Meenal and Antara..who’s more deserving. - Page 4

I think meenal is more deserving thn antara bcoz she proved herself several times even though she didnt get good comments frm judges in last gala bt i think she wasnt tht bad bt antara was jus k....
so I think Meenal should come forward... All the best to her

Originally posted by: vikksterr

It is pretty clear that irfa did not even bother to read what I have written in my post. Irfa, go read it. Agar english nahi aati theek se to batao..mein hindi mein type kar dunga tumhaare liye. Maine clearly kaha hai ki this is not a thread against meenal. It is a thread against ppl trying to put Antara down. And there are many thread like that? Khud hi dekh lo.

You have wrigten it That this is not against her, but You are inderectly letting her out. Why you are comparing her with antara. They both are compeletly diferent. Plz tell me who is comparing Antara with Meenal from Meenal fans side. Show me then the topics from Meenal fans, where they are talking bad about Antara.(it should be from Meenal fans)

It is pretty clear you also don't bother to read, because you have 2 times writen my name fault

Don't inselt my intelligence😡!!!!

Why are you going personally. Don't talk about my language, because if I become rude then that wouldent be soo nice at all 😡😡

please lets keep BOTH the girls from being voted out from the show.

meenal and antara fans unite to keep them both till top 4. vote for girl power 😛

SHAAN said in an interview(posted in the forum)that amey,karunya,antara and meenal are the best. 😊

Antara and Meenal are both good

But the better Singer is Antara. Because her singing has emotion, expression and feel to it!

Meenal is too stale! She has no screen presence AT ALL! Like Farah Said "she cannot connect with anything properly"

Meenal is neday more deserving...Antara gets sympathy votes cuz she keeps on sayin shez poor shez poor and dat where she livz is not on the world map plus she dint even feel her latest gala song unlike meenal who was really good!

Antara is a hack. She uses the "village belle" card real well. She is what I would call a "chust" ladki.

Meenal is a really good singer.

I think mini and aman are the ones whe keep bringing it up.even in the 'dadi episode' ,mini asked antara how her gaaon was reacting.I thought atleast in the last episode amar shd have shut up. 😡

Originally posted by: Shawn89

Antara and Meenal are both good

But the better Singer is Antara. Because her singing has emotion, expression and feel to it!

Meenal is too stale! She has no screen presence AT ALL! Like Farah Said "she cannot connect with anything properly"

i agree with u..antara is better den meenal. even i felt dat no emotion while she was singing the song "lambi judai" but last year wen i heard the same song from 'aditi paul'' it was really touched in my heart.

but meenal also a gud singer .

None..Amey is the most deserving followed by Karunya if anyone!!

MEENAL.. is definately more deserving than cry baby Antara..

Meenal has a better voice and can sing a wider range of songs compared to Antara.. I think Antara's voice is very thin and only suited for melodius songs.. whereas Meenal is a complete singer.. she can sing both melodius and dance numbers equally well