Meenal and Antara..who’s more deserving.

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Ifra

@ifra

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#21

I can understand want you are trying to say but I don't understand one thing.

People are making threads against Antara, but they are not always Meenal fans, And if there are Antara hate topics then why Anatara fans always attack Meenal.
Whats the Meenal fault yaar.

And talking about to be rude, I think this topic was very very disapointment for me.
comarison starts always from Anatara fans, Show me one tpoic of comparion started by Meenal fan

Quote

Ifra

@ifra

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#22

If one this indian forum are more Meenal fans then Antara thats not my fault or there either.
She deserve to have more and more fans

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Rohini Gowtham

@SLV3

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#23

In my opinion, both are good but Meenal got more maturity in her voice and sounds more professional than Antara. Antara needs bit more practice for singing high notes.

Quote

Purva

@purva

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 19 years ago

#24

To me Meenal is better than Antara. Though Antara's voice quality is very good........she tries to add lot of style to her singing, which affects her pronunciation. Which is not necessary I think.

But I surely hope to see both these girls along with Amey and Karunya in top 4. Come on people vote for girls as well. All boys in top 4 or 5 or 6 will be so boring 😕

Quote

Mukul

@gamezone

Navigator

Posted: 19 years ago

#25

I used to like Antara before. But now she has created a suspense in my mind. How can Antara be so fluent in English & Hindi even after being from a small village. Just look at other Kolkata gals, they speak Hindi with gr8 difficulty. Mujhe daal mein kuchh kaala lag raha hai.
No offence Antara fans. I too like her as a singer

Quote

devrat

@devrat

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#26

Meenal is more versatile and i prefer meenal over Antara. Well ok Antara is good, but i don't think she will make it to top 5 contestents.

Quote

vikksterr

@vikksterr

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#27

It is pretty clear that irfa did not even bother to read what I have written in my post. Irfa, go read it. Agar english nahi aati theek se to batao..mein hindi mein type kar dunga tumhaare liye. Maine clearly kaha hai ki this is not a thread against meenal. It is a thread against ppl trying to put Antara down. And there are many thread like that? Khud hi dekh lo.

Quote

2kool4u

@2kool4u

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#28

I personally feel dat der same as each other can't rely compare, bt i strongly thought monali was da best out of da gals, unfortunately shes out, so both r deservin 2 me.........

Quote

classyhombre

@classyhombre

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#29

i do not think Antara is a good singer. She is very ordinary. But she is getting a lot of hype from Anu malik & the public who is voting for her because Sony keeps talking about her being from 'Chotta gaon" etc.i think she sang very poorly on Monday.
I personally feel Meenal is better though I prefered Monali over both of them.That's my opinion.You can have yours.

Quote

radha

@radha_ruby

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#30

Originally posted by: vikksterr

We have more Meenal fans on this board becuz most of them can identify with her more than Antara. Cuz she's a city bred girl and knows exactly how to conduct herself becuz she knows her votes are going to come from ppl living in big cities and not small villages.

I TOTALLY DISAGREE WITH YOU THE WAY SHE CONDUCTS HERSELF HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH HER COMING FROM CITY.
SHE IS A VERY SWEET AND LIKABLE PERSON AND THATS THE REASON WHY?
YASHASHREE WHEN SHE WAS LEAVING SHE SAID MEENAL I HAVE HIGH HOPES ON YOU.
MONALI SAID SHE WANTS MEENAL TO BE INDIAN IDOL AND WIN
NEHA SAID SHE NOT ONLY SINGS WELL BUT ALSO IS A VERY GOOD PERSON.
ANTARA CRY AND STUFF IS CRAP SHE PRETENDS MOST OF THE TIME.
SO I GO WITH MEENAL DIGNITY WITH PRIDE AND SWEET VOICE.

Quote

1 2 3 4 5

Meenal and Antara..who’s more deserving. - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics