Amey sounded off key!!! - Page 5

Great!
I was thinking If i spoke about this today, I'd have bricks thrown on me by all the hardcore Amey fans.. I too generally like Amey, but yesterday i think he paid TOO much attention to the song, that he lost track of the singing. Agreed, that Daler put his might to that song, I really didnt think it suited Amey well.

I kept thinking to myself, was I the only one who thought he sounded loud and off key? Sonu seemed to like it, and i always thought he was one to give rite comments.

Can anyone agree with me that Ravi ACTUALLY did a rather fine job yesterday?? He sounded WAAAAYYY better than he normally does!

For once, i thought this competition is getting really tough!!

Originally posted by: marymathew

Great!
I was thinking If i spoke about this today, I'd have bricks thrown on me by all the hardcore Amey fans.. I too generally like Amey, but yesterday i think he paid TOO much attention to the song, that he lost track of the singing. Agreed, that Daler put his might to that song, I really didnt think it suited Amey well.

I kept thinking to myself, was I the only one who thought he sounded loud and off key? Sonu seemed to like it, and i always thought he was one to give rite comments.

Can anyone agree with me that Ravi ACTUALLY did a rather fine job yesterday?? He sounded WAAAAYYY better than he normally does!

For once, i thought this competition is getting really tough!!

yea but just ask anyone to sing rang de basanti and no one would even come close to amey's rendition! i didnt think he even made a mistake plus daler mehndi sings such hard songs that you shouldnt even compare amey to daler! and well ravi's songs are ALWAYS easy to sing so he gets no compliments from me

Originally posted by: Kadwiphool

yea but just ask anyone to sing rang de basanti and no one would even come close to amey's rendition! i didnt think he even made a mistake plus daler mehndi sings such hard songs that you shouldnt even compare amey to daler! and well ravi's songs are ALWAYS easy to sing so he gets no compliments from me

Wot makes u think anybody else cannot sing rang de basanti?😆😆😆

Originally posted by: fastlover21

Wot makes u think anybody else cannot sing rang de basanti?😆😆😆

i meant anyone else on indian idol only!

Originally posted by: fastlover21

yea but just ask anyone to sing rang de basanti and no one would even come close to amey's rendition! i didnt think he even made a mistake plus daler mehndi sings such hard songs that you shouldnt even compare amey to daler! and well ravi's songs are ALWAYS easy to sing so he gets no compliments from me

I don't think the problem was that song was too hard. Amey has sang harder song than that well. Problem was he tried to imitate Daler and failed at that.

Originally posted by: caldevil

I don't think the problem was that song was too hard. Amey has sang harder song than that well. Problem was he tried to imitate Daler and failed at that.

nah i dont think he tried to imitate daler i think he was just trying best to live up to the expectations and i think he definitely met those expectations!

^^May be but for me Karunya was better. He sang Nusrat Saheb song and not once he was off key. Karunya was the star of show last evening.

There was nothing in the show where other participants have said they cannot sing that RDB song 😆 😆 😆
kadwiphool, how did u come to know that no body else can sing that song at all?

Originally posted by: fastlover21

There was nothing in the show where other participants have said they cannot sing that RDB song 😆 😆 😆
kadwiphool, how did u come to know that no body else can sing that song at all?

i'm giving my personal opinion that no one in indian idol can come close to singing the song rang de basanti as good as amey did! maybe karunya but i think amey's the best when it comes to singing high pitches and also singing songs in one breath. THAT WAS MY POINT!

yahhhhhhhhh man i agreeeeeee......amey chose a bad song to sing thizzzzzzz time....i hope though he'll be saved cozz i luvvvvvvv him sooo much. he's maa fav from day one........god plzzzzz save amey....this is his first time low grade performacne ever........ppl must overlook it.....he's a great singer no doubt. luv amey 4 ever
mona