Top 5 of II 1 Vs. Top 5 of II 2

Hi Friends,

So atlast we have the top 5. Now plz take a moment and compare the top 5 of Idol 1 with this years top 5.

Indian Idol 1:

Aditi Paul: great voice (i have just been informed that she was in top 6..so take it that way)

Prajakta: superb voice, great personality (my Indial Idol)

Rahul: OMG...one of the best voices ever

Amit: great singer

Abhijeet: The most complete package (truely deserved winner)

Now.....I am very sorry to say that this years finalists have been a big let down...U know, I didn't watch II 1, but just watching or listening them once gave me an idea that how talented they are....

But this year....apart from Amey and Karunya, no one is worthy of being in top 5 (Anatara is good but not my top 5)....lets see them

Indian Idol 2:

Anuj: I dont know why is he here...he is a good singer, but boy! does he deserve to be in top 5

Sandeep: again...a very mediocre singer

Anatara: hhmmm....well its ok if she is in top 5

Karunya: Fabulous singer...can be matched with Amit Sana (talent wise)

Amey: superb, outstanding, brilliant ... he is the one who is keeping II 2 alive....

But overall, I have to admit that top 5 of II 2 are not actually the top 5....bring back Panna, Meenal and may be Monali as well and we have a perfect Top 5

what do u say guys???

i agree with u on each and every count

aditi paul wasnt in top 5.....it was ravinder ravi in the top 5 of last years idol

You are right this year only Amey, Karunya and Meenal deserved to be there in Top Five. But sadly Meenal is voted out. I feel very sorry for her. And I fail to understand why Anuj & Sandeep are still there. Sandeep so far has not shown any improvement from his Day 1 performance. Neither does he have verstality!!!! And anuj dont know why is still there???

Well Aditi Paul was in Top 6 . We had Ravinder Ravi, who like Anuj and Sandeep shouldn't have been there.

if II2 top 5 was
amey
karu
panna
antara
meenal
then they wld b unbeatble 10000000000000000% better thn II1 bt the top 5 is nt tht!! 😡 😡

Well Aditi Paul was in Top 6 . We had Ravinder Ravi, who like Anuj and Sandeep shouldn't have been there.

Like Adit Meenal go out thsi time....

So wish liek Ravi next time Anuj or Sandeep will go....

I think Anuj got more support than sandeep...the order tehy r calling last 3 galas seems Anuj gets mroe votes...

Today top 5 is
Anuj
amey
sandeep
karunya
antara

Originally posted by: sumesh

Like Adit Meenal go out thsi time....

So wish liek Ravi next time Anuj or Sandeep will go....

I think Anuj got more support than sandeep...the order tehy r calling last 3 galas seems Anuj gets mroe votes...

Today top 5 is
Anuj
amey
sandeep
karunya
antara

i also think the same...

Well after Aditi Paul got voted off, I stopped watching the show, I just saw it. Get what I mean? Maybe not.

I think both Top 5 of II1 & as well as II2 have been pretty bad, IMO. If I'd have to pick, I'd pick II1 as a little better.

The Top 5 Indian Idol 1(SHOULD have been)
Winner: Aditi Paul
Runner-up: Amit Sana
3rd Spot: Rahul Saxena
4th Spot: Prajakta Shukre
5th Spot: Anyone.

Top 5 Indian Idol 2(SHOULD have been)
Winner: Antara Mitra/Meenal Jain/Monali Thakur
Runner-up: Antara Mitra/Meenal Jain/Monali Thakur
3rd Spot: Antara Mitra/Meenal Jain/Monali Thakur
4th Spot: Amey Date
5th Spot: NC Karunya