My rating, whats urs? - Page 4

Hi all,
This is my rating based on the recap by varmap.

1. Panna
2. Amey
3. Karunya
4. Sagar
5. Sandeep
6. Ravi

Just saw the recap video posted be vermap.

I know it is unfair to judge them on the basis of 2-3 seconds clip of their performance but i am sure about no. 6 on my list. It's Sandeep. His performance was the weakest in my opinion.

And as Aditi said..........somebody tie his left hand 😡 In just 3 second clip his hand annoyed me so much. Don't know how i will watch his entire performance 😕

But i am looking forward to see rest of them perform. Then i will write my ratings 😊

My ratings are:

1. Panna Gill (must accept that he really performed well and performance in literal terms).
2. Karunya (Don't agree with Sonu and Farha. He was not as bad as they were trying to put him as)
3. Ravi Tripathi (surprised me)
4. Amey (not very outstanding)
5. Sagar (good performance)
6. Sandeep (poor performance and should have chosen a song with slightly high pitch)

purva yes it was very irritating, even ravinder ravi had the same thing , others also do but its not quite irritating

Originally posted by: aditigill

even with trouble in his voice, he did a good job.

My rating is:

1. Karunya - chak de

2. panna(suprisingly!!! he sang better).- jhalak dikh laaaja

3. Ravi(i thought he sang better than before).- jiya dhadak dhadak

4. Sagar - dhadak dhakada bnb

5. Sandeep- janam dekh lo... (his left hand should be tied)

6. Amey (why? i dont know didnot like at all) - judaaa hoke bhi mujhe mein aise baat hain

all of them together sang bheege hont tere. mallika joins the boys on the stage,

I think you either closed your ears or just put the TV off when Amey was singing because if that was the 6th position for you then you really need some understanding in music and singing.

No doubt Panna's performance was good even I agree, in my personal opinion panna is there by default not because of his singing capabilities but because he is the favorite among girls and he has the X factor. 😡😡

Please do give due respect to talent of singing as well.

Posted: 16 January 2006 at 10:10am | IP Logged

------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------

Karnuya was teh worst today....

She sorry he dont have a good personality at all....

If u have noticed his way of talking walking & dancing u will realise that he got a feminine character may be since he is pet to his dad as teh clip shows....

Sorry karunya fans but I have to say this as I feel a best singer cum performer with a good personality should be the winner...& Karnuya really disappointed me..I were checking him last special episodes onwards & that time I mentioned abt this....

Nw I cleared my doubt...anyways the way he shake his head & move hsi body...I think karunya fans know abt this fact & tehy purposefully avoid thsi defect as they saw his piano round performance only...In that very lesse shown abt him & he didnt perform too....

Today I feel he is the weak one ...even ravi & panna far better tahn him....

sorry karunya fans but check him carefully with ur open eyes not closed eyes....I am sure no karunya fans will agree to this...but if anyone missed taht point watch him tomorrow result show...check his talking walking style....

Edited by sumesh on 16 January 2006 at 10:27am

__________________
"Miles to go before you sleep!!!"


Harsh,

I've written this with lot's of pain because even I'm not interested to criticize someone without reasons and have never personally made any remarks. I did read some mssgs which are really disheartening. All that I can do is request ppl here not to make personal comments on somebody whom we don't know.

Sorry, Sumesh's mssg has been copied above by mistake. My reply was to Harshmm.

Sorry, Sumesh's mssg has been copied above by mistake. My reply was to Harshmm.

Sorry, Sumesh's mssg has been copied above by mistake. My reply was to Harshmm.

Well if someone is making personal remarks, thats their problem lovlina and not ours, its their shortcoming, thats all.
No matter what we comment here, the best will win anyway isn't it Lovlina?