Update -7th Feb 2006 - Gala Results - Page 4

I can't beleive Monali is out. 😭 Voting is really screwed this year. How can Karunya be in bottom 3 when all judges were so impressed by him! 😕

There is something fishy going on. I mean the way the judges were commenting and then smiling makes me doubt that the comments are scripted.

Originally posted by: Shantibai

i am sorry to see Monali out
But this is the way of the aam indian voting public
And as long as you entrust the voting to them you are bound to find some himesh hypnotised lovers with mediocre choices who are simply out to sabotage the good quality of music that one craves for .....
After all Himmm ish (sing it like shreya )the Silken Rashmiyya with his 1000 songs per year contract of dishwater music needs some lousy singers from these two pools *Saregama ghol maal dhoom dhadaak dhin dhin dhoom and Indian Idiot 123) to churn out his brand of dishwater music to flood the CD market his supporters from Pakistan are funding 😉 😉

WELL SAID!😆 😆 😆

There is some weight in the suggestions that the results can be manipulated by organized calling.. why else would the best talent end up in the bottom three most of the times..

Amey bottom three last time??? someone would have won a HUGE sum of money had Amey been kicked out..

And now Karunya? He needs to be the semi-finalist with Amey in this one.. the others are there as eye-candy.

Don't blame Janta.. most of them don't care to vote even.. American Idol gets millions of call in votes.. why such a low call in volume for Indian Idol?

Originally posted by: aries_sakshi

cant comment on this statement.. but yup, it was weird to hear abt Ravi comments on karunya.. which was totally unexpected.

hmmm...something fishy alrite!!!!!...i am soooo sad for monali..i m sure she could have given us such rocking performances...had she stayed😕

well to be frank,i didnt like monali's performance at all yesterday and i considered her to be one of the weakest singers yetsreday,her voice was shaky throughout the song .As for ravi and sandeep...they have been selected through by the same 3 judges and people and they are now in final 12 so its not their fault that monali is out, afterall even they have come to win indian idol just like others.
they are giving their best and the rest is up to the people .Maybe when karunya gets so much praise from all judges,the people(his fans) feel that he will sail through and dont vote enough and the rest maybe vote coz their fav may be in danger coz their performance was not appreciated much by the judges
that how i htink it works
no offense but based on yesterdays performance i really felt that monalis going out was right

It is surprising that neither Anu nor Sonu thought that day.. What happened to them?

May be Tina can answer - they forgot music.. no??

Something wrong somewhere.. Many did not trust QAZI getting so much votes in FG but there was an wave of support for QAZI all around.. and how come this Ravi is never even in bottom 3 without having any support?

Without going into much details, I think at this stage 10 to 20 thoudand votes can make a difference. May be he /his family is investing the amount?

We will know when the competition gets tougher and it will be impossible to spend own money to get votes.

Originally posted by: tina59

well to be frank,i didnt like monali's performance at all yesterday and i considered her to be one of the weakest singers yetsreday,her voice was shaky throughout the song .As for ravi and sandeep...they have been selected through by the same 3 judges and people and they are now in final 12 so its not their fault that monali is out, afterall even they have come to win indian idol just like others.
they are giving their best and the rest is up to the people .Maybe when karunya gets so much praise from all judges,the people(his fans) feel that he will sail through and dont vote enough and the rest maybe vote coz their fav may be in danger coz their performance was not appreciated much by the judges
that how i htink it works
no offense but based on yesterdays performance i really felt that monalis going out was right

I think the problem is the format of voting. One person can send as many votes as possible. Hence, if you have money or some big shot is backing you, you can put 1000 to vote for you lets say 100 times. How fair is that? I think the restriction should be that 1 person can vote only once. I just cant believe that people like Ravi Tripathi deserve to be even in the galas. He should be kicked out. 😡 😡 😡
I will miss you Monali!!! 😭 😭 😭

I think this is right decision. Monali's voice had some kind of shivering....

I am glad others are still IN.