Amey sounded off key!!! - Page 4

Originally posted by: fastlover21

Don't just say judges know more than us.
Judges r human too and they are also baised sometimes to some singers.

i agree with what you are saying that they are also humans..but dont forget they have so much EXpierence...i am sure none of us have as much expierence as they do!!

Hello Siddh,

Now I understood how u became Goldie 😛

Arey Dilpe matle yaar, we all know u r Goldie, but that doesn't mean anything to anyone here, ever1 is same.

U were just blocked by Moderator for posting biased statements 😃

I know its hard for Maey fnas. I am sure Amey would bounce back with a superb performance next time

Sidh and other amey fans,
I don't want to annoy anybody or bad mouth amey. I was just expressing my honest opinion. He is better than most of the singers in II2. He really did perform well in the sense he danced well and tried to give his 100% which is well appreciated but he did not sound good singing that song. Being a true fan means understanding the weakness of your favourite contestant and not closing your eyes to his/her flaws. One can vote for him because he has a reputation of being a good singer, but the way he sang this time was not good, if he would have sung it in his voice it might have sounded better.
Cheers
Pragati

AMEY SINGING WAS AMAZING!!! like sonu every singer should experiment and i think amey did a great job!

like i always say VOTE A-SQUARED!!! AMEY-ANTARA! 😛

Originally posted by: sgr3

if you are an amey fan..you shouldnt post here...by doing so u are only making this post active...so amey fans ignorance is bliss

thats not true!..

i am a HUGE amey fan!.. and im definitely replying to this!

if you really are a true fan, you will notice a singer's faults.. and that includes amey's faults in today's gala!.. he was pretty bad!.. he was trying too much to imitate daler mehndi!.. he was sereiously shouting more than singing!.. buy since i am an amey fan.. i would still vote for him if i lived in india!... but you can't overlook the fact that he wasnt that good today!.. today, karunya was definitely the best and you cant deny that!

as for the judges.. i dunno what happned to them!.. how could they not notice amey's faults today!.. i mean im not saying i know more that sonu.. but yes i do have some knowledge of sangeet... im learning as well.. and could defnitely tell that amey wasnt very good today!.. and was genuinely surprised with the judges' remarks!

Originally posted by: pragatimanoj

Sidh and other amey fans,
I don't want to annoy anybody or bad mouth amey. I was just expressing my honest opinion. He is better than most of the singers in II2. He really did perform well in the sense he danced well and tried to give his 100% which is well appreciated but he did not sound good singing that song. Being a true fan means understanding the weakness of your favourite contestant and not closing your eyes to his/her flaws. One can vote for him because he has a reputation of being a good singer, but the way he sang this time was not good, if he would have sung it in his voice it might have sounded better.
Cheers
Pragati

coulnt have agreed more! 👏

Originally posted by: pragatimanoj

Hi guys,
I think amey sang horrendously out of tune. He was trying to sing in Daler's style but he was far from it. He is a good singer and should choose songs that fit his voice. This was a big mostake...and I can't believe the comments judges gave. If Ravi Tripathi would have sung the same song the way amey had sung it judges would have thrown bricks and stones at him.
Cheers
Pragati

I agree with u...it kinda sounded as if he wuz yellin..wasn't fun to watch like his other perfomances..

Judges are human too, today they cudn't comment anything bad abt Amey's performance cuz they know he is a good singer and that he shudn't b voted out.
Again we never know, judges may go back home, watch the recap and might change their decision 2morrow 😆
It happened to Karunya last time, Anu said he sang really good, then the very next day he said he wud put Karunya in bottom 3 cuz he changed his mind after seeing the recap 😉

Originally posted by: ILoveAmey

amey sang a risky song and did full justice to it and showed how versatile he is...obviously they would have thrown bricks at ravi, he cant even sing easy songs

hahaha 😆 i totally agree!!! sounds like the person who posted this is probably ravi's relative again! why even compare amey to ravi?! and he did fulll justice to the song, no one on indian idol can even come close to how well he sung such a hard song!

Moderator's Note: do you know that for a fact? please dont make accusations without backing them with full proof