants👏I enjoyed reading the debate.One thing i'd like to compliment you people on is that you kept up the cordial atmosphere that most often forget whilst debating. Great job!! However, the sms language was a bit inconvinient to read. I would have liked it better if the debates were in proper , punctuated Queens English.
Before I give my verdict, I would like to apologize in advance if my views hurt any of the members, because that is most certainly not my intention.
Without further ado, my comments;
This week's debaters are:
Anu's team - raunaq : I liked your arguments, they were quite convincing.....you used valid examples to further emphasize on your point, which strengthened the debate. You took part actively,argued with conviction.Rebuttals were great too, explanations were clear and persuasive. Well Done👏
Alisha's group - shahrukh fan : Considering the fact that it was your first debate, you did an good job. You were defending your point till the very end but somewhere I felt you got confused regarding what you were arguing for.It was as if though you couldn't quite realize which side you wanted to stick too. Despite all this, I liked
Javed's group - the_charm : You were active throughout and your posts were summed up nicely....though at times I felt you could have added more to the debate, had you used the help of examples your rebuttals could have been better.
Udit's group - chief saab : You argument made sense, yet I really cant comment much from the two posts that you made. I was hoping you had more to say.Please do not take my marks to heart, I have nothing against you-its just that i dont think its fair to judge you on the basis of one post while the others where continously countering arguments one after the other.
| | raunaq | shahrukh fan | the_charm | chief saab |
| Variety of Points | 9.5 | 8.5 | 8 | 4(lack of participation) |
| Providing sufficient proof and examples | 9.5 | 8.5 | 7 | 4(lack of participation) |
| Tact of dealing with the rebuttals | 9.5 | 8.5 | 7.5 | 4(lack of participation) |
| Was The Debate Convincing | 10 | 8 | 8 | 4(lack of participation) |
| Energy Level | 9.5 | 9.5 | 9.5 | 4( lack of participation) |
| Total | 48 | 43.0 | 40 | 20 |
Winner : Raunaq
Runner Up : Shahrukh fan.
--
Love,
Eisha
**********************************************************
Round 6 Results - Thanks to priya.nair (Priya) once again for judging another round for us, in such a short notice 👏
Comments for contestants:
This topic I know is a very difficult topic to debate as its human nature to tend to like someone and feel for someone's singing whatever the reason may be and the debaters have done a wonderful job in trying to reason this. Now to my 2 sense
Anu's team - RonnieK- This debater reminded me of actually Anu Malik. The way the debate was presented in a very factual manner and making sure to counter each and every argument was very anu like. Not to mention the energy level inspite of being sick and the pink shirt. Also made sure you had the final word with a very well summarized conclusion.
Alisha's group - ash_sabihey I guess this person was not available.Hope to see you debate in the future
Javed's group – nsheena Started with a very fine opening. Loved the way the logic and facts were coupled together and flowed well. Did have the signs of a good debator Would have loved to see more confutations as the points were pretty interesting and also a conclusion to tie up the loose ends.
Udit's group – xmuqix The opening statement to the rebuttals were very convincing . It felt that that what was being said was truly believed. Also had lots of confidence on what was being presenting.
| RonnieK | Ash_sabhiey | Nsheena | xmuqix | |
| Variety of Points | 9 | 0 | 8 | 7.5 |
| Providing sufficient proof and examples | 10 | 0 | 8.5 | 8 |
| Tact of dealing with the rebuttals | 9.5 | 0 | 9 | 8 |
| Was The Debate Convincing | 9 | 0 | 9 | 9 |
| Energy Level | 10 | 0 | 9 | 9.5 |
| Total | 48.5 | 0 | 43.5 | 42 |
Now to the best (rather hard) part . the winner is RonnieK and the runnerup nsheena.
**********************************************************
Join with us congratulating raunaq and RonnieK for winning the fifth and sixth round for Anu Malik's Team👏👏👏
Congratulations to shahrukh fan and nsheena for being the runner up👏👏👏
**********************************************************
To check out the scoreboard go here:
https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=617953
Get Ready for the 7th and last round everyone!
The contestants are:
bruno4 for Anu Malik
~Ouma*n*Eijaz~ for Alisha Chinoy
cute_zee17 for Udit Narayan
tabu for Javed Akhtar
Good Luck and all the best! 👏
Regards,
II Dev Team
Chat Clubs
Members Lounge
