HOW DO U RATE FARAH KHAN AS A JUDGE - Page 2

Originally posted by: alishba_fareed

Indiaman I thing people listen Farah,s judge ment in last gala and forgot Anu/Sonu comments for meenal thats why she is in Last 2..... but from Know they will Properly pay attention to what Sonu said

I hope tht happens 2.But even I feel the public listen 2 Farah coz even in the case of Sagar the same happened.Meenal just escaped coz Yeshasree was tht bad.Good 4 her.But wonder wat Farah is thinking.Maybe she has some personal fav and she is trying 2 make them win.She is sooo biased yaar.Does she know tht this is a singing competition and not a fashion show

You guys said it all 😳 . I still don't understand one thing about Farha's judgement 😡 . In the boys' gala she advised all of them not to over-perform and said Sandeep and Ravi performed very well 😆 whereas Sagar and Karunya didn't perform well. In the girls' gala she praised Yashashree who sang pathetically and didn't make any facial expressions and said Meenal didn't perform well. I think something's wrong with Farha .

On the result night, she said Yashashree and Meenal were paagal to laugh to be in bottom three and Anu and Sonu contradicted her statement in a classy way by saying that to laugh in adversitites is great. Not everybody can do it. I think Farha 😡 should learn something from these talented girls and take some judging tips from Anu and Sonu.

I didnt like Farah last season & earlier this season but I think her judging has been pretty accurate. Farah is doing a great job! Go Farah!!!

Farah ji,s job in INDIAN IDOL IS TO PRODUCE AN
X- FACTOR & LOOKS.
SO SHE ALWAYS SAYS SHE CAN,T COMMENT ON SINGING.
SO SHE ONLY CONCENTRATES ON THESE ISSUES ,
MAY BE SHE DOES A GOOD JOB HERE.

Farah gets annoying with that same thing "x-factor" she needs to do way better then that, afterall she is a judge for indian idol. she's very repititive, and she annoys me alotttttt 😡

Also sometimes feel that x factor ke chakkar mein contestants are forgetting sur taal in order to impress the janta.

PlZzz Farah jee
ab ki baar kisi achay singer ki singing ko apnay X factor k chakkar mein nazar andaaz mat karna j sa Meenal k saath kiya tha.....
PErformance par comments dainay chahiye lekin Singing ki tareef bhi saath saath karni chahiye i she sings well...

I totally agree. farah needs to work on giving better comments. she can be very very rude at times but u hav to give a little bit of credit to her coz one of the reasona that amit sana and abhijeet sawant are so great performers is bcoz farah kept on nagging them abt x-factor. but still she is very rude. i dont get why she hates meenal so much

I agree that Farah gives some very insensitive comments which really puts a contestant down and makes her less confident of herself. Even I was surprised when Sonu & Anu praised Meenal, Farah did not comment on her singing, instead commented on her dressing and movements instead.

What has singing got to do with how she portrays herself on stage. Farah is supposed to listen to the songs the contestants are singing and not comment on things which are not related to the show.

Well Farah is commenting only on performance but she shud not give it more importance than singing.She is not bothered abt the singing at all.If the contestant looks good then she has been already won