Mountain out of a molehill!

Anuj's re-entry seems to have triggred off a huge storm of controversies!!!!!!!!!!

I seriously dont see why this is taking such an ugly turn.Jolly being kept away was a tad unfair especially as she says shes fully recovered and fit.

But this does not have anything to do with Anuj.It was a unanimous decision to bring him back probably based on the judges opinion as well as the fact that amongst the other deserving candidates who were unfairly eliminated during the piano round,anuj may have scored the highest.

In any case...the decision has been made and we have to accept it.Anuj's presence is just going to make the competition healthier and tougher and this is good news.Now everyone will try real hard and the not-so good singers will be very obvious and come to front.

Also,think about Anuj.Its going to be so difficult for him to make a place in people;s heart.And imagine the mental tension the poor guy will be going throughWhat if the other contestants dont warm up to him and treat him badly??WE know how immature some of themcan be...

So people..please give Anuj a break and let the competition go on.Why should we fight amongst ourselves about this?WE all have our favourites and lets keep suporting them as well as appreciate good singing.

AS I say aways...may the best singer win!

You agree with me people??

Smi

You answered ur own question.

If Indian Idol was truly about singing we wud never even see Amey and Meenal in the bottom two.

101% agree with you SMI. I think Anuj needs a break. It's not his fault. Imagine how happy he would have been when he heard this good news 😳 . I'm really very happy for Anuj. As far as competition is concerned, I have all my trust in my KARU baby that he will excell in spite of Anuj's existence 😃 . Karu is confident and so are we and that's why we have no problem in Anuj's getting into the galas.

true...point noted..
i was also equally shocked about the results..
but this unnecessary controversy about anuj's inclusion seems to be taking an ugly turn..
what is said here does have an influence on people's minds..
so why shun a guy for no fault of his especially if he is a really talented guy like anuj?

with all the support from us if amey and meenal can be in bottom 3...i cannot imagine what anuj has in store for him..

what say?

anuj is an excellent singer and his vote out from piano round was unfair too but bringing him back without any competition is unfair to other singers like kshitij, dipreet, jyotsna, ritu because they too deserved to be in galas.

so i don't agree with the judges here.they should have conducted a round for those 4-5 singers and selected the best. i still like anuj because it's not his fault.

In yesterday's episode, I'm pretty sure Farah said that they had called 3 to 4 ppl for an audition in order to pick the "last chance candidate"...so I'm pretty sure they probably (or at least I hope)called back ppl like Dilpreet, Kshitij, Jyotsana, etc. and they must have found Anuj to be the best singer of them all.

It does seem a bit unfair considering that they replaced Jolly with a guy, but it's over and as smi has pointed out, it's really no fault of Anuj's...anyway, the janta doesn't seem to be focusing on "sur" enough, so the fact that Anuj is a great singer by no means guarantees he'll do well... As it is, he has come late, so ppl have already formed their opinions as to their favorites...IMO he has his work cut out for him...

But I think Dilpreet should have been taken back keeping in mind tht a girl was send off. that sld have made equal number of gilrs and guys and made the competion more interesting. And singingwise too Dilpreet was no less than Anuj. But when he is back and its the judges decision lets all of us give him a warm welcome.

I think very few are upset about Anuj coming back, we are upset about him coming back because of a) instead of a girl b) after 2 Gala's its unfair to those who have still managed to stick around.

agreed...but maybe anuj got the highest votes amongst the other 4 that you mentioned...and also the judges thought he was the best...we will never know..
but as you said..its not Anuj's fault that he was eliminated back then nor is it his fault that he was brought back to the show..
hes a good singer...and i hope to see him do well along with amey meenal and karunya..

Originally posted by: *Anjali*

In yesterday's episode, I'm pretty sure Farah said that they had called 3 to 4 ppl for an audition in order to pick the "last chance candidate"...so I'm pretty sure they probably (or at least I hope)called back ppl like Dilpreet, Kshitij, Jyotsana, etc. and they must have found Anuj to be the best singer of them all.

It does seem a bit unfair considering that they replaced Jolly with a guy, but it's over and as smi has pointed out, it's really no fault of Anuj's...anyway, the janta doesn't seem to be focusing on "sur" enough, so the fact that Anuj is a great singer by no means guarantees he'll do well... As it is, he has come late, so ppl have already formed their opinions as to their favorites...IMO he has his work cut out for him...

no anjali! anuj was told that there are others and he needs to compete with them but farah later told that 'you don't even have to sing as you are in default'. judges played the game to just see anju cry because it seems he looks cute while crying.