Same judges for II3? - Page 2

I want Mrs. P. Gill (Saba), Mrs. Date (Mallu) and Mrs. Sandeep (Kiran) as next judges.. wives of the rock stars wud know everything better.. so they shud sit 😃

Originally posted by: ani11

I want this dramabaaz,insensitive cruel judges out of II now because i don't want anyone else to face the humiliation that anuj and others faced.
Boo for the three judges 🤬

There is no matter of humiliation here.....If u dont do ur work properly u hav 2 hav the guts to hear criticism in ur face.....there is no point in giving false hopes.....only if they told Anuj wud he know tht he is not good enuf....jhoote tareef karne me kya faida hai??????They r veterans....u dont except them to say that the performane was gr8 when it wasnt.....they have always said the truth in the face and tht I think is the biggest plus point of the trio.....

They r judges....and they r doing their duty perfectly.......JUDGING not buttering the contestants........True Musicians can never say the singing is good when it isnt....woh apne imaaan ke khilaf nahi jaa sakte kyunki music hi unki zindagi hai.....there is no provision 4 sentiments in a competition

Originally posted by: xMrs. Datex

lol thankoo thankoo! i will take anu malik's seat n be d crappiest shayar! 😆

😆

Is it even possible to be a crappier shayar than Anu??? 😆

Originally posted by: xMrs. Datex

lol thankoo thankoo! i will take anu malik's seat n be d crappiest shayar! 😆

yeah and sabs can be the make up box - farah khan 😆

Originally posted by: sonu_nigamfan

There is no matter of humiliation here.....If u dont do ur work properly u hav 2 hav the guts to hear criticism in ur face.....there is no point in giving false hopes.....only if they told Anuj wud he know tht he is not good enuf....jhoote tareef karne me kya faida hai??????They r veterans....u dont except them to say that the performane was gr8 when it wasnt.....they have always said the truth in the face and tht I think is the biggest plus point of the trio.....

They r judges....and they r doing their duty perfectly.......JUDGING not buttering the contestants........True Musicians can never say the singing is good when it isnt....woh apne imaaan ke khilaf nahi jaa sakte kyunki music hi unki zindagi hai.....there is no provision 4 sentiments in a competition

U r rite the judges need to be honest. But if they have to be honest then tell them to be honest like how Simon Cowell is....he might not be a nice guy but atleast he recognises wat's good n wat's not and says so. With the judges in II, it's almost lik they have some kinda mental block against anuj.....its' almost lik they've decided tht they r gonna criticise Anuj no matter how he sings!

The Idol judges, on the one hand r sayin tht they have nothing against anuj, n then they say tht they want him outta the competition. And wat abt the walkout? Im an Amey fan, and i didnt appreciate the walk-out ONE BIT coz they treated anuj lik a nobody......they spoke as if Anuj is here only due to regional voting😕😕...as if he had no talent at all!

How would u excuse the walkout.....it's almost lik they didnt want anuj on teh show anymore. As judges isnt it rite for them to appreciate the format of the show? If they r so bothered abt the talent then they shd give these singers a proper break......wat did Anu do for Praju and Rahul----gave them songs lik 'hello madam'🤢🤢🤢

Originally posted by: buttercup

I want Mrs. P. Gill (Saba), Mrs. Date (Mallu) and Mrs. Sandeep (Kiran) as next judges.. wives of the rock stars wud know everything better.. so they shud sit 😃

i ll take Farah's place ...n actually show dem some dance moves 😆...Panna onez

Originally posted by: sonu_nigamfan

There is no matter of humiliation here.....If u dont do ur work properly u hav 2 hav the guts to hear criticism in ur face.....there is no point in giving false hopes.....only if they told Anuj wud he know tht he is not good enuf....jhoote tareef karne me kya faida hai??????They r veterans....u dont except them to say that the performane was gr8 when it wasnt.....they have always said the truth in the face and tht I think is the biggest plus point of the trio.....

They r judges....and they r doing their duty perfectly.......JUDGING not buttering the contestants........True Musicians can never say the singing is good when it isnt....woh apne imaaan ke khilaf nahi jaa sakte kyunki music hi unki zindagi hai.....there is no provision 4 sentiments in a competition

I was no talking about the criticisms,i meant the damn walk out😡.i used to adore sonu just like u but my opinions have changed now.i never criticise anybody unnecessarily.

Originally posted by: breathing_irony

U r rite the judges need to be honest. But if they have to be honest then tell them to be honest like how Simon Cowell is....he might not be a nice guy but atleast he recognises wat's good n wat's not and says so. With the judges in II, it's almost lik they have some kinda mental block against anuj.....its' almost lik they've decided tht they r gonna criticise Anuj no matter how he sings!

The Idol judges, on the one hand r sayin tht they have nothing against anuj, n then they say tht they want him outta the competition. And wat abt the walkout? Im an Amey fan, and i didnt appreciate the walk-out ONE BIT coz they treated anuj lik a nobody......they spoke as if Anuj is here only due to regional voting😕😕...as if he had no talent at all!

How would u excuse the walkout.....it's almost lik they didnt want anuj on teh show anymore. As judges isnt it rite for them to appreciate the format of the show? If they r so bothered abt the talent then they shd give these singers a proper break......wat did Anu do for Praju and Rahul----gave them songs lik 'hello madam'🤢🤢🤢

exactly my point.healthy criticism is good but to walk out on a contestant for no fault of his was🤬🤢🐷.i am not against criticism.

I agree that the walkout was a bit foolish...but I take it being musicians they r very emotional... They cudnt stand it when a singer like Amey got kicked out...especially when Anuj was in...It all happ at that moment....Sonuji went and apologized to Anuj after that.......

Yeah and u said it was like accepted that they had 2 give bad comments 2 Anuj....when did he actually sing well????
He got good comments from them 4 his munda punjabi if u remember....Sonuji gave him a big compliment when he sang ADA if u remember...and even 4 Fiza Sonuji said the song was difficult so his mistakes cud be forgiven......

Though I wanted to kick hi 4 singing a Sonu song so badly....Its not that he didnt get good comments.....He rarely sang properly....why blame the judges???????He has to face the truth.......he has a long way 2 go if he wants 2 be a singer tht too in Bollywood where there is no room 4 anyone imperfect......