reasons why karunya didnt win? - Page 7

Originally posted by: giggles_2005

And Sandy does???😆

yes he is

Originally posted by: IMPerfectionist

I'm not INDIAN not live in INDIA, though I watched it with pleasure. IMHO, AMEY DATE should be the winner. I liked KARUNYA in the beginning, but he's JEALOUS, OVER-CONFIDENT and does't have the PERSONALITY to be a PEOPLE'S CHOICE. He definitely has done more RIAAZ & has SUR, but don't forget he has a 'BAREEK/SHEER' voice also. I think a big factor is JUDGES UNFAIR APPLAUD and his PARENTS, specially his DAD's stupid moves. I hated all of these for this. SANDEEP is just a NEW AGE, NEXT DOOR HUMBLE GUY, he has SWEET VOICE & probably he can IMPROVE with time. I'm giving him OPTIMISTIC REMARKS because he's HONEST, SINCERE & very CARING.. not forgetting the right PERSONALITY to rule people's hearts.

SANDEEP enjoy your win. In fact, SONU brought up SOUTH issue so much that even if I could vote, I would definitely give it to SANDEEP because I'm not going to give it in SYMPATHY to KARUNYA for not being GOODLOOKING, or lacking the CHARISMA or being from SOUTH.

LOVE to AMEY… an ideal IDOL
👏

Originally posted by: IMPerfectionist

I'm not INDIAN not live in INDIA, though I watched it with pleasure. IMHO, AMEY DATE should be the winner. I liked KARUNYA in the beginning, but he's JEALOUS, OVER-CONFIDENT and does't have the PERSONALITY to be a PEOPLE'S CHOICE. He definitely has done more RIAAZ & has SUR, but don't forget he has a 'BAREEK/SHEER' voice also. I think a big factor is JUDGES UNFAIR APPLAUD and his PARENTS, specially his DAD's stupid moves. I hated all of these for this. SANDEEP is just a NEW AGE, NEXT DOOR HUMBLE GUY, he has SWEET VOICE & probably he can IMPROVE with time. I'm giving him OPTIMISTIC REMARKS because he's HONEST, SINCERE & very CARING.. not forgetting the right PERSONALITY to rule people's hearts.

SANDEEP enjoy your win. In fact, SONU brought up SOUTH issue so much that even if I could vote, I would definitely give it to SANDEEP because I'm not going to give it in SYMPATHY to KARUNYA for not being GOODLOOKING, or lacking the CHARISMA or being from SOUTH.

LOVE to AMEY… an ideal IDOL
👏

🤢 I am speechless!

Originally posted by: sreejan

That has to be one of the least intelligent posts I've ever read. I don't see how you can say any of that. I don't see how you say Karunya is a jealous, over-confident person. In case you don't remember from the finale, it was Karunya who smiled even after his loss. It was Karunya who congratulated and humbly accepted his loss. However, it was Sandeep who gave himself 20/10 points after a performance that was criticized by 3/4 judges (this was a in a previous episode). I don't see how you can call that new age, honest, and humble.

Also, The judges applaud Karunya because he has far more talent than Sandeep. He is younger and they are aware of the fact that he has a much brighter future in music than Sandeep does. The don't applaud him for no reason. They applaud him because he is better, and as judges, that is their job. People who feel pity for Sandeep because of this are ignoring the fact that judges have a job to do, and criticism may be a part of it. People have to be less soft and realize that the judges are just doing their job. They got angered when Amey was eliminated because they knew that he was more talented than Sandeep and Anuj.

Sure, Sandeep can improve, but so can Karunya, and Karunya is already better, meaning that with improvements, he has a limitless capability. Karunya is the younger, more talented singer. You yourself said that he has better sur. Everyone who says Sandeep is more likeable has to remember that this is a singing contest, not a likeability contest. In my opinion, Karunya was the more honest, likeable, and more talented singer.

Edited by thelittleman - 19 years ago

Originally posted by: sreejan

Originally posted by: IMPerfectionist

I'm not INDIAN not live in INDIA, though I watched it with pleasure. IMHO, AMEY DATE should be the winner. I liked KARUNYA in the beginning, but he's JEALOUS, OVER-CONFIDENT and does't have the PERSONALITY to be a PEOPLE'S CHOICE. He definitely has done more RIAAZ & has SUR, but don't forget he has a 'BAREEK/SHEER' voice also. I think a big factor is JUDGES UNFAIR APPLAUD and his PARENTS, specially his DAD's stupid moves. I hated all of these for this. SANDEEP is just a NEW AGE, NEXT DOOR HUMBLE GUY, he has SWEET VOICE & probably he can IMPROVE with time. I'm giving him OPTIMISTIC REMARKS because he's HONEST, SINCERE & very CARING.. not forgetting the right PERSONALITY to rule people's hearts.

SANDEEP enjoy your win. In fact, SONU brought up SOUTH issue so much that even if I could vote, I would definitely give it to SANDEEP because I'm not going to give it in SYMPATHY to KARUNYA for not being GOODLOOKING, or lacking the CHARISMA or being from SOUTH.

LOVE to AMEY… an ideal IDOL
👏

Originally posted by: thelittleman

That has to be one of the least intelligent posts I've ever read. I don't see how you can say any of that. I don't see how you say Karunya is a jealous, over-confident person. In case you don't remember from the finale, it was Karunya who smiled even after his loss. It was Karunya who congratulated and humbly accepted his loss. However, it was Sandeep who gave himself 20/10 points after a performance that was criticized by 3/4 judges (this was a in a previous episode).

And yet this isn't considered overconfidence or arrogance at all! 😕 Oh well, leaving aside all of this....although I agree that it isn't Sandy's fault that he won I just hope he doesn't turn into another Abhijeet who really is a nobody and who can't perform if asked to after a year! Anyways I think it's unfortunate that people can't see the purity in Karu's singing and personality likewise! It's so sad that people will never get to see it again at not on the II stage! However, the one thing that I would have to commend II on is the discovery of someone as WONDERFUL as Karu! Although he can't stay hidden forever considering that immense talent but I'm glad Sony gave the music industry the privelege to notice him and to be impressed thoroughly by him! You can't always rely on the junta to back you up and eventually have to rely on your talent rather than looks and that's where Karu will benefit and shine! So just coz someone says stuff like that about our gem of a person Karu it won't make it right....like they say even if you scream a lie from the top of a bldg it won't make it true! 😃